The Buhner babesia protocol was insufficient to get on top of my babesia duncani infection. Cryptolepis, neem, sida acuta, and wormwood are all somewhat effective, with the first two being the strongest, but I had to use the pharmaceuticals.
I too had to give up the tinctures, but that was good because it got me into crushing up the herbs myself which is a whole lot cheaper.
I used chloroquine, azithromycin, quinine, and the above mentioned herbs in different combinations to get my load down, though I'd now recommend against using chloroquine as I developed chloroquine-induced retinopathy after just over a year on the drug. If I were to do it all over again I'd use 4 malarone as my foundation and rotate in the others as they seemed to work most effectively.
Nowadays for maintenance I use 1 generic malarone per day along with either cryptolepis or azithromycin.
Getting on top of babesia was huge for me. Made a big difference in my illness. I feel like a totally different person now.