soulfeast
Senior Member
- Messages
- 420
- Location
- Virginia, US
If this is so as Erik says.. then the HLA type is less an issue? The toxins are not toxins without an inflammatory response in a sense?
Then that makes HLA type irrelavant? If so then what is relevant? What is triggering the inflammation if not the toxin and inability to tag it and get rid of it?
?? My husband also has a multisuseptable and has handled lyme and stachy exposure just fine so far. Played with mercury as a child, bitten my many ticks, has had to have plenty of exposure to biotoxins before our house had its experience.. ??? I am not sure he had the pesticide exposure I had as a child. I dont think he had as high a sugar diet as I did as a child, adult either.. xmrv???
Circulating toxins have to have a factor here. They have to have an impact.. do all HLA types identified by Shoemaker definitely not clear the toxins?
Then that makes HLA type irrelavant? If so then what is relevant? What is triggering the inflammation if not the toxin and inability to tag it and get rid of it?
?? My husband also has a multisuseptable and has handled lyme and stachy exposure just fine so far. Played with mercury as a child, bitten my many ticks, has had to have plenty of exposure to biotoxins before our house had its experience.. ??? I am not sure he had the pesticide exposure I had as a child. I dont think he had as high a sugar diet as I did as a child, adult either.. xmrv???
Circulating toxins have to have a factor here. They have to have an impact.. do all HLA types identified by Shoemaker definitely not clear the toxins?
Hey Dan,
Thanks for your wonderful insight (as always!). I've observed the same thing, and not just with chemicals. Some of the more-or-less healthy family members of severely-il patients in our Columbus clinic got tested for heavy metals and were FLOWING with them. I recall Dr. Klinghardt say we're the leftovers of human evolution in the face of an increasingly toxic environment. Metals/chemicals/mold are not the problem per se; the differential in reactivity to these is the problem. My father has a mouth full of amalgams (seriously). My mom and dad and their families all grew up and lived in Taiwan, which is a MOLD HAVEN with constant rain, typhoons, and humidity. Yet I am the first one that I know of in either family that has ever gotten this DD.
Of course, if anyone knew the answer to why the differential in susceptibility and reactivity, we wouldn't be here right now. We'd probably be popping a pill or looking into gene therapy that addresses "the missing pathway." But here we are, susceptible and reactive 24/7 to whatever it is that's innocuous to just about everyone else, and the question is what are we gonna do about it. Sure, the end goal is to have researchers look into it and find exactly how we can manipulate effective detoxification & normal reactivity to "?" mold and/or mold toxins, but in the meantime, some are taking a non-ideal path to resolve these issues, often successfully, and that path is one that challenges livability and what most human beings consider a normal lifestyle. It is what it is.
The jury's still out on whether this "extreme avoidance" will help a very small subset, whether any of these recovered patients have XMRV, or whether hypothetically if we had a bunch of patients with the means and the help to get "out there" a large percentage or all of them would have a significant response. Unfortunately, very few researchers and doctors are looking at this issue through these particular types of lens, but I know that a small group of patients, researchers, and doctors are trying to change this on a very grassroots level. It will take time, tons of it, and it may never come to fruition. So in the meantime it really seems we only have two options regarding extreme mold reactivity: we can take the roundabout way to find out or let it remain a very interesting thought experiment.
Another tidbit from Erik:
"I know it sounds crazy, but these toxins are apparently not all that toxic without the
inflammation.
Like the difference between someone who goes into anaphylaxis from bee stings and
someone who doesn't. If the extreme responder could somehow get the immune system
to calm down its response, he might conceivably go back to tolerating a few stings now
and then."