Enterovirus and treatments

Hip

Senior Member
Messages
18,146
And is there any way of knowing if he has collaborated with the Stanford folks on his findings.

Sadly few of the other researchers and ME/CFS doctors take much interest in enterovirus etiologies, even though enterovirus probably accounts for more than half of all ME/CFS cases. It's only Dr Chia who is holding the fort.

And it's not much better in the ME/CFS patient community either: there always seems to be much less interest in enterovirus, in comparison to herpesvirus. You will find many patients have been tested for herpesviruses, but not many test for enterovirus.
 

godlovesatrier

Senior Member
Messages
2,612
Location
United Kingdom
Hi all.

I just wanted to add my current experience. I've been taking oxymatrine for 2 days and so far have noticed no herx at all. So I guess I might be another non responder type. But I'll report back in a week to let you know if anything has changed. I do feel like I may have reduced and/or eliminated much of the viral load (assuming it is viral) by taking 6g of andrographis paniculata for 6 months. I'm now taking 3g a day as a maintenance dose.

I also started taking 50mg of andrographolide as well and have noticed mild herxing with this, which I think is interesting as Andrographis is the only herb I can remember herxing on in a big way both when I originally started taking it and with increased dosage. I took this over about 2 years all in all, but highest dose for longest consistent dosing over 6 months.

I just want to add that a bad sore throat did come on in the night after I started taking oxymatrine. But to be honest this feels like nothing more or less than a mild cold virus. However I have had sore throat on and off for 3 years, mainly off for the last 18 months. So I will see if this persists for longer than a week.

I'll report back about the oxymatrine when I have been taking it for longer.
 
Last edited:

godlovesatrier

Senior Member
Messages
2,612
Location
United Kingdom
I'm 11 days in now and started to notice a stimulating effect on the Oxymatrine after taking it. I am trying not to do loads as I feel like I have more energy, but I do wonder if it is just my imagination? Has anyone else had this stimulating effect? I am worried it's dirty energy and this is why people crash if they come off it too quickly. I've had a sore throat on and off for 11 days too, not sure if that's a herx as I have a cold as well. I'll check back when I know more.
 

godlovesatrier

Senior Member
Messages
2,612
Location
United Kingdom
It's been 4 weeks now on Oxy. I can't tell but my immune response may have taken a bit of a hit recently. I've just got over what felt like a virus, but it lasted about 4 or 5 days and I am wondering now if it's a potential die off with the oxy instead. As it felt like the flu but I never get sick like that in April. Feeling breathless and very run down at the moment, hoping it lifts. Currently at 3 Oxymatrine tablets a day.
 

Hip

Senior Member
Messages
18,146
@godlovesatrier, Dr Chia often finds that a brief flu-live fever lasting a few days at the 1 or 2 months stage on oxymatrine is a good sign, indicating the immune system has kicked into action. Once the fever is done, he finds patients often feel better. So the oxymatrine fever is a kind of turning point.
 
Messages
17
How are you doing Godlovesatrier? I am about 11 days in right now and I also have a pretty wicked sore throat.
 

godlovesatrier

Senior Member
Messages
2,612
Location
United Kingdom
Hi MB. I'm going through a terrible bout of ME right now. The likes of I haven't felt for probably 12 to 18 months. It's horrible to be honest. The fatigue is crippling. But I can't say it's due to the oxy. I have had a high temp and fever on the oxy a few times but if anything I felt like i was going backwards even before I hit this crash. Because I started to suffer with mild fatigue 2 weeks ago. Anyway I've stopped taking it today that is I'm titrating down slowly. Personally it does seem to help but I also get the feeling it might just be stimulating me in a volatile way and that's no good really.

So the truth is at the 6 week point I've had to titrate down. But this may not be the right decision. I just desperately need relief right now as I'm in agony. Ironically feels like a virus, flu like symptoms plus muscular aches and pains and terrible drenching night sweats. What I mean is classic ME symptoms. I just can't help but feel the oxy has opened me up to where I am now even if it didn't cause it.

I hope it works for you I sincerely do.
 

godlovesatrier

Senior Member
Messages
2,612
Location
United Kingdom
Thanks. This is a horrible crash, it's extreme. But I can't entirely put it down to the oxy. Suffice to say I've been off it for 2 days and I feel like it hasn't caused me to crash further. If that makes sense. I've gone back on andrographis paniculata and taking ginseng so I can function. But I must admit I do think it probably is the oxy because it was stimulating my immune system (I think) quite a lot, I had more energy taking it, but I think that might have been because I was constantly in a TH1 state. Maybe it works for some people, but I think this unstable aggressive th1 dominant approach wouldn't work for me. Just hoping and praying I can recover back to a decent baseline at the moment.

