Retrovirology Publishes Five Papers on XMRV and Contamination

WillowJ

คภภเє ɠรค๓թєl
Messages
4,940
Location
WA, USA
I don't quite understand how differences within the 22Rv1 cell line viruses could arise during PCR amplification but obviously this is important as the phylogeny results were the killer finding in the Retroviology papers.

I think it goes like this:

PCR is polymerase chain reaction. You can start with a small amount of genetic material (DNA or RNA) and keep multiplying copies so you get an amount large enough to do testing with. This is the point of PCR amplification. You put the genetic material and enzymes in a machine that cycles through stages with appropriate conditions for various stages of replication (copying).

You have a primer which will have a sequence of nucleotides matching the a unique (or relatively unique, and unique in your sample) sequence in a specific thing you're looking for (XMRV, mouse mitochondria, a criminal suspect, pGLO, a particular genetic defect, whatever). You can make any sequence you desire, synthetically. You usually have another primer for the other end of whatever you're interested in.

You put copies of the primer in with the double-stranded (or usually with doubled-over, depending on the virus) RNA (we'll say it's RNA because most viruses are RNA), enzymes, etc. You have a commercial kit which supplies the enzymes and such. The machine heats the RNA so that the parts where two strands (or two parts of the same strand) are bonded together, break apart (it's normally held together with non-covalent bonds, in this case hydrogen bonds). Then returns to a state where H-bonds are again allowed (and I think not too strongly). Now your primer can find a matching sequence on your target RNA and bind.

An enzyme called RNA Polymerase (RNA Pol for short; DNA Pol if it's copying DNA) is what copies the RNA but it can't start from scratch; it needs something to grab hold of (as it would have in a live cell situation). This is another reason the primers are useful. So it starts copying from the edge of the primer and goes until it falls off the end of the molecule.

Say unwanted parts of molecule are O, primer are P, desired portion D. (In real genetic material, you would see the sequence represented by the letters C,G,A, and T in DNA or C,G,A, and U in RNA), and matches would look like this:

3'CGCUCGA5'
5'GCGAGCU3'

For simplicity, I'm going to match like this:

OOOPPDDDPPO
OOOPPDDDPPO

please ignore the dashes (leading spaces aren't working) and spaces (not sure what makes those) and not-quite-matches

Starting DNA:

OOOOOOOOOPPPPPPPDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDPPPPPOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOPPPPPPPDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDPPPPPOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

First cycle: (green is the copy)

OOOOOOOOOPPPPPPPDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDPPPPPOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
-------------PPPPPPPDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDPPPPPOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO


OOOOOOOOOPPPPPPPDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
PPPPP
OOOOOOOOOPPPPPPPDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDPPPPPOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Second cycle: (purple is the new copy)

OOOOOOOOOPPPPPPPDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDPPPPPOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
-------------PPPPPPPDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDPPPPPOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

-------------PPPPPPPDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDPPPPP -------------PPPPPPPDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDPPPPPOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO



-------------PPPPPPPDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDPPPPPP
OOOOOOOOOPPPPPPPDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDPPPPP

OOOOOOOOOPPPPPPDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDPPPPP
OOOOOOOOOPPPPPPDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDPPPPPOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

With all these loose ends, you can get strands stuck together that you didn't intend. Maybe if you didn't select your primers carefully, you could end up with fragments, or maybe there's recombining RNA/DNA, and thus the variations?
 

oceanblue

Guest
Messages
1,383
Location
UK
With all these loose ends, you can get strands stuck together that you didn't intend. Maybe if you didn't select your primers carefully, you could end up with fragments, or maybe there's recombining RNA/DNA, and thus the variations?

Thanks, WillowJ; that's possible but how likely is it and how big an effect. And wouldn't it apply to everything sequenced after amplification by PCR, in which case it might apply equally to everything on the phylogenetic tree?
 

Bob

Senior Member
Messages
16,455
Location
England (south coast)
The Yanks are coming, the Yanks are coming...

In a fight against Americans, these red coats will all fall like toy soldiers. General tells Magua, "I want Weasel's scalp!" ;)

LOL, who shall we name the George Washington of xmrv/retroviology? Perhaps it's still too early to say.

It's a WAR!!! Silly brits, don't you know Americans always win?:mask:

lol

But this time there has been a mutiny against the British generals... The British footsoldiers have defected to the other side, leaving a small isolated group of desperate British generals standing alone against vast, and growing, American and British forces... I'm following the Yanks, led by General Mikovits!
 
