• Phoenix Rising needs funds to operate: please consider donating to support PR

XMRV Patent application Judy A. Mikovits Francis W. Ruscetti San

eric_s

Senior Member
Messages
1,925
Likes
75
Location
Switzerland/Spain (Valencia)
Those patent applications are much too complicated for me to really understand but i would be interested in this: Is there some overlap between the 2?

I hope they won't start cannibalizing each other now, if they smell the money.

It would not stop progress, but it would not be nice.
 

CBS

Senior Member
Messages
1,513
Likes
849
Bullybeef,

No offense but if this is out there (and we know that it is to some degree), how else do you think they're going to find this in our brains? I'd rather that than a biopsy. Still, there are pathogens that hide out in brain tissue and don't readily circulate (toxoplasmosis). Don't think it's not there.

I'm wondering if the same methods would be used to look in prostate and lymphatic tissue.
 

CBS

Senior Member
Messages
1,513
Likes
849
I can hear the howls from the XMRV-Prostate Cancer Deniers now:

"Bob Silverman is Exploiting Prostate Cancer Patients! We must stop that unethical SOB!"

"The Cleveland Clinic is nothing but a front for it's greedy founders and their efforts to separate these vulnerable, desperate, naive patients from their money!*"

* Honest, we're just trying to protect you poor ignorant prostate cancer patients from yourselves.
 

bullybeef

Senior Member
Messages
488
Likes
138
Location
North West, England, UK
Bullybeef,

No offense but if this is out there (and we know that it is to some degree), how else do you think they're going to find this in our brains? I'd rather that than a biopsy. Still, there are pathogens that hide out in brain tissue and don't readily circulate (toxoplasmosis). Don't think it's not there.

I'm wondering if the same methods would be used to look in prostate and lymphatic tissue.
Sorry, I should have explained my reaction CBS. I have recently wondered whether a spinal tap would show anything. I find it fascinating that in the future this diagnostic method could show our XMRV status.
 

CBS

Senior Member
Messages
1,513
Likes
849
Sorry, I should have explained my reaction CBS. I have recently wondered whether a spinal tap would show anything. I find it fascinating that in the future this diagnostic method could show our XMRV status.
Bullybeef,

I'm just having a little fun with this. I've suspected for a very long time that they would one day be looking in our brains. I've been arguing with doc over 'odd' MRI findings since 1995 (I'll spare you the details - feel free to PM). It's going to be interesting to watch and see what is found once they actually start looking.

Take good care and I do hope I didn't offend.
 

judderwocky

Senior Member
Messages
328
Likes
3
I can hear the howls from the XMRV-Prostate Cancer Deniers now:

"Bob Silverman is Exploiting Prostate Cancer Patients! We must stop that unethical SOB!"

"The Cleveland Clinic is nothing but a front for it's greedy founders and their efforts to separate these vulnerable, desperate, naive patients from their money!*"

* Honest, we're just trying to protect you poor ignorant prostate cancer patients from yourselves.
labs patent things all the time... if they had been at a university this would have probably been patented already... my guess is they had to work it out between three labs first ... and usually that thing is covered in the collaboration agreements between universities.....
*i think*

a patent shouldn't be considered suspicious
 

CBS

Senior Member
Messages
1,513
Likes
849
labs patent things all the time... if they had been at a university this would have probably been patented already... my guess is they had to work it out between three labs first ... and usually that thing is covered in the collaboration agreements between universities.....
*i think*

a patent shouldn't be considered suspicious
Apparently my attempts at satire are falling flat this morning. I'll stop.
 

Lynn

Senior Member
Messages
366
Likes
250
CBS,

I thought it was funny as well. Unfortunately I knew it would bring trouble from some who didn't get that it was a joke from their first reading.

Lynn
 

Lesley

Senior Member
Messages
188
Likes
4
Location
Southeastern US
I think that they needed to get the patent application filed before VIP Dx began offering the new test. Hopefully, now that the application has been filed, the testing should be available.
 

bullybeef

Senior Member
Messages
488
Likes
138
Location
North West, England, UK
Bullybeef,

I'm just having a little fun with this. I've suspected for a very long time that they would one day be looking in our brains. I've been arguing with doc over 'odd' MRI findings since 1995 (I'll spare you the details - feel free to PM). It's going to be interesting to watch and see what is found once they actually start looking.