The above is anecdotal but that's been my experience.
 

Swim15

Senior Member
Messages
369
Waking up an old thread but found a lot of this info really interesting.

After reading some of the theories at the beginning, it seems like a reasonable set of actions would be to...

1. get glutamate signaling under control (probably with gaba-ergics and NMDA antagonists.

2. reduce viral load as much as possible (at this point that’s just herbal antivirals, something like ribivarin or arbidol, and ozone/HBOT)

3. then hitting things with oxymatrine to boost interferon along with other herbs that boost IFN potentially

Does it make sense theoretically that this may be more effective?
 

Hip

Senior Member
Messages
18,146
1. get glutamate signaling under control (probably with gaba-ergics and NMDA antagonists.

If you have "wired but tired" glutamate issues, this thread might be of interest.


You might like to look at the low-dose oral interferon story in this post, which put one patient into remission. I started to try this myself, but got mental health side effects forcing me to stop. Not sure why oral interferon should work in such low doses, but maybe it targets enteroviral infections in the stomach?
 

Swim15

Senior Member
Messages
369
If you have "wired but tired" glutamate issues, this thread might be of interest.


You might like to look at the low-dose oral interferon story in this post, which put one patient into remission. I started to try this myself, but got mental health side effects forcing me to stop. Not sure why oral interferon should work in such low doses, but maybe it targets enteroviral infections in the stomach?

Yeah I just recently got most, and still not all, of those types of symptoms under control with 1mg klonopin every other day and 10mg memantine.

Hip - have you seen any reports of people using cycloferon in combination with any of the protocols Chia uses like oxymatrine or any other treatments?
 

Swim15

Senior Member
Messages
369
This is also a very random question as I haven’t been able to find anything so far but what the fuck is the difference between Coxsackie or echo virus serotypes?

Googled around and tried to find the difference between CV3/4 and CV1 or CV6 and can’t find anything.

On that note, I never see CV1 or CV6 mentioned in literature which I had pop up on my labs.

Could any assumption be made that arbidol could be used for CV1/6 infections?
 

Hip

Senior Member
Messages
18,146
Hip - have you seen any reports of people using cycloferon in combination with any of the protocols Chia uses like oxymatrine or any other treatments?

I think one person may have mildly benefited from cycloferon, but that could have been due to its anti-inflammatory effects. I think if cycloferon and similar Russian immunomodulators which boost interferon were effective, you would feel tired and/or depressed while taking them, because that's what actual interferon causes.

I think I read once that some of these Russian immunomodulators were demonstrated to induce interferon in mice, but that does not mean they work for humans. It's generally easier to induce interferon in mice.



Googled around and tried to find the difference between CV3/4 and CV1 or CV6 and can’t find anything.

There's not a great deal of difference. All 6 CVB and all 32 echoviruses come under the enterovirus B classification, in the new enterovirus taxonomy. So they are all the same species: enterovirus B.

CVB is more commonly found in ME/CFS, and echovirus less common.

CVB3 and CVB4 are the most commonly coxsackievirus B serotypes in ME/CFS. Then less common are CVB2 and CVB5.

CVB6 is pretty rare in general, you don't find many people with it in the general population.

CVB3 is often used as the prototype coxsackievirus B in lab experiments.

CVB4 and to a lesser extent CVB1 are linked to type 1 diabetes: they infect the insulin-producing beta cells of the pancreas, and some researchers think they might be the cause of T1D. I have high titers to CVB4, and a relative who caught it from me went on to get T1D, but only several years later.

Sometimes antivirals work for some CVB serotypes, but not others. Dr Chia found interferon works for ME/CFS patients with CVB3 and CVB5, but not for CVB4. Chia found oxymatrine does not work for echovirus.
 

Swim15

Senior Member
Messages
369
@Hip appreciate that.

So yes on the cycloferon...isn’t increasing IFN how oxymatrine works though?

At this point, while I feel like an intelligent person, I’m still trying to line some of these pieces up in my mind. It seems like CVB infections can ‘turn off’ an interferon response that is responsible for destroying viral RNA - so using both IFN stimulators would potentially yield better results?

I’m sure that’s an over simplification
 

Hip

Senior Member
Messages
18,146
So yes on the cycloferon...isn’t increasing IFN how oxymatrine works though?

