Ah yes right, they sad something about contaminating theyr old lab.
XMRV & Blood Supply Webinar Tuesday, Mar 29
- Thread starter ahimsa
- Start date
Ah yes right, they sad something about contaminating theyr old lab.
August59
Daughters High School Graduation
- Messages
- 1,617
- Location
- Upstate SC, USA
I heard the part about the caretakers and to add to it wasn't there verbage that indicated that caretakers had higher viral loads or antibody counts in some cases than the patient?
August59
Daughters High School Graduation
- Messages
- 1,617
- Location
- Upstate SC, USA
She referenced several people that she was working in conjunction with when referring to this high throuhput assay, but i didn't catch whether or not it had anything to do with BWG though?
alex3619
Senior Member
- Messages
- 13,810
- Location
- Logan, Queensland, Australia
Pathogens in the Blood Supply
New York Academy of Sciences Webinar
29 March 2011
Both Judy Mikovits and Ian Lipkin presented at this webinar. Lipkin's slides were not available, so there was no visual aid - but his presentation was on hunting pathogens, not XMRV specific. Judy was talking about XMRV detection and disease association.
These are taken from my hastily typed notes. Any errors are mine, and I cannot guarantee 100% accuracy. I have also had to interpret some of it, so I may have introduce bias - I hope not, but there is no substitute for listening to it or a word for word transcript.
Lipkin
Lipkin reported on intestinal biopsies in autism spectrum distorder, and they are finding a deficiency in enzymes for the metabolism and transport of sugars. Because of sugar alterations this may result in the dysbiosis that is frequently seen.
Lipkin was asked something like five questions, four were directly or indirectly about XMRV. He did not give answers that are very relevant to us, except for the upcoming study on XMRV. Three labs have been met with and had an agreed plan, the same for six clinicians. The hold up has been getting approvals, especially from Stanford and Harvard - but they should be ready to go soon.
Mikovits
Mikovits covered a lot of ground. Much of it is well known and I shall not report it again. I will however touch on the high points of the anti-contamination findings, even if is already well known.
1. They have measured high levels viral proteins from patients.
2. 30% of ME/CFS patients have two strains of viruses.
3. APOBEC3G induces G to A hypermutation, but while this mutates the viral RNA, the resulting amino acid sequence is frequently unaltered, and the virus can still be transmitted. APOBEC3G just reduces the viral load.
4. Diseases associated with XMRV -
mcl
thymoma (a thymus cancer)
melodysplasia
lymphoma
itp ( ideopathic thrombocytopenia, 50% in one study had XMRV)
cll
itp
5. All 60 cell lines at the WPI have been tested for XMRV and are not contaminated.
6. Something Lipkin had also noticed, copathogens can increase severity.
7. Patient contacts including caretakers have higher risk of XMRV so this might be considered as a screening criteria for blood donations.
8. A question about XMRV transmission noted that an implication of CROI is that XMRV might be airborne. This is being investigated, but is not proven.
9. Mikovits is talking to Dr. Lerner about XMRV and herpes virus interactions.
10. Mikovits describes ME/CFS as an Aquired Immune Deficiency.
11. A new high security lab may enable research they have not been able to do so far.
12. It was confirmed that Chronix have indeed claimed to have found fully integrated XMRV in ME/CFS, including flanking DNA on both sides of the virus.
13. Pathogenicity is not proven. However, it is suspected that antivirual methylation might be removed by epigenetic factors including those induced by the virus itself.
The rest of the presentation was not of much relevance to ME/CFS, but there was a long presentation on babesia which might be of interest to some. This is still ongoing, but I thought I would post as I doubt much of importance to us will be said in the remainder.
Bye
Alex
New York Academy of Sciences Webinar
29 March 2011
Both Judy Mikovits and Ian Lipkin presented at this webinar. Lipkin's slides were not available, so there was no visual aid - but his presentation was on hunting pathogens, not XMRV specific. Judy was talking about XMRV detection and disease association.
These are taken from my hastily typed notes. Any errors are mine, and I cannot guarantee 100% accuracy. I have also had to interpret some of it, so I may have introduce bias - I hope not, but there is no substitute for listening to it or a word for word transcript.
Lipkin
Lipkin reported on intestinal biopsies in autism spectrum distorder, and they are finding a deficiency in enzymes for the metabolism and transport of sugars. Because of sugar alterations this may result in the dysbiosis that is frequently seen.