Messages
96
Location
Chicago
when they found XMRV in prostate cancer the news were generally well accepted, but when they linked XMRV to ME/CFS is when the problems started, what I'm wondering is, did these people with prostate cancer have other health issues that haven't been mentioned? it would be interesting to know. Maybe some of them were ME/CFS patients to begin with..
 

free at last

Senior Member
Messages
697
Lol Bob, general Mikovits, colonel Alter, captain Klein.

private Wessley, private sharp, private white, Striped there ranks due to misconduct.
Myra mclure the prison officer shouts no freedom for these renegades. General Mikovits orders her capure first, through interrogation, she spills the beans,and proceeds to admit, they was never trying to find xmrv from the beggining, it was a dog and pony show, weres George, he might want to interrogate further.
 

free at last

Senior Member
Messages
697
The other side of the contamination coin is the potential for cell cultures used for producing vaccines may also be contaminated.
Maybe Sophia Mirza contracted XMRV after the vaccinations, and the variouse viruses she was exposed to then let all hell break loose,Or maybe she already had it, but the vaccines triggered it into activation ? I WISH HER SPINAL FLUID COULD BE TESTED BY jUDY AND Alter
 
C

Cloud

Guest
Maybe Sophia Mirza contracted XMRV after the vaccinations, and the variouse viruses she was exposed to then let all hell break loose,Or maybe she already had it, but the vaccines triggered it into activation ? I WISH HER SPINAL FLUID COULD BE TESTED BY jUDY AND Alter

This has been my view all along. Looking at risk factors, transmission possibilities, the different modes of disease onset, and my own experience, I believe contaminated vaccine is the most likely source.

My thoughts: Overachiever (chronic stress) is our dominant personality trait and supposedly xmrv loves cortisol. We have both clusters and isolated cases. Onset almost always follows Immune stress and trauma, but not always as an infection. And, we have government health agencies strongly resisting discovery of the cause of this illness. I did not have an infectious onset....it was triggered by stress and the Hep B vaccine. Since I had 25 years of excellent health prior to onset, whatever was triggered had most likely been there (latent) for many years. I believe I contracted xmrv one of 2 ways....vertically, or via contaminated vaccine in childhood. I lean heavily to the latter.



Dr Judy has suggested vaccine as a trigger:

"On that note, if I might speculate a little bit," she said, "This might even explain why vaccines would lead to autism in some children, because these viruses live and divide and grow in lymphocytes -- the immune response cells, the B and the T cells. So when you give a vaccine, you send your B and T cells in your immune system into overdrive. That's its job. Well, if you are harboring one virus, and you replicate it a whole bunch, you've now broken the balance between the immune response and the virus. So you have had the underlying virus, and then amplified it with that vaccine, and then set off the disease, such that your immune system could no longer control other infections, and created an immune deficiency."

 

Dx Revision Watch

Suzy Chapman Owner of Dx Revision Watch
Messages
3,061
Location
UK
As published by the ME Association, today:

http://www.meassociation.org.uk/?p=3628

Retrovirology summary of the first international workshop on XMRV

December 23, 2010

The open access journal Retrovirology has published a 23-page summary of the first international workshop on XMRV which was held at Bethesda, Maryland , in September. The authors of the summary are Jonathan P Stoye, Robert H Silverman, Charles A Boucher and Stuart F J Le Grice, and the event was co-sponsored by the National Institutes of Health, the Department of Health and Human Services and Abbott Diagnostics.

The abstract appears below:

Review

The Xenotropic Murine Leukemia Virus-Related Retrovirus Debate Continues at First International Workshop

Jonathan P Stoye , Robert H Silverman , Charles A Boucher and Stuart FJ Le Grice

Retrovirology 2010, 7:113doi:10.1186/1742-4690-7-113

Published: 22 December 2010

Abstract (provisional)

The 1st International Workshop on Xenotropic Murine Leukemia Virus-Related Retrovirus (XMRV), co-sponsored by the National Institutes of Health, The Department of Health and Human Services and Abbott Diagnostics, was convened on September 7/8 on the NIH campus, Bethesda, MD. Attracting an international audience of over 200 participants, the 2-day event combined a series of plenary talks with updates on different aspects of XMRV research, addressing basic gammaretrovirus biology, host response, association of XMRV with chronic fatigue syndrome and prostate cancer, assay development and epidemiology. The current status of XMRV research, concerns among the scientific community and suggestions for future actions are summarized in this meeting report.