My understanding (which is only a limited one) is oxymatrine shifts the Th1-Th2 immune balance in the direction of Th1. Th1 is the immune response which targets intracellular infections (such viral infections, or intracellular bacteria like Chlamydia pneumoniae). Whereas Th2 is the immune mode which targets extracellular pathogens, like bacteria.

There is an old idea that ME/CFS patients may have insufficient Th1 response, so that they find it harder to clear viruses. Some factors can cause a shift away from the desirable antiviral Th1 response, and shift immunity towards Th2. The Th1-Th2 balance is a bit like a seesaw: if you raise one side, the other side will automatically go down (to an extent). So factors which boost Th2 will tend to automatically reduce Th1.

However, this Th1-Th2 hypothesis of ME/CFS is just a theory; there's no solid science that demonstrates a Th1-Th2 imbalance is the cause of ME/CFS. Nevertheless, people like Dr Chia use the Th1-Th2 model to explain how oxymatrine works for ME/CFS patients.

Cytokines which move the immune response to Th1 are IL-12, IL-2 and interferon gamma. Cytokines which move the immune response to Th2 include IL-4 and IL-10.

One study found that oxymatrine boosts the Th1 cytokines interferon gamma and IL-2, and inhibits the Th2 cytokines IL-4 and IL-10.

So you can see oxymatrine alters the Th1-Th2 seesaw such that Th1 is increased.

It's interesting that when Dr Chia did a cytokine profile of ME/CFS patients given oxymatrine, all the oxymatrine responders showed a definite shift to Th1; whereas in the oxymatrine non-responders, their immune system did not shift; somehow it remained stuck in Th2.

You can see a graph of this cytokine profile of Dr Chia's oxymatrine patients in this video at timecode 37:05. You might like to watch the whole oxymatrine section of that video, which starts at 25:08.

I am a non-responder to oxymatrine, which may mean my immune system is stuck in Th2, and does not move to Th1 even with high doses of oxymatrine (I've taken 6 tablets daily for months, but saw nothing).




At this point, while I feel like an intelligent person, I’m still trying to line some of these pieces up in my mind. It seems like CVB infections can ‘turn off’ an interferon response that is responsible for destroying viral RNA - so using both IFN stimulators would potentially yield better results?

In these chronic so-called non-cytolytic enterovirus infections, you just get a pure naked viral RNA infection of the cells (this RNA exists in the cell in both the single-stranded and double stranded forms, and it's thought it is the dsRNA form which is hardest to eradicate).

For some reason, the interferon response is being thwarted, and the immune system is unable to clear this enterovirus RNA (even though there are only small amounts in the cells, and it replicates only very slowly).

Dr Chia and others have suggested the enterovirus dsRNA acts like a seed or a spore, which is hard to remove.

However, a different explanation was recently proposed, relating to some genetic mutations that are known to exist in the non-cytolytic enterovirus RNA: it's been suggested these mutations confer resistance to the interferon response.
 
Last edited:

Hip

Senior Member
Messages
18,146
I should add that I am not clear on how the Th1-Th2 immune balance links into secretion of type 1 interferons like interferon alpha, beta and delta.

Interferon gamma, a type 2 interferon, in intrinsically connected to the Th1-Th2 balance, because interferon gamma is a Th1 cytokine, that will boost Th1 and shift the Th1-Th2 balance to the Th1 side.

However, when Th1 is activated (either naturally or by immunomodulators like oxymatrine), I am not sure if that then leads to any increase secretion of type 1 interferons.

I've never seen any indications that oxymatrine can boost type 1 interferons; whereas there are herbs like astragalus which boost interferon alpha.



I believe type 1 interferons are secreted when viral dsRNA is detected within the cell (TLR3 is the cell's dsRNA detector).
 
Messages
12
Thanks. This is a horrible crash, it's extreme. But I can't entirely put it down to the oxy. Suffice to say I've been off it for 2 days and I feel like it hasn't caused me to crash further. If that makes sense. I've gone back on andrographis paniculata and taking ginseng so I can function. But I must admit I do think it probably is the oxy because it was stimulating my immune system (I think) quite a lot, I had more energy taking it, but I think that might have been because I was constantly in a TH1 state. Maybe it works for some people, but I think this unstable aggressive th1 dominant approach wouldn't work for me. Just hoping and praying I can recover back to a decent baseline at the moment.

The above is anecdotal but that's been my experience.
Hi! I was going to schedule an online consultation with Dr. Chia it can’t find his office phone number or any information about him through Google. Can you please help? Thank you!
 
Back