Lipkin was asked something like five questions, four were directly or indirectly about XMRV. He did not give answers that are very relevant to us, except for the upcoming study on XMRV. Three labs have been met with and had an agreed plan, the same for six clinicians. The hold up has been getting approvals, especially from Stanford and Harvard - but they should be ready to go soon.
Mikovits
Mikovits covered a lot of ground. Much of it is well known and I shall not report it again. I will however touch on the high points of the anti-contamination findings, even if is already well known.
1. They have measured high levels viral proteins from patients.
2. 30% of ME/CFS patients have two strains of viruses.
3. APOBEC3G induces G to A hypermutation, but while this mutates the viral RNA, the resulting amino acid sequence is frequently unaltered, and the virus can still be transmitted. APOBEC3G just reduces the viral load.
4. Diseases associated with XMRV -
mcl
thymoma (a thymus cancer)
melodysplasia
lymphoma
itp ( ideopathic thrombocytopenia, 50% in one study had XMRV)
cll
itp
5. All 60 cell lines at the WPI have been tested for XMRV and are not contaminated.
6. Something Lipkin had also noticed, copathogens can increase severity.
7. Patient contacts including caretakers have higher risk of XMRV so this might be considered as a screening criteria for blood donations.
8. A question about XMRV transmission noted that an implication of CROI is that XMRV might be airborne. This is being investigated, but is not proven.
9. Mikovits is talking to Dr. Lerner about XMRV and herpes virus interactions.
10. Mikovits describes ME/CFS as an Aquired Immune Deficiency.
11. A new high security lab may enable research they have not been able to do so far.
12. It was confirmed that Chronix have indeed claimed to have found fully integrated XMRV in ME/CFS, including flanking DNA on both sides of the virus.
13. Pathogenicity is not proven. However, it is suspected that antivirual methylation might be removed by epigenetic factors including those induced by the virus itself.
The rest of the presentation was not of much relevance to ME/CFS, but there was a long presentation on babesia which might be of interest to some. This is still ongoing, but I thought I would post as I doubt much of importance to us will be said in the remainder.
Bye
Alex
August59
Daughters High School Graduation
- Messages
- 1,617
- Location
- Upstate SC, USA
He doesn't seem to be the least bit influenced by past research. He is solely focused on his task and stays neutral.
Caretakers? I dont remember anything about caretakers - maybe because its a term we dont really use in England in this context. Caretakers polish floors in schools and put away chairs.
I remember Mikovits said that she had shown that XMRV is a human infection because she had shown that it was mutated by APOBEC in the bloosd cells - plus all the antibodies to MLVs she had found in her patients (not just XMRV antibodies)
Please tell me this talk will be available on the forum - I didnt take notes because I was sure I would be able to listen to it again!
I remember Mikovits said that she had shown that XMRV is a human infection because she had shown that it was mutated by APOBEC in the bloosd cells - plus all the antibodies to MLVs she had found in her patients (not just XMRV antibodies)
Please tell me this talk will be available on the forum - I didnt take notes because I was sure I would be able to listen to it again!
urbantravels
disjecta membra
- Messages
- 1,333
- Location
- Los Angeles, CA
One interesting answer that Lipkin gave to the questions - he said the patients selected for their study would be selected to fit ALL the clinical criteria, and that they would go even further and have experienced clinicians' input on the selection, so that they would be most likely to get the patients with "highest risk" of having infectious disease.
urbantravels
disjecta membra
- Messages
- 1,333
- Location
- Los Angeles, CA
"Caretakers" = "carers" if you speak British English. Usually in American English we call them "caregivers." Dr. Mikovits didn't refer to caregivers per se, she talked about doctors and nurses being "contact controls" who often test positive (I *think* that's what she said) but don't express disease.
I see lots of problems here with people catching exactly what she said, because she was talking much, much too fast. That's a bad thing in public speaking; not only does it reduce audience comprehension but it tends to project less confidence and inspire less confidence in listeners, regardless of whether the person speaking is actually credible or not. Frustrating.
I see lots of problems here with people catching exactly what she said, because she was talking much, much too fast. That's a bad thing in public speaking; not only does it reduce audience comprehension but it tends to project less confidence and inspire less confidence in listeners, regardless of whether the person speaking is actually credible or not. Frustrating.
Sing
Senior Member
- Messages
- 1,784
- Location
- New England
Alex,
Many, many thanks for your summary! I would ask you, please, to spell out the acronyms here for certain illnesses:
4. Diseases associated with XMRV -
mcl
thymoma (a thymus cancer)
melodysplasia
lymphoma
itp ( ideopathic thrombocytopenia, 50% in one study had XMRV)
cll
itp
Urbantravels,
I think Lipkin said regarding using all the definitions that they will be studying those patients who most likely have an infectious "cause".
