The mechanism for L-form bacteria's sensitivity to D3 is theorized to be equivalent to smoking's nicotine addiction:
1. Try smoking. Toxin exposure causes nausea.
2. Try smoking again. Liver upregulates detox pathways to clear toxins faster, side effect is better nicotine tolerance and less toxin accumulation.
3. Nicotine blood levels from smoking increase causing euphoria due to dopamine increase.
4. Overstimulation of dopamine receptors causes decreases in the number of receptors causing the high to wear off.
5. Now dopamine receptors are desensitized so smokers feel less pleasure unless they smoke.
For L-form infection:
1. Viral infection decreases number of vitamin D receptors (VDR).
2. L-form bacteria exposure and colonizes, further decreases receptors.
3. Body responds to infection by maximizing production of 1,25D (D3) causing an overdose.
4. Overstimulation of VDR receptors causes decreases in the number of receptors causing the cells to stop receiving signals to make antibacterial peptides.
5. D3 is now in a vicious cycle where tolerance causes less effect until eventually no effect.
I found some interesting research regarding supplementation in Navy submariners. Doses of 400 IU daily D3 did not prevent bone turnover. I"m wondering if the problem could be due to decreased absorption due to overly frequent dosing; something we often see occurring with other supplements. Moreover, because D3 is the active form (1,25 D cholecalciferol) the body can't regulate its stores through feedback and it would be prone to overdose). You need 2000 IU/day D3 to overcome the resistance effect. This looks suspiciously similar to the above theorized D3 resistance and makes me suspect that daily dosing of D3 is unhealthy.
The submariner paper also quoted studies showing that VDRs are located on monocytes and lymphocytes47 and seem to promote self tolerance which is the ability of the immune system to not attack host tissues.48,49 This loss of autoimmunity may be a factor in CFS with a presentation similar to myastheia gravis where autoantibodies attack acetylcholine neurotransmitters. (Gertner, J. Vitamin D Supplementation in Submariners. December 2, 2008. Naval Submarine Medical Research Laboratory. NSMRL/50210/TR--2008-1267. http://www.dtic.mil/cgi-bin/GetTRDoc?Location=U2&doc=GetTRDoc.pdf&AD=ADA498140)
Here's the basic theory quoted from my comments in another thread.
I just found more evidence for a link between autoimmune disease and cell receptor changes due to uv light like what we see in D3 ingestion:
For years weve been warned that too much sun exposure increases the risk of skin cancer and can turn the soft, supple skin of youth into a weathered and leathered topography. But now it turns out the suns dangers are more than skin deep. The suns rays particularly deep-penetrating ultraviolet-A (UVA) rays can damage the DNA within the nuclei of the bodys cells, inhibiting their ability to control how and when cells grow and divide. While the most obvious threat is skin damage, the suns rays also can wreak havoc for many people with lupus, as well as those taking certain arthritis medications. And recent research has connected UV radiation with the development of cancer of lymphoid tissues, including Hodgkins disease, non-Hodgkins lymphoma and leukemia. (Dunkin, MA. Do you have an autoimmune disease? Why you should stay out of the sun. accessed 10/23/2010. http://www.arthritis.org/sun-and-the-immune-system.php)
No one understands what, specifically, the UVA rays do to immune system cells in people with lupus, but a large percentage of people with lupus have problems with the sun, says Robert Brodell, MD, professor of medicine in the dermatology section at Northeastern Ohio Universities College of Medicine in Rootstown. Problems can range from an immediate redness, burning and stinging of the skin to a systemic flare of the disease, characterized by inflammation of the joints, blood vessels and internal organs.
People with scleroderma, too, can be affected by sun exposure, says Frederick Wigley, MD, director of the Johns Hopkins Scleroderma Center in Baltimore. While they dont have the same blistering or flares associated with lupus, the sun can cause further damage to skin already hardened and damaged by the disease, he says. Also, some people with scleroderma have hyperpigmentation of the skin that is made worse by sun exposure.
Several medications that people take for those and other inflammatory diseases, including rheumatoid arthritis (RA), can also cause sun sensitivity and lead to problems such as skin rash or rapid burning. Some of the most common culprits are nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) and some disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs (DMARDs), including hydroxychloroquine (Plaquenil), methotrexate and sulfasalazine (Azulfidine). Tetracycline antibiotics, some antidepressants and diuretics can cause sun sensitivity too.
Minimizing sun effects as well as reducing risks of cancers means protecting your skin from harmful rays.
Fluorescent Light & Lupus: May Be a Dangerous ComboThe sun isnt the only light source that gives off ultraviolet-A (UVA) rays. Most people dont know that fluorescent bulbs do too. For people with lupus who are extremely sensitive to UVA rays, the rays given off by fluorescent lights may cause a burn or trigger a flare. If you have fluorescent lights in your home, replace them. If you work in an office with fluorescent lighting, be sure to wear sunscreen to work. Ask to have the bulbs in your immediate work area removed or simply keep them turned off, if possible and use an incandescent desk lamp instead.
If you think about the way people have managed D3 in the past thousand years, there was no D3 available orally so what would happen is that people would get sun exposure for 3/4 of the year then in the winter be deprived-allowing the levels to go down. Now because there is supplementation in the food supply people lack that wean down period and overdose. Additionally, the daily dosing desensitizes the receptors to lower their activity.
I think the solution is to use vitamin D2 dosed weekly rather than D3 daily. This allows the body to use its feedback control mechanisms to control the D3 levels.