Hi Valentijn,
I think you wrongly thought that i have any issues with rational criticism with the previous statement i said, hence your reply above. I am fine with rational criticism. Nothing is perfect in this world, so there needs be more further analysis for better understanding. I have no issues with what you are saying here.
It's not pseudo scientific explanation. It's more unsubstantiated that that. It is just my personal belief only. Dots. Hahaha! I personally would doubt that there is any studies of such a sequence happening, even if it does actually occur, though i have not searched for it. Well, i do have my random unsubstantiated belief on possible mechanism, but it's random and not TCM related, so i'll just keep on topic track here.
Perhaps. Or perhaps not. I dont know. One way to know better might be to question Giovanni himself.
Goodnight all![Smile :) :)]()
Wintersky
I was simply pointing out that his perceptions do not constitute a reputable source of information. That was not an insult - it's a fact of life, and it's the reason that there are scientific procedures that should be used to sidestep our unconscious human biases. And I most certainly am allowed to rationally critique the methods which he is using to reach his conclusions.
I think you wrongly thought that i have any issues with rational criticism with the previous statement i said, hence your reply above. I am fine with rational criticism. Nothing is perfect in this world, so there needs be more further analysis for better understanding. I have no issues with what you are saying here.
This strikes me as another attempt at a pseudo-scientific explanation. I don't believe there is evidence of such a process causing a chronic illness to potentially start at a later time point. Can you provide an exact mechanism by which this could occur?
It's not pseudo scientific explanation. It's more unsubstantiated that that. It is just my personal belief only. Dots. Hahaha! I personally would doubt that there is any studies of such a sequence happening, even if it does actually occur, though i have not searched for it. Well, i do have my random unsubstantiated belief on possible mechanism, but it's random and not TCM related, so i'll just keep on topic track here.
While ME/CFS may potentially be a subset of fatigue or dampness, it is a very distinct subset with distinct symptoms and distinct pathologies. He has made a big error by labeling his chapter as dealing with a specific Western illness, when he is really addressing something much, much broader, where fewer than 10% of the patients in that broad category actually have ME/CFS.
Perhaps. Or perhaps not. I dont know. One way to know better might be to question Giovanni himself.
Goodnight all
Wintersky