The complete article is available as a provisional PDF. The fully formatted PDF and HTML versions are in production.

http://www.retrovirology.com/content/pdf/1742-4690-7-113.pdf
 

Dx Revision Watch

Suzy Chapman Owner of Dx Revision Watch
Messages
3,061
Location
UK
My thoughts: Overachiever (chronic stress) is our dominant personality trait and supposedly xmrv loves cortisol...

Woah, Cloud. I'm not comfortable with statements like this that make sweeping generalizations about "personality traits" and alleged association with, or predictor of CFS and ME.

Suzy
 

WillowJ

คภภเє ɠรค๓թєl
Messages
4,940
Location
WA, USA
With all these loose ends, you can get strands stuck together that you didn't intend. Maybe if you didn't select your primers carefully, you could end up with fragments, or maybe there's recombining RNA/DNA, and thus the variations?

Actually, I spoke too soon (good thing I wasn't talking to a newspaper :grin: ); I think the problem is more likely to be that while the Polymerase complex has a proofreading mechanism, in PCR you're in a cell-free system. But in the cell there are more proofreading mechanisms. So if a mistake gets past the proofreading, it won't be corrected like it would in a real situation.

With all these loose ends, you can get strands stuck together that you didn't intend. Maybe if you didn't select your primers carefully, you could end up with fragments, or maybe there's recombining RNA/DNA, and thus the variations?

Thanks, WillowJ; that's possible but how likely is it and how big an effect. And wouldn't it apply to everything sequenced after amplification by PCR, in which case it might apply equally to everything on the phylogenetic tree?

Yes, I have limited knowledge of various viruses and am going only off my general knowledge of PCR. Why it would affect one thing more than another I don't know. What he said was that it would arise from PCR, which was a general statement.

Not sure where a phylogenetic tree comes in? PCR is an artificial system. We run PCR, do some lab tests, and then when we're through put the materials in an autoclave (complete sterilization via heat and pressure), freeze for later testing, or otherwise safely and carefully dispose of them. We don't return amplified material to a live system.
 

Bob

Senior Member
Messages
16,455
Location
England (south coast)
Lol Bob, general Mikovits, colonel Alter, captain Klein.

private Wessley, private sharp, private white, Striped there ranks due to misconduct.
Myra mclure the prison officer shouts no freedom for these renegades. General Mikovits orders her capure first, through interrogation, she spills the beans,and proceeds to admit, they was never trying to find xmrv from the beggining, it was a dog and pony show, weres George, he might want to interrogate further.

lol

And don't forget private Reeves who has already been stripped of his rank and posted to do menial work due to associating with the enemy and general untrustworthiness...

Pity the poor prisoners if George is let loose on them! I can hear him growling already!
 

WillowJ

คภภเє ɠรค๓թєl
Messages
4,940
Location
WA, USA
The other side of the contamination coin is the potential for cell cultures used for producing vaccines may also be contaminated.

That's something that I agree we should look at: can we make our vaccines safer?

The problem is, the CDC's default "don't panic the populace" mode will never allow them to consider whether vaccines can be made safer (you cannot get safer than "already safe enough! end of story!").

Maybe the FDA and NIH can do this (check whether vaccines should and could be made safer); they have shown amenability to actual science and reason in recent months.
 

lancelot

Senior Member
Messages
324
Location
southern california
My thoughts: Overachiever (chronic stress) is our dominant personality trait and supposedly xmrv loves cortisol.
[/I]

yes, i am an overachiever, a perfectionist, type A, and i've worked very hard in my career, school, and gym. So are many of my high functioning friends and none of them have CFS. personality traits is not a reason for this disease. There is definitely a physical cause-possibly a smoldering retrovirus that takes 10-20 years to cause disease thereby affecting mainly 30-50yo. It's not like we can mentally or physically fight this disease. this disease is so devastating that it has knocked me to my knees and has broke my will.
 

Esther12

Senior Member
Messages
13,774
Woah, Cloud. I'm not comfortable with statements like this that make sweeping generalizations about "personality traits" and alleged association with, or predictor of CFS and ME.

Me neither. I'm a lazy slacker, but I'm still ill!

I thought all the stuff about 'type A' personalities etc were a result of selection biases: when doctors didn't like to give a diagnose of CFS it was only pushy patients who ended up being referred on to specialists.
 

