- Messages
- 549
- Likes
- 718
I think I read someone «debunking» it here on PR But I cant find the thread/comment.
What does science actually say about psychological illness manifesting in severe physical illness?
- Thread starter ChookityPop
- Start date
I'm not quite sure what you're getting at, but my sister died of a non-me illness, and became completely manic the last 4 months of her life due to significant weight loss because of surgery and other medical treatment to the point that the hospital requested that we go to court and retain legal guardianship. I don't think this is that uncommon, though it did seem to be a surprise for the hospitals involved.
- Messages
- 549
- Likes
- 718
Im very sorry hearing about your sister. I have people in my life that suffers from mental illness and I know that mental illness can be severly crippling for these patients.
I meant severe physical illness like ME or anything along those lines. There are obviously people out there that think this is possible and I'm curious to know what they base that on.
I meant severe physical illness like ME or anything along those lines. There are obviously people out there that think this is possible and I'm curious to know what they base that on.
Last edited:
Thank you.
The field of mental illness is a pseudoscience. There are no objective lab tests for the various mental conditions in the DSM-5.
Having dealt with family members who had stroke, Parkinson's, bipolar, ADHD, Asperger's, and anxiety, I've read a lot about brains and brain function over time. There are a number of things that affect the brain function and though there are a wide variety of " normal" conditions, variations in these and combinations of these can produce abnormal brain function:
The field of mental illness is a pseudoscience. There are no objective lab tests for the various mental conditions in the DSM-5.
Having dealt with family members who had stroke, Parkinson's, bipolar, ADHD, Asperger's, and anxiety, I've read a lot about brains and brain function over time. There are a number of things that affect the brain function and though there are a wide variety of " normal" conditions, variations in these and combinations of these can produce abnormal brain function:
- Microglial activation - this is the brains immune system and there various triggers that can set off the activation as well as inflammation
- Nutrient deficiencies and imbalances
- Lipopolysaccharides from the gut
- Infections
- Hormonal deficiencies and imbalances
- Toxicity - metals, mold mycotoxins, chemicals
- Lack of oxygen
Physical illnesses like multiple sclerosis, Parkinson's, irritable bowel syndrome, Crohn's, etc often lead to mental symptoms like depression and anxiety, even psychosis, there is no controversy about that.
The controversy comes from the reverse: the idea that mental symptoms (like anxiety or feeling stressed) can transform into physical illnesses. That notion is known as a psychosomatic illness, or a somatoform disorder.
There is a subtle difference between psychosomatic and somatoform disorders:
Psychosomatic illness = has actual objectively-measurable physiological symptoms (such as blood pressure) that are affected and aggravated by psychological factors such as emotional state.
Somatoform disorder = subjective feelings of illness that are untestable by medical tests.
The highly dubious and slightly crazy psychiatrists like Simon Wessely who entered ME/CFS research in the 1980s and recast ME/CFS as a a psychologically-caused disease considered ME/CFS to be a somatoform disorder, because there are no medical tests which can find any substantial pathology in ME/CFS.
So the idea is that your mental state or thoughts can cause an actual illness. There's almost no evidence for that, apart from obvious simple things like stress can raise blood pressure, which is true.
Wessely stated that ME/CFS was simply caused by a belief: he said that patients believed they were ill, and then this thought in their mind actually transformed into the illness of ME/CFS. See Wessely quotes here.
Patients then started being blamed for creating their own illness just by having the wrong thoughts in their mind, and treatment of ME/CFS patients turned into a form of exorcism of the thoughts that these mad psychiatrists said were causing ME/CFS.
Treatment of young teenage ME/CFS patients in the UK is still in effect based on exorcism. Not just exorcism of the patient's thoughts, but exorcism of the parent's thoughts as well: if parents actually think that there child is really ill, that is deemed to be supporting the the belief system of the patient, and these parents are then reported to social services for child abuse.
These crazy psychiatrists think the parents are encouraging the child's "illness beliefs" and thereby causing the ME/CFS.
I know that sounds unbelievable, but reporting parents for child abuse happens regularly with teenage ME/CFS cases, as Jane Colby of the Tymes Trust Children's ME Charity will tell you.
At timecode 25:37 of episode 4 of this set of podcasts, Jane Colby states that in recent years she has dealt with over 200 cases of parents being reported for the "child abuse" of believing that their kid's illness is real
Note that there are two podcasts on the page named "episode 4", the Colby one is the second of the two.
The controversy comes from the reverse: the idea that mental symptoms (like anxiety or feeling stressed) can transform into physical illnesses. That notion is known as a psychosomatic illness, or a somatoform disorder.
There is a subtle difference between psychosomatic and somatoform disorders:
Psychosomatic illness = has actual objectively-measurable physiological symptoms (such as blood pressure) that are affected and aggravated by psychological factors such as emotional state.
Somatoform disorder = subjective feelings of illness that are untestable by medical tests.
