Ever.
'Independent' PACE TSC member speaks on MUS at British Infection Association
- Thread starter Esther12
- Start date
Woolie
Senior Member
- Messages
- 3,263
There is a technique for presenting yourself to doctors, isn't there? And you don't work it out for ages. At first you sincerely believe that your doctor will want to hear what you have to say. Its only later you realise they're humoring you.
Here's what I've learned:
* Focus on the big things, and keep quiet about the smaller symptoms.
* Avoid describing symptoms in ways that allow them to be easily dismissed as psychological. Early on I mentioned to the doctor my high resting pulse rate and heart palpitations. I only realised later how I was gifting my doctor an opportunity to label me as anxious. Ditto for fatigue - easy to attribute to depression - better to be more specific about what the sensation is and when it occurs.
* 'Objectify' your symptoms as much as possible. What makes them worse, under what circumstances do they lift, and what does that feel like? (For example, if I'm in a crash, my symptoms peak at around 6-8pm and I get a window of relief around 9-30-11pm). Vague descriptions of symptoms that overwhelm you and are almost constantly present are another gift to psychologisers.
* If you feel at your worst in the morning, keep quiet about it. Some doctors treat this as evidence of depression.
* Never 'bite' when they ask you how upset you are about your health, and never EVER bite when they ask you about other problems in your life. You're managing as best you can given your health limitations, you have gained courage, you have learned many lessons. But you're eager to get back fully to your great life!
* Frame every complaint as a barrier to you doing the things you really want to in life. You should also include a specific request of what you want to happen. e.g. if I could manage symptom x, that would allow me to do more of Y, and I desperately want to do that. Or: if there is even a 1 in 100 chance of this test finding something wrong with me that is treatable, that's worth it to me, because I desperately want to do x,y,z.
* Never exhibit your distress. Use other ways of conveying the seriousness of the matter. e.g., I'm not scared of (some bad diagnosis). My life is so severely limited now, I honestly can't imagine many scenarios that are worse than this.
* Say often: "Do you understand my position here?" "Can you appreciate why I might want that?" "Do you see my reasoning here?" "If you were in my position, I suspect you'd ask the same thing". These comments force the doctor to take your perspective. They challenge his/her view of you as somehow 'other'.
* Oh, and assume the doctor is humouring you unless you hear clear statements to the contrary. Many doctors are very good at that.
None of this stuff will work if your doctor is fully determined to believe your problem is psychological. But its gotta be worth trying, eh?
Here's what I've learned:
* Focus on the big things, and keep quiet about the smaller symptoms.
* Avoid describing symptoms in ways that allow them to be easily dismissed as psychological. Early on I mentioned to the doctor my high resting pulse rate and heart palpitations. I only realised later how I was gifting my doctor an opportunity to label me as anxious. Ditto for fatigue - easy to attribute to depression - better to be more specific about what the sensation is and when it occurs.
* 'Objectify' your symptoms as much as possible. What makes them worse, under what circumstances do they lift, and what does that feel like? (For example, if I'm in a crash, my symptoms peak at around 6-8pm and I get a window of relief around 9-30-11pm). Vague descriptions of symptoms that overwhelm you and are almost constantly present are another gift to psychologisers.
* If you feel at your worst in the morning, keep quiet about it. Some doctors treat this as evidence of depression.
* Never 'bite' when they ask you how upset you are about your health, and never EVER bite when they ask you about other problems in your life. You're managing as best you can given your health limitations, you have gained courage, you have learned many lessons. But you're eager to get back fully to your great life!
* Frame every complaint as a barrier to you doing the things you really want to in life. You should also include a specific request of what you want to happen. e.g. if I could manage symptom x, that would allow me to do more of Y, and I desperately want to do that. Or: if there is even a 1 in 100 chance of this test finding something wrong with me that is treatable, that's worth it to me, because I desperately want to do x,y,z.
* Never exhibit your distress. Use other ways of conveying the seriousness of the matter. e.g., I'm not scared of (some bad diagnosis). My life is so severely limited now, I honestly can't imagine many scenarios that are worse than this.
* Say often: "Do you understand my position here?" "Can you appreciate why I might want that?" "Do you see my reasoning here?" "If you were in my position, I suspect you'd ask the same thing". These comments force the doctor to take your perspective. They challenge his/her view of you as somehow 'other'.
* Oh, and assume the doctor is humouring you unless you hear clear statements to the contrary. Many doctors are very good at that.
None of this stuff will work if your doctor is fully determined to believe your problem is psychological. But its gotta be worth trying, eh?
Last edited:
Cheshire
Senior Member
- Messages
- 1,129
FWIW: This study was done by Carson, Stone and Sharpe, within a BPS frame, but it debunks the idea that the number of symptoms is a sign that identifies psychosomatic illness
Somatic symptom count scores do not identify patients with symptoms unexplained by disease: a prospective cohort study of neurology outpatients.
Carson AJ, Stone J, Hansen CH, Duncan R, Cavanagh J, Matthews K, Murray G, Sharpe M.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2015
http://jnnp.bmj.com/content/86/3/295.full.pdf+html
Woolie
Senior Member
- Messages
- 3,263
Unfortunately, I fear this information will be used in the wrong way: to insist that you don't need a high symptom count to qualify as having MUS.
There've been a few studies of this type lately. Disproving some widely believed tenet of "psychological" illness accounts. But then essentially refusing to revise their model. For example, one recent study showed that there was no greater susceptibility to anxiety, depression etc. in people with functional movement disorders (FMDs) than in control participants with 'organic' movement disorders.
But instead of using this evidence to challenge the conventional psychological explanations of FMDs, the researchers maintained their view that the illness had a psychological origin. They simply decided that measurable psychological dysfunction should not be a requirement for FMD diagnosis!
Jo Best
Senior Member
- Messages
- 1,032
I agree with your interpretation; I think they're just trying to make it easier to give a primary or additional 'diagnosis' of psychogenic / functional disorder in order to maintain and build their empire.
I see no difference between that and scientific fraud.
Jo Best
Senior Member
- Messages
- 1,032
In the context of infection, thought this was interesting, from a paper published yesterday.
This extract is at 16.5 Environmental confounders
(I posted the article here: http://forums.phoenixrising.me/inde...rome-in-health-and-disease.54015/#post-897178 )
This extract is at 16.5 Environmental confounders
(I posted the article here: http://forums.phoenixrising.me/inde...rome-in-health-and-disease.54015/#post-897178 )
Woolie
Senior Member
- Messages
- 3,263
I think its different because its about the limitations in people's thinking, not a deliberate desire to misrepresent. For people who work in 'psychological' explanations of illness, this concept is at the core of what they do, its gonna take a very special type of person to really question the whole thing.
Woolie
Senior Member
- Messages
- 3,263
Here's what I was talking about (from the 2017 FND conference in Edinburgh).
Kudos to the author of this poster for telling it like it is. But the problem is, despite work like this, the psych explanations for this disease will continue to flourish unchecked.
Last edited: