ME Global Chronicle: Dr Nigel Speight FAILINGS IN THE CARE OF PATIENTS WITH VERY SEVERE ME (VSME)

Countrygirl

Senior Member
Messages
5,670
Location
UK
https://meglobalchronicle.wordpress.com/.../failings-in.../
The ME Global Chronicle

New article by Dr Nigel Speight

FAILINGS IN THE CARE OF PATIENTS WITH VERY SEVERE ME (VSME)​

GEPUBLICEERD OP 12 maart 2024

In the UK over recent years there have been a succession of cases of very severe ME who have been mismanaged by the medical profession, in the worst cases with fatal consequences.
There is a repeated pattern of failings in these cases which I will attempt to analyse, and then use individual case reports to illustrate these patterns.

Background problems
For many doctors, either family doctors, paediatricians or physicians, being confronted with a case of very severe ME will be their first experience of such a case. This may lead to a form of denial, whereby the doctor has to find another explanation for the presentation. Possible alternative labels include an Eating Disorder, despite the patient lacking any evidence of body dysmorphism or wanting to lose weight. Other psychological diagnoses considered include Pervasive Refusal Syndrome (PRS), or Pervasive Arousal and Withdrawal Syndrome (PAWS). Most distressingly for the family, mothers are sometimes accused of Fabricated and Induced Illness (FII).
Perhaps more understandably, most doctors will tend to panic initially, and to fear they are missing some other diagnosis. There is also a natural fear that the patient may die and they may be blamed. This leads to hospitalization and subjecting the patient to a battery of investigations, some of which will be very traumatic for the patient and lead to worsening of the condition.
Naturally, if the doctor starts from a position in which he/she does not accept that ME is an organic condition in the first place, these mistakes are even more likely to occur. Previous preference for the weaker term Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS) will increase the chances of denial, as no one ever talks of very severe CFS.
I have joked in the past that if God wants to drive doctors mad he confronts them with a case of ME. If this fails, God then confronts them with a case of Very Severe ME which usually does the trick!

Very severe ME
The patient with VSME will be totally bedridden, extremely sensitive to light and touch and too weak to feed themselves adequately. Whatever the age, they will naturally be dependent on a caring relative, usually the mother. If and when they are hospitalized, ideally this caring relative should be allowed full access to the patient 24 hrs a day as they will be the best person to provide both physical care and emotional support. Here they are often confronted by senior nursing staff who may adopt a territorial posture and object to the relative being allowed in in this way.
I once gave a talk to my nursing staff to prepare them for the admission of a very severely ill 16 year old girl. At the end of my talk one of our best nurses said “So what you are telling us is that everything we have been taught as nurses is wrong for this condition”. Brilliant. The same point could be made for doctors who tend to insist on investigation and treatment of patients with VSME as they would for patients with other conditions.

Nutritional support
Nearly all patients with VSME will require nutritional support in the form of nasogastric (NG) tube feeding initially, possibly moving to gastrostomy feeding if prolonged. Ideally this support should be instituted early rather than late, and should be provided on a domiciliary basis. In nearly all the cases to be described, this proved almost impossible to arrange at home, and patients had to be admitted to hospital simply to have a NG tube inserted, with all the resultant upset that hospital management can cause.

Case A
A 12 year old girl was under her paediatrician who had already diagnosed ME of moderate severity. The girl’s condition deteriorated markedly, she had to be admitted for tube feeding. The paediatrician then panicked and called in a Child Psychiatrist. The latter changed the diagnosis to PRS, and obtained a court order to compel the girl’s admission......................................

The ME Global Chronicle
New article by Dr Nigel Speight

 
Back