Jemal

Senior Member
Messages
1,031
yes, i am an overachiever, a perfectionist, type A, and i've worked very hard in my career, school, and gym. So are many of my high functioning friends and none of them have CFS. personality traits is not a reason for this disease. There is definitely a physical cause-possibly a smoldering retrovirus that takes 10-20 years to cause disease thereby affecting mainly 30-50yo. It's not like we can mentally or physically fight this disease. this disease is so devastating that it has knocked me to my knees and has broke my will.

Yeah, I think the retrovirus is a large part of the problem. I also have the feeling it takes many years before it results in symptoms. I have had weird health issues for at least a decade and I am now 32. The telltale fatigue I got in december 2009. Before that I "only" had fibromyalgia and some other CFS symptoms. The fibromyalgia was manageable, as it was "just" minor to average pain. The fatigue, the feeling of unwellness, the non-refreshing sleep... that's crushing for me. I used to need only about 6 hours of sleep. Now I can easily sleep 12 hours a day and still feel like a wreck.

My first health issues manifested itself when I was seeing a woman who suffered from atypical MS. I am wondering if she might have this virus as well...
 

lancelot

Senior Member
Messages
324
Location
southern california
Yeah, I think the retrovirus is a large part of the problem. I also have the feeling it takes many years before it results in symptoms. I have had weird health issues for at least a decade and I am now 32. The telltale fatigue I got in december 2009. Before that I "only" had fibromyalgia and some other CFS symptoms. The fibromyalgia was manageable, as it was "just" minor to average pain. The fatigue, the feeling of unwellness, the non-refreshing sleep... that's crushing for me. I used to need only about 6 hours of sleep. Now I can easily sleep 12 hours a day and still feel like a wreck.

Sounds sorta like me. I'm 40 now, but was finally disabled by CFS at 37. In the previous year, one day i woke up completely unable to move due to exhaustion with horrendous unrefreshing sleep. this would last for a few days before i came back to normal. then, it repeated again 1x/month then 1X/few weeks and it was lasting longer and longer up to 1 week at a time. i quite work to rest up. i started sleeping +14hours/day(hypersomnia) but the unrefreshing sleep would never go away. After going to the doctor and being put on the poisin pill called cymbalta, i got much much cognitively worse and got insomnia as a result. one thing that didn't change was the horrible unrefreshing sleep whether i had hypersomnia or insomnia. after seeing 5 docs, multiple meds, treatments-accupuncture, TCM herbs, i went downhill fast and never recovered to any point before seeing a doctor. i quite all meds and doctors after 6 months, and i've been slowly getting better after +2years from 10% bedbound functional to 20-30% housebound functional now. I had no previous health problems and was a health nut and gym rat for the last 20 years. friends described me as the "healthiest person i know" now the "sickest".

What were your weird health issues prior to CFS?
 
C

Cloud

Guest
Lol, I knew there was a good possibility of getting jumped over the contaminated vaccine issue...but I didn't consider this one. You guys are completely misunderstanding me...and maybe I could be more clear. I think sometimes my writing is kinda confusing due to brain blur.

I didn't say anything about being an overachiever and stress causing or pre-determining ME/CFS. What I was trying to convey was that since stress is known to be one of the triggers of this disease, maybe it's activating latent xmrv. I think many would agree with that. Well, how did I get the xmrv? Early childhood contaminated vaccine makes a lot of sense to me. And maybe I had it from an early age but it was suppressed by my immune system until being activated (aka triggered) by stress, acute infection, or some other immune trauma such as another vaccine.

I've been at this a long time guys....I know the ropes and have a well deserved seat at this table. For 17 years now, I've been involved in real life education on everything ME/CFS and the political Goliath we have been up against for over 1/4 century? I've been side by side on many threads with you guys...but maybe you've still missed my story. Oh hey, lol here it is..... http://forums.aboutmecfs.org/showthread.php?7387-Okey-Dokey-Hokey-Pokey

as Lily Tomlin would say...And that's the truth
 

lancelot

Senior Member
Messages
324
Location
southern california
Cloud, don't do it again with your psycobabble! JUST KIDDING!!! HAHA!

i'm not truly convinced that mental stress is a trigger for this horrendous disease. for sure, a flu, infections, pregnancy, or other physical stressors seem to trigger or initiate this disease. but then again, mine was a gradual 2-3months with no stressors. so what was my trigger? maybe you don't even need a trigger.
 
Back