Prusty talks about his upcoming research on a podcast

Messages
56
1685570204919.png
 

Osaca

Senior Member
Messages
344
No idea which journal, any guesses? Also, will the preprint show up on bioRxiv.org regardless?
Seems like they submitted to a journal which isn't Frontiers (yay!) where some of his previous publications appeared. In that case the preprint wouldn't be made public if the paper is rejected by the journal. At least that's how I've come to know it work.

But I don't understand why it's not put on the Arvix independently. Should be common practive and should be done. In other sciences it's frowned upon for not submiiting to the Arvix as it's the collection of all our knowledge for the common good.
 
Messages
600
As i understand it Frontiers is where all the junk go that nobody else wants to publish. Thats what i heard at reddit anyways.
 
Messages
56
Seems like they submitted to a journal which isn't Frontiers (yay!) where some of his previous publications appeared. In that case the preprint wouldn't be made public if the paper is rejected by the journal. At least that's how I've come to know it work.

But I don't understand why it's not put on the Arvix independently. Should be common practive and should be done. In other sciences it's frowned upon for not submiiting to the Arvix as it's the collection of all our knowledge for the common good.
I don't know if I am being paranoid, but it feels like he's handling it as sensitive material, whatever that means. We all know what happened to Judy Mikovits as an example.
 

Osaca

Senior Member
Messages
344
Is this the case, should I skip Frontiers?
Frontiers is a pay to publish venue and is often considered shady and predatory, MDPI is usually considered to be below Frontiers. In many university or even countries, Frontiers publications don’t count toward tenure or toward the assessment of researchers and PhD positions aren’t allowed to publish there. A researcher would try to get his articles published somewhere better. You wouldn’t consider it an big accomplishment publishing in Frontiers and researchers are proud people. There’s also so many Frontiers sub-journals that the quality varies and you’ll find some that are very decent, whilst a physicist publishing in “Frontiers in physics” would be looked upon as “your paper got rejected by all reputable journals but you still desperately need it to be published so you paid.”

However, it’s also extremely field dependent and in some fields it’s not a taboo at all and the various journals seem good with reputable authors publishing there, of course without being top journals.

That being said the quality of an article speaks for itself and you can still find good publications in bad journals (and bad papers in good journals). It's the quality of the work that matters.

Personally, what I find a worse practice is if people don’t submit to the Arvix. I find that ridiculous.
 

Tsukareta

Senior Member
Messages
150
I hope we get something good from the conference today, I believe i've found the cause of the worst of my current health problems ( on top of ME/CFS ) but we can never count our chickens with CFS, i've been lucky with my functioning level so far but thats one of the problems with the illness is its unpredictable nature.
 
Back