The highly dubious and slightly crazy psychiatrists like Simon Wessely who entered ME/CFS research in the 1980s and recast ME/CFS as a a psychologically-caused disease considered ME/CFS to be a somatoform disorder, because there are no medical tests which can find any substantial pathology in ME/CFS.
So the idea is that your mental state or thoughts can cause an actual illness. There's almost no evidence for that, apart from obvious simple things like stress can raise blood pressure, which is true.
Wessely stated that ME/CFS was simply caused by a belief: he said that patients believed they were ill, and then this thought in their mind actually transformed into the illness of ME/CFS. See Wessely quotes here.
Patients then started being blamed for creating their own illness just by having the wrong thoughts in their mind, and treatment of ME/CFS patients turned into a form of exorcism of the thoughts that these mad psychiatrists said were causing ME/CFS.
Treatment of young teenage ME/CFS patients in the UK is still in effect based on exorcism. Not just exorcism of the patient's thoughts, but exorcism of the parent's thoughts as well: if parents actually think that there child is really ill, that is deemed to be supporting the the belief system of the patient, and these parents are then reported to social services for child abuse.
These crazy psychiatrists think the parents are encouraging the child's "illness beliefs" and thereby causing the ME/CFS.
I know that sounds unbelievable, but reporting parents for child abuse happens regularly with teenage ME/CFS cases, as Jane Colby of the Tymes Trust Children's ME Charity will tell you.
At timecode 25:37 of episode 4 of this set of podcasts, Jane Colby states that in recent years she has dealt with over 200 cases of parents being reported for the "child abuse" of believing that their kid's illness is real
Note that there are two podcasts on the page named "episode 4", the Colby one is the second of the two.
Last edited:
- Messages
- 1,777
- Likes
- 2,441
I had a long reply here but on second thought will send directly to OP ibstead
@Learner1 you mean your sister was believed to have a mental illness but really was a result of physical damage? awful. any relation to your illnesses? condolonces.
@Learner1 you mean your sister was believed to have a mental illness but really was a result of physical damage? awful. any relation to your illnesses? condolonces.
Last edited:
- Messages
- 11,704
- Likes
- 28,556
I thought the following was really interesting....related to how psychologist view folks with lists of things wrong.
THE Psychology of Malingering.....they think about 20-30% of people are malingering and faking it...in a variety of examples on the document below.
This is a whole deal in psychology. Where they think a percentage of people are faking or pretending or exaggerating illness, typically for some benefit like Avoid Military Service, Or avoid work....
I was listening to some excerpts from the Johnny Depp trial. And this psychologist described all these tests they give people.
This is really interesting in that it describes all these generalizations and assumptions psychologists have regarding this malingering.
So part of this is the problem we face with our illness and presenting it to doctors, etc.
Posting this here....
https://www.fmhac.org/uploads/1/2/3/9/123913996/scott_malingering_handout.pdf
THE Psychology of Malingering.....they think about 20-30% of people are malingering and faking it...in a variety of examples on the document below.
This is a whole deal in psychology. Where they think a percentage of people are faking or pretending or exaggerating illness, typically for some benefit like Avoid Military Service, Or avoid work....
I was listening to some excerpts from the Johnny Depp trial. And this psychologist described all these tests they give people.
This is really interesting in that it describes all these generalizations and assumptions psychologists have regarding this malingering.
So part of this is the problem we face with our illness and presenting it to doctors, etc.
Posting this here....
https://www.fmhac.org/uploads/1/2/3/9/123913996/scott_malingering_handout.pdf
- Messages
- 549
- Likes
- 718
Very interesting, thanks for sharing! Im saving this one.
- Messages
- 11,704
- Likes
- 28,556
I generally lost it entirely (hysterical laughter, indicator of I am Not Depressed...) on pages 9-11 of the Malingering outline.
Saved it too.
Saved it too.
- Messages
- 549
- Likes
- 718
I forgot to Ask. Where does it say that they Think 20-30% are malingering and faking it?
- Messages
- 11,704
- Likes
- 28,556
in a few places...like:
Between25-30% of individuals presenting forworker’s compensation o rdisability claims demonstrate probable symptom exaggeration.
IntheirsurveyoftheAmericanBoardofClinicalNeuropsychologymembership, Mittenberg et al. (2002) determined that 30% of 3,688 disability cases involved probable malingering.
- Approximately one-third of malingerers dramatically overplay their presentations (thats 33%)
In their research, Gervais et al (2001) found that between 25-30% of patients who claimed major depression in civil litigation were probably malingering based on their performance on forced choice tests.
Between25-30% of individuals presenting forworker’s compensation o rdisability claims demonstrate probable symptom exaggeration.
IntheirsurveyoftheAmericanBoardofClinicalNeuropsychologymembership, Mittenberg et al. (2002) determined that 30% of 3,688 disability cases involved probable malingering.
- Approximately one-third of malingerers dramatically overplay their presentations (thats 33%)
In their research, Gervais et al (2001) found that between 25-30% of patients who claimed major depression in civil litigation were probably malingering based on their performance on forced choice tests.
- Messages
- 549
- Likes
- 718
Thank you!!