RyeRyeBread
Senior Member
- Messages
- 123
- Location
- New Jersey, US
*Possibly controversial, just fyi*
So, I'm on a few subreddits about ME or CFS on reddit. To be honest, avoid most of them, most of the time, because a good chunk of people on there have either gone down the rabbit hole of natural treatments (only talking about herbs, spices, vitamins, etc. and nothing else) or they are talking about recovery stories.
The controversial part here is my opinion on the recovery stories, or "cured" people. Let me preface this by saying I am not claiming to be correct and maybe science will soon prove me wrong, I am open to it. That being said, I have yet to hear an actual recovery/cure story (I'm talking 80-100% better and essentially no longer sick, not just improvement) that I believed. Not that I do not believe their improvement or recovery, but that I do not believe that is the same illness that the majority of us know as "ME" (or CFS depending on your preference).
I believe the people who have these grand recoveries or found this random cures were suffering, definitely, and they they were 100% legitimately ill -- But I do not think it's the same ME that the rest of us have. I am a subscriber to the theory that there may be multiple illnesses currently shoved under the diagnoses of ME, MECFS, and CFS, and I believe these people were (unfortunately and fortunately) misdiagnosed.
So I was on this subreddit, and I came across a recovery story. Normally I'd scroll past and leave it, but this one caught my eye. I clicked, read through, and if I'm honest I immediately got offended. This woman claims she recovered by changing the way she thought about her symptoms. She changed her thoughts, basically thought more positive and acted like her symptoms were less scary than they were, and she saw a 85% recover over time. She considers herself to have *had* ME/CFS, but to now be easentially cured.
I find this not only offensive and problematic, but also harmful and sad. As I'm sure many of us know, our thoughts do not make our illness, so changing them will do nothing but help your mood. Sure, you might see a little improvement, as the psychological mind does impact our physical bodies, but it would not cure ME. So, I commented and shared that. I do not have my original comment as I was later permanently banned for (I believe, they didn't tell me outright, just that I violated one of their 3 rules) denying a person's illness.
The ban is wrongful and incorrect, as I never stated her illness was not ME, or even that it wasn't real - I only spoke about generalized ME and how other people with recovery stories were most likely misdiagnosed. I made sure not to speak specifically about her because I know people get defensive real easily over stuff like that (and I was correct, she got fiesty and then i was banned lmao), and I also didn't want to be rude while sharing a comment I hoped would reach more people than just her.
In summary, my [non-doctor/researcher] opinion is that if your ME greatly improves simply by thinking better, you do not have ME. Sounds either like placebo effect that is temporary, or that your illness has a huge psychological factor go it and should be addressed that way.
What about ya'll? Do you believe the recoveries/cures? Again, by cures I mean 100% or near to it, I have heard of and believe the semi-recoveries that happen with pacing and whatnot, but even those people aren't healthy people again, just greatly improved or mild. Do you think a person who recovers thanks to their thought processes actually has ME?
*If that woman is in these forums and sees this, I just want to take a second and apologize if I made her feel invalidated, that was not my intention.
I wish you and anyone in a similar situation good luck.
So, I'm on a few subreddits about ME or CFS on reddit. To be honest, avoid most of them, most of the time, because a good chunk of people on there have either gone down the rabbit hole of natural treatments (only talking about herbs, spices, vitamins, etc. and nothing else) or they are talking about recovery stories.
The controversial part here is my opinion on the recovery stories, or "cured" people. Let me preface this by saying I am not claiming to be correct and maybe science will soon prove me wrong, I am open to it. That being said, I have yet to hear an actual recovery/cure story (I'm talking 80-100% better and essentially no longer sick, not just improvement) that I believed. Not that I do not believe their improvement or recovery, but that I do not believe that is the same illness that the majority of us know as "ME" (or CFS depending on your preference).
I believe the people who have these grand recoveries or found this random cures were suffering, definitely, and they they were 100% legitimately ill -- But I do not think it's the same ME that the rest of us have. I am a subscriber to the theory that there may be multiple illnesses currently shoved under the diagnoses of ME, MECFS, and CFS, and I believe these people were (unfortunately and fortunately) misdiagnosed.
So I was on this subreddit, and I came across a recovery story. Normally I'd scroll past and leave it, but this one caught my eye. I clicked, read through, and if I'm honest I immediately got offended. This woman claims she recovered by changing the way she thought about her symptoms. She changed her thoughts, basically thought more positive and acted like her symptoms were less scary than they were, and she saw a 85% recover over time. She considers herself to have *had* ME/CFS, but to now be easentially cured.
I find this not only offensive and problematic, but also harmful and sad. As I'm sure many of us know, our thoughts do not make our illness, so changing them will do nothing but help your mood. Sure, you might see a little improvement, as the psychological mind does impact our physical bodies, but it would not cure ME. So, I commented and shared that. I do not have my original comment as I was later permanently banned for (I believe, they didn't tell me outright, just that I violated one of their 3 rules) denying a person's illness.
The ban is wrongful and incorrect, as I never stated her illness was not ME, or even that it wasn't real - I only spoke about generalized ME and how other people with recovery stories were most likely misdiagnosed. I made sure not to speak specifically about her because I know people get defensive real easily over stuff like that (and I was correct, she got fiesty and then i was banned lmao), and I also didn't want to be rude while sharing a comment I hoped would reach more people than just her.
In summary, my [non-doctor/researcher] opinion is that if your ME greatly improves simply by thinking better, you do not have ME. Sounds either like placebo effect that is temporary, or that your illness has a huge psychological factor go it and should be addressed that way.
What about ya'll? Do you believe the recoveries/cures? Again, by cures I mean 100% or near to it, I have heard of and believe the semi-recoveries that happen with pacing and whatnot, but even those people aren't healthy people again, just greatly improved or mild. Do you think a person who recovers thanks to their thought processes actually has ME?
*If that woman is in these forums and sees this, I just want to take a second and apologize if I made her feel invalidated, that was not my intention.
I wish you and anyone in a similar situation good luck.