I suspect that Dr. Mikovits's rapid speech does communicate well with her scientific peers and audience here, but like you, my ability to track and comprehend all she said was hardly 100%. I still do not know what DNA methylation is, for instance, and feel that I should.
Sing
Many, many thanks for your summary! I would ask you, please, to spell out the acronyms here for certain illnesses:
4. Diseases associated with XMRV -
mcl
thymoma (a thymus cancer)
melodysplasia
lymphoma
itp ( ideopathic thrombocytopenia, 50% in one study had XMRV)
cll
itp
Urbantravels,
I think Lipkin said regarding using all the definitions that they will be studying those patients who most likely have an infectious "cause".
I suspect that Dr. Mikovits's rapid speech does communicate well with her scientific peers and audience here, but like you, my ability to track and comprehend all she said was hardly 100%. I still do not know what DNA methylation is, for instance, and feel that I should.
Sing
ixchelkali
Senior Member
- Messages
- 1,107
- Location
- Long Beach, CA
Aaarrrrgh!
Darned ME/CFS! I pre-registered for this, had it on my calendar and all, then this morning I did one of those CRASH - Timberrr! things with flu-like symptoms laying me out. Woke up hours later, all foggy and fevery, and realized I'd missed the webinar. Expletives!
Does anyone know if it was taped?
:In bed:
Darned ME/CFS! I pre-registered for this, had it on my calendar and all, then this morning I did one of those CRASH - Timberrr! things with flu-like symptoms laying me out. Woke up hours later, all foggy and fevery, and realized I'd missed the webinar. Expletives!
Does anyone know if it was taped?
:In bed:
anne_likes_red
Senior Member
- Messages
- 1,103
https://picasaweb.google.com/magnet...OfXMRVInBloodByJudyAMikovits?feat=directlink#
...Here's a link to Judy M's slides.
PS thanks Alex for your notes.
...Here's a link to Judy M's slides.
PS thanks Alex for your notes.
shannah
Senior Member
- Messages
- 1,429
From the CAA FB Page:
"Question submitted by another participant: Will the study use the Canadian criteria?
Dr. Lipkin's answer: The criteria we're using are very complex. They include all criteria published for CFS, plus additiional criteria established by the clinicians and laboratorians to identify group with the highest risk for an infectious agent."
.
I did not see the presentation (didn't know it was on or that it would be today! but had an appointment anyway and could not have made it.... thank you so much Alex and everyone for notes and comments, and thanks Anne_likes_red for the link to the slides), but between me and Google, it looks like these conditions:
mcl => mantle cell lymphoma
cll => Chronic lymphocytic leukemia
itp is a repeat of ideopathic thrombocytopenia
DNA methylation is "epigenetic information" or hereditary information not encoded in DNA sequences. It's a relatively new field of molecular biology.
When DNA is stored in the cell, it is packed up carefully. It's thought that methylation gives information about the DNA to tell information about what sort of info is on the DNA, how often to use it, or how tightly to pack the DNA, or maybe where exactly in the cell nucleus it should be stored.
DNA methylation is part of the solution to the problem of having genes very similar but organisms very different.
I went hunting for some links and this is what I found...
http://www.gate2biotech.com/the-epi...thylation-research-from-basics-to-biomarkers/
http://genomebiology.com/2011/12/1/R10
the background section is good; I didn't read the rest
nature issue focus on epigenetics (I didn't read the articles, just the editorial, but they're there if interested)
http://www.nature.com/reviews/focus/dnamethylation/index.html
DNA Methylation and Cancer (technical, chemistry, I didn't read it all)
http://jco.ascopubs.org/content/22/22/4632.full
http://www.molgen.mpg.de/~steinhof/vorlesung_ws0708/
(I did not open the powerpoints, but it appears that this might be useful if interested)
When DNA is stored in the cell, it is packed up carefully. It's thought that methylation gives information about the DNA to tell information about what sort of info is on the DNA, how often to use it, or how tightly to pack the DNA, or maybe where exactly in the cell nucleus it should be stored.
DNA methylation is part of the solution to the problem of having genes very similar but organisms very different.