Take good care and I do hope I didn't offend.
Of course not, CBS, I took it in good humour....I wouldn't put it past Wessely, Reeves and Co to order brains biopsies on all of us, and send us away with a lobotomy free of charge so we don't sue!!!! :tear:
 

Navid

Senior Member
Messages
561
Likes
540
cbs: i got your satire, please don't stop it's very funny and we'll only cry if we can't laugh:D:D
 

SOC

Senior Member
Messages
7,849
Likes
16,359
"...the XMRV-related neuroimmune disease is selected from the group consisting of chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), Niemann-Pick Type C Disease, fibromyalgia, Multiple Sclerosis (MS), Parkinson's Disease, Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS) and autism."
[my bolding]

:eek: and :eek::eek:

My FIL died of aggressive prostate cancer 25 (?) years ago. My MIL died of "atypical ALS" about a year before my daughter and I came down with ME/CFS. And we've got lymphoma on my side of the family......

:eek: [running off to hide under the blankets]
 

alex3619

Senior Member
Messages
13,801
Likes
37,619
Location
Logan, Queensland, Australia
Hi SickofCFS

I wouldn't read this as anything definite yet, its from the patent application, and may be more from suspicion or hypothesis than anything solid. They just want to cover all their options in the patent. On the other hand, should this be published as a definite finding later dont be surprised. It also gives us several more patient groups we should consider contacting.

Bye
Alex


[my bolding]

:eek: and :eek::eek:

My FIL died of aggressive prostate cancer 25 (?) years ago. My MIL died of "atypical ALS" about a year before my daughter and I came down with ME/CFS. And we've got lymphoma on my side of the family......

:eek: [running off to hide under the blankets]
 

SOC

Senior Member
Messages
7,849
Likes
16,359
Hi SickofCFS

I wouldn't read this as anything definite yet, its from the patent application, and may be more from suspicion or hypothesis than anything solid. They just want to cover all their options in the patent. On the other hand, should this be published as a definite finding later dont be surprised. It also gives us several more patient groups we should consider contacting.

Bye
Alex
I'm not, really. :D It's just my own little not-very-funny grim humor.
 

julius

Watchoo lookin' at?
Messages
785
Likes
5
Location
Canada
I see why Einstein quit his job as a patent clerk. It was easier to figure out the fabric of the universe than to understand one of these applications.
 

natasa778

Senior Member
Messages
1,774
Likes
2,450
I see why Einstein quit his job as a patent clerk. It was easier to figure out the fabric of the universe than to understand one of these applications.
:tear::tear::tear:

he actually came up with his best stuff WHILE working as a patent clerk!! I guess he flexed his brain muscles so well by doing patent stuff that the Relativity theory was easy-peasy. It could have been his little Sudoku, a way of relaxing :D
 
Messages
1,479
Likes
522
Location
Clay, Alabama
Controversy, is there any controversy over the Prostate Cancer claims of linkage with XMRV. I mean, the association is in the 20-30% and is anyone claiming foul on the studies and claims afterward?

Or is it just us that have to deal with this mess? Same testing method, but much higher association.

Tina
 

garcia

Aristocrat Extraordinaire
Messages
975
Likes
247
Location
UK
Controversy, is there any controversy over the Prostate Cancer claims of linkage with XMRV. I mean, the association is in the 20-30% and is anyone claiming foul on the studies and claims afterward?

Or is it just us that have to deal with this mess? Same testing method, but much higher association.

Tina
I agree Tina. It is double-standards pure and simple.

If you listen to Myra McClure's interview she did with Australian ABC radio, she proves the case for XMRV involvement in prostate cancer, and de facto proves the case for XMRV involvement in ME/CFS. All you have to do is replace one disease name with the other. The arguments apply verbatim. I suggest this is the reason why Myra McClure made a swift exit from CFS-research because effectively she painted herself ("I'm 10,000 percent confident") into a corner and was too proud/stubborn to back down.