@
JES
That is an interesting effect that you experienced from using N-acetyl-glucosamine (NAG) and the other anti-inflammatory supplements.
Your theory sounds like a good one: ie, that these anti-inflammatories are unfortunately weakening some aspect of your immune response a little, such that one or more microbial infections that are part of the root cause of your anxiety symptoms grow larger, so that although these anti-inflammatories help in the short term, in the long term (after a few weeks), as the infection grows, your symptoms actually worsen.
So far, this is first time I have heard of this particular response to NAG, flaxseed oil, etc. The reports I get back from people trying these supplements are usually either that (a) these supplements work very well for their anxiety and "wired" symptoms, or (b) they do not work at all. But this is the first time I have seen these supplements cause these negative and positive effects together.
Though I did consider the possibility that these anti-inflammatories could weaken some aspect of the immune response and thus promote an underlying infection, so I am not entirely surprised to hear your experiences.
The interesting thing about NAG is that this supplement reduces the Th17 (and the Th1) immune response
1 (or at least it does so in the context of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis). Now reducing Th17 is actually a good thing in the case of viruses, especially coxsackievirus B, as the Th17 immune response appears to increase coxsackievirus B replication,
1 and the Th17 immune response increases viral persistence.
1
However, the Th17 immune mode is important in fighting against certain microbes, particularly Candida albicans and Staphylococcus aureus.
1 So conceivably, although NAG may be reducing your viral load, it might just be increasing levels of Candida albicans and Staphylococcus aureus in your gut (though not everybody has the latter in their gut), thereby increasing inflammation. It might be idea to try NAG again, but in combination with some anti-Candida medications, to try to prevent any increase in Candida levels. But this idea is very speculative.
Also, theoretically, NAG may feed Borrelia bacteria (as discussed earlier in this thread), so if you in fact had Lyme disease rather than ME/CFS, theoretically NAG might make your condition worse.
The other anti-anxiety approach I would recommend, instead of (or in addition to) the NAG and the anti-inflammatory approach, is taking
NMDA receptor antagonist supplements.
Blocking the NMDA receptors on neurons was in fact my first successful approach to treating my anxiety symptoms.
You can find details of the theory and practice of using NMDA receptor blocker supplements in my thread here (see the section entitled "GABA and NMDA" in the very first post of the thread):
Non-Standard Anti-Anxiety Treatment
See also
this post in the above thread.
And you can what Dr Cheney says about the GABA and NMDA balance
here.
The basic idea is that overactivation of the NMDA receptor by glutamate (a neurotransmitter released during brain inflammation) is what over-sensitizes neurons, leading to anxiety and/or the "wired" state of ME/CFS.
So by taking supplements that block this NMDA receptor activation, you effectively reduce anxiety and "wired" symptoms.
I would suggest trying two or three NMDA receptor blockers in combination, particularly these:
Transdermal magnesium (as magnesium chloride or magnesium sulfate) applied to the skin all over your body. Magnesium is a potent NMDA receptor antagonist, but you need to take it transdermally, as orally you cannot absorb sufficient quantities. Transdermal magnesium is generally a good treatment for ME/CFS in general, and many ME/CFS patients use it. The method I use to apply transdermal magnesium is given
here.
Taurine powder 3 or 4 grams orally. You can buy bulk taurine powder very cheaply from bulk supplement powder suppliers such as:
purebulk.com,
www.nutraplanet.com,
www.myprotein.com,
www.bulkpowders.co.uk,
www.bulkpowders.com.au.
Progesterone cream (which is always applied transdermally), at a daily dose of around 10 to 15 mg of progesterone. This is another effective NMDA blocker, though progesterone does unfortunately also promote the Th1 response.
I have found that this NMDA receptor blocker approach to treating anxiety disorder is not quite a powerful as the anti-inflammatory approach, but NMDA blocking certainly does have a good anti-anxiety effect, and I often take NMDA blockers in combination with my anti-inflammatories, for an even better anti-anxiety action.
A third approach you might want to try is the
intranasal arginine method detailed
here. I found that snorting just 50 mg of arginine powder had a surprisingly good anti-anxiety effect. The intranasal route is a fast way to get a medication into the brain.