• Welcome to Phoenix Rising!

    Created in 2008, Phoenix Rising is the largest and oldest forum dedicated to furthering the understanding of, and finding treatments for, complex chronic illnesses such as chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS), fibromyalgia, long COVID, postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS), mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS), and allied diseases.

    To become a member, simply click the Register button at the top right.

D. A. Henderson, epidemiologist, dies at 87

halcyon

Senior Member
Messages
2,482
Donald A. Henderson, one of the epidemiologists that studied the 1950s US epidemic neuromyasthenia outbreaks (aka ME), has died at age 87.

One of the last papers he published on the subject, in 1994, is a short but interesting read. Full text is available on sci-hub. An amusing excerpt:
The invitation to speak at this international conference on the chronic fatigue syndrome came as an all but forgotten echo of the past. Epidemic neuromyasthenia-the candidate name which Alexis Shelokov and I proposed for the syndromes we had studied was a recurrent preoccupation for us both over a number of years, as I shall relate. There weren't many who shared that interest three decades ago. In fact, a meeting of North American scientists interested in the problem in the late 1950s could be and usually was held in my hotel room. However, my interest had to be put on hold somewhat over one-quarter century ago when the Surgeon General decreed that I should devote my time to coping with smallpox.

After 11 years as an eradicator, I returned to the United States and the preoccupations of a dean at Johns Hopkins University. Then, in the mid-1980s, newspaper accounts appeared of a mysterious epidemic on the California-Nevada border. The epidemic sounded suspiciously like those that we had investigated and reviewed. The investigators of the Centers for Disease Control (CDC, Atlanta) alluded to certain other outbreaks with similar characteristics but made no reference to the epidemics of the 1950s. I suggested to colleagues at the CDC that the investigators might benefit from reading our 1959 review article in the New England Journal of Medicine. They had not seen it. As they said, "We did not know it was that long ago. In the literature search, we only went back to 1965." Although I do appreciate the fact that I am not so young as I used to be, I do not appreciate my earliest papers being treated as some form of prehistory. Whatever, you have asked for reflections on certain prehistorical outbreaks and I shall do my best aided, in part, by certain dusty files that were reread after several decades of quiet moldering. I should note, in passing, that you have done irreparable damage to my wife's campaign to chuck at least a few of those ancient files that "have not been looked at in years."
 
Last edited:

taniaaust1

Senior Member
Messages
13,054
Location
Sth Australia
One of our unsung heros.

the following part really got to me
The epidemic sounded suspiciously like those that we had investigated and reviewed. The investigators of the Centers for Disease Control (CDC, Atlanta) alluded to certain other outbreaks with similar characteristics but made no reference to the epidemics of the 1950s. I suggested to colleagues at the CDC that the investigators might benefit from reading our 1959 review article in the New England Journal of Medicine. They had not seen it. As they said, "We did not know it was that long ago. In the literature search, we only went back to 1965." Although I do appreciate the fact that I am not so young as I used to be, I do not appreciate my earliest papers being treated as some form of prehistory
............

Im wondering if anyone in our ME communities could go and rescue the very valuable info which still probably would be at his place before it is passed on to gov people who could vanish the old studies published etc or his wife throws it all out?

He's probably got the collection of the old Australian/ New Zealand ME or CFS research journals from way back (sorry I forget now what it would be called but as far as I know no copies have been archieved online of this, there would be very little copies left and he may hold one of the last as not many of our specialists from back before the Lake Tahoe outbreak in the 1980s are left.

I strongly suspect him he would subcribed to this when it was being published .. he would of known about this ME journal on this rare illness he studied himself even if it wasnt in his country

I saw a couple of old copies of this over (not online) 9? years ago now,, these journals I think predate all the bullcrap that CDC caused in the 1980s.. all the original ME studies published in an Australian and New Zealand journal on our illness
 
Last edited:

anciendaze

Senior Member
Messages
1,841
As it happens, I passed through Punta Gorda in November of 1956, site of the outbreak investigated by Henderson and Poskanzer. The "worst flu of my life" took place the following year, when the "Asian flu" hit. Whatever the patients studied in the Punta Gorda outbreak had it was not the Asian flu, because that was highly contagious. We found out the following year that most of the U.S. population had no immunity to it. Doctors and hospitals were overwhelmed with cases. I am not aware of any long-term followup on the health of those affected by the Asian flu.

The people studied in the Punta Gorda outbreak were permanent residents in an area where most people had agricultural or service jobs. What you will find nowhere in that paper is a mention of the tourist destinations they served: Port Charlotte, Fort Myers, Sanibel island, Captiva. If any tourists were affected, the investigators didn't see them. Presumably, they went home, where doctors did not notice an epidemic. Florida health officials were adverse to advertising an outbreak in tourist destinations.

Another outbreak took place among student nurses at a private psychiatric hospital near Washington, Chestnut Lodge. This was investigated by Alexis Shelokov. At the time of publication he was chief of the laboratory section on infectious diseases at NIAID. At this remove we can't distinguish between a possible viral disease and an early outbreak of what came to be known as Lyme disease. Today there is no question both the ticks and the spirochetes are found in that part of Maryland.

Henderson and Shelokov went on to publish a paper on such outbreaks.

None of them changed the opinions expressed in those publications. They believed they had seen outbreaks of a neurological disease. None of these people could be dismissed as lightweights, instead they were simply ignored.

It is time this came to an end.