Hi Kurt. I was just pointing out that when you say it's just as likely that the WPI was mistaken, that also means the NCI and the Cleveland Clinic being mistaken, which is true.
I don't think that's a fair characterization of the very thoughtful examination of information that goes on on this forum.
people here are acting like XMRV is an established fact so any lab that does not find it in 'my CFS' is obviously flawed, but that is just not the case.
You are right, I should have said 'some people here..'. There are many viewpoints represented here.
But I think you have to admit that the thoughtful examination tends to be very one-sided. How many people here are carefully examining the Science article objectively? Maybe we need a thread for that.