I went hunting for some links and this is what I found...
http://www.gate2biotech.com/the-epi...thylation-research-from-basics-to-biomarkers/
http://genomebiology.com/2011/12/1/R10
the background section is good; I didn't read the rest
nature issue focus on epigenetics (I didn't read the articles, just the editorial, but they're there if interested)
http://www.nature.com/reviews/focus/dnamethylation/index.html
DNA Methylation and Cancer (technical, chemistry, I didn't read it all)
http://jco.ascopubs.org/content/22/22/4632.full
http://www.molgen.mpg.de/~steinhof/vorlesung_ws0708/
(I did not open the powerpoints, but it appears that this might be useful if interested)
Sing
Senior Member
- Messages
- 1,784
- Location
- New England
Thank you, Willow! I will try to dig into that information. I remember a NOVA show on epigenetics several years ago, I think, which showed how environment and experience could modify genetic instructions via the modified copies of the DNA called epigenetic material. Did I get that right?
that's probably close to right. we didn't talk a lot in my classes about how epigentic info was modified except during meiosis. however I believe environment and happenings can modify genetic instructions... either through a traditional mutation (changing the DNA sequence) or through changing epigenetic info (such as methylation patterns).
The DNA with changed instructions (either because the DNA itself is mutated in the strand itself, or because the info ON but not part of the DNA, has changed... epi- meaning "on" or "upon", and referring to histones, methylation patterns, and other info that is not located on the DNA strand itself but is part of the packaging upon and around it) can be part of mitosis and result in more cells with similarly-changed instructions.
This can either be a part of normal development as differentiation takes place and cells learn what tissue or organ they are to become, or it can be part of a cancer or other disease when there is a wrong change that takes place.
Here's a nice graphic (grey spheres evidently represent sets of histones; you can see the histone tails with methylations and various functions of different methylation patterns):
http://www.cellsignal.com/reference/pathway/Histone_Methylation.html
More graphics showing histones with histone tails, and how DNA is compacted and stored:
http://www.answers.com/topic/nucleosome
These are maybe more understandable about how DNA is compacted and stored, but lack showing the histone tails:
http://www.accessexcellence.org/RC/VL/GG/ecb/chromatin_packing.php
http://biology-today.com/cell-biology/ultrastructure-of-chromosome/
a methyl is a -CH3 group, and it must give different info based on what amino acid in the histone tail (which is a protein) it's attached to (and related to what other aminos are nearby), as this would affect what sorts of activating and silencing proteins could bind there.
The DNA with changed instructions (either because the DNA itself is mutated in the strand itself, or because the info ON but not part of the DNA, has changed... epi- meaning "on" or "upon", and referring to histones, methylation patterns, and other info that is not located on the DNA strand itself but is part of the packaging upon and around it) can be part of mitosis and result in more cells with similarly-changed instructions.
This can either be a part of normal development as differentiation takes place and cells learn what tissue or organ they are to become, or it can be part of a cancer or other disease when there is a wrong change that takes place.
Here's a nice graphic (grey spheres evidently represent sets of histones; you can see the histone tails with methylations and various functions of different methylation patterns):
http://www.cellsignal.com/reference/pathway/Histone_Methylation.html
More graphics showing histones with histone tails, and how DNA is compacted and stored:
http://www.answers.com/topic/nucleosome
These are maybe more understandable about how DNA is compacted and stored, but lack showing the histone tails:
http://www.accessexcellence.org/RC/VL/GG/ecb/chromatin_packing.php
http://biology-today.com/cell-biology/ultrastructure-of-chromosome/
a methyl is a -CH3 group, and it must give different info based on what amino acid in the histone tail (which is a protein) it's attached to (and related to what other aminos are nearby), as this would affect what sorts of activating and silencing proteins could bind there.
ixchelkali
Senior Member
- Messages
- 1,107
- Location
- Long Beach, CA
Thanks for the link, Anne.
I noticed Judy Mikovits talked about clearing XMRV from the blood supply by using the Intercept Blood System. I wonder if this is part of the "translational" research collaborations she's going to be working on. Here's a link to her Intercept Blood System & XMRV poster at the AABB Annual Meeting last October: http://www.interceptbloodsystem.com/documents/2010_AABB_Mikovits.pdf . And wasn't that what Dr Alter was talking about when he inadvertantly leaked the news from his paper?
It's on youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m46_XErVosU
alex3619
Senior Member
- Messages
- 13,810
- Location
- Logan, Queensland, Australia
Hi WillowJ, thanks. I put this together in a hurry, and didn't edit out all the bits properly - so the extra itp got in because I forget to delete that part of my notes. My notes were much more extensive, but I only mentioned the interesting stuff, and now its online for all to watch.
Bye
Alex