USA residents - is there consensus of whether we should order with alldaychemist now or wait?
Depends on if they will still replace any order you don't get because it's seized by customs.
There are 3 problems.
1) De Minimis rule
The de minimis rule just means you'll pay a tariff, so that's not really a problem.
2) IndiaPost Ban
India has outlawed IndiaPost from sending any packages to the US as a retaliation for other tariffs & arguments. However, private carriers like UPS, DHL, FedEx will still ship from India to the US, but they have a little higher risk of getting caught by Customs that regular IndiaPost/USPS mail. Some still get through, but it's more of a risk.
3) Custom's Scrutiny
The biggest problem is the now increased scrutiny at US Customs. Seems like they've stepped it up with these new import policies. But increased scrutiny and checks at Customs would be the problem.
I had a package seized in July and I'm trying to get a replacement sent and my Indian pharmacy said that they're waiting until things are more clear. In my opinion, tariffs and de minimis won't be removed for a long time (maybe slightly lower after an agreement). The IndiaPost ban will get reversed, but unknown how long - timeline more in months I'd guess.