Countrygirl
Senior Member
- Messages
- 5,342
- Location
- UK
George Monbiot, journalist of The Guardian, on Long Covid, Chronic Fatigue and Misogyny
(It is mostly about ME)
We have a new champion!
Welcome to Phoenix Rising!
Created in 2008, Phoenix Rising is the largest and oldest forum dedicated to furthering the understanding of and finding treatments for complex chronic illnesses such as chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS), fibromyalgia (FM), long COVID, postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS), mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS), and allied diseases.
To register, simply click the Register button at the top right.
1. There’s an aspect of this story that I didn’t have space for in the column. This is about how the scientific and media establishment closed ranks around bad science, defending it from legitimate questioning and criticism.
2. In 2011, the Lancet’s editor, @richardhorton1, a man I otherwise admire, was challenged about major anomalies and irregularities in the PACE Trial paper he published. He dismissed the critics as “a small but highly vocal minority”. They turned out to be right.
3. In 2012, a promoter of the now-debunked claims that Cognitive Behavioural Therapy and Graded Exercise Therapy are effective treatments for ME/CFS was awarded the John Maddox Prize for defending them against what the Prize board called “intimidation and harassment”.
4. Intimidation and harassment are never acceptable. It’s true that some patients resorted to online insults and abuse, which was clearly wrong. But much of what was called “intimidation and harassment” was in fact legitimate critique of the methodology and requests for data.
5. Queen Mary University of London spent 5 years rebuffing requests for the PACE Trial data, characterising them as “vexatious”. In the media, these requests were described as “harassment”. Again.
6. But these data should have been in the public domain from the outset. When they were eventually released and re-analysed, they showed that the PACE Trial conclusions were unsafe and unsupported.
7. When patients and the scientists supporting them revealed massive methodological flaws and showed that the £5m PACE Trial had reached unsafe conclusions, it was an amazing victory for citizen science. But it was reported in the media as - you guessed it - further “harassment”.
8. Here’s something that shouldn’t need stating. Scientists should NEVER close ranks against empirical challenge and criticism. They shouldn’t deny requests for data, shouldn’t shore up disproven claims, shouldn’t circle the wagons against legitimate public challenge.
9. Some major soul-searching is in order. Why was it that massive methodological flaws in the PACE Trial weren’t picked up in peer review? Why weren’t they spotted by the steering committee and external adjudicators?
10. Why weren’t the trial data released from the outset? Why was it left to patients and independent researchers to expose the problems with a massive and expensive trial? Why did senior figures and boards continue to defend disproven claims?
11. A great injustice has been done to patients already suffering grievously from a terrible condition. On the basis of flawed findings, they’ve been told that their condition is largely psychological, and they’ve been pressed into useless and, arguably, dangerous treatments........................
George Monbiot, journalist of The Guardian, on Long Covid, Chronic Fatigue and Misogyny
(It is mostly about ME)
We have a new champion!
Yes, the journalist from The Guardian does have some good points. Let's hope they're listened to.
@Country Girl: Two questions. The first is do you know how much the British Govt. is putting into research for Long COVID?
and Second: Whatever happened to the young woman who was almost dying in a hospital in the north of England, I believe. I never saw a later report on what occurred. I may have just missed it. Sorry. Yours, Lenora.
Yes, the journalist from The Guardian does have some good points. Let's hope they're listened to.
@Country Girl: Two questions. The first is do you know how much the British Govt. is putting into research for Long COVID?
and Second: Whatever happened to the young woman who was almost dying in a hospital in the north of England, I believe. I never saw a later report on what occurred. I may have just missed it. Sorry. Yours, Lenora.
I’ve been discharged from my M.E. clinic in the U.K. and told it’s because they have too many long covid cases. It makes me kind of suspicious of the U.K. government. Are they really making new clinics, or just kicking ME people out of old ones and repurposing them? Hmm!
I’ve been discharged from my M.E. clinic in the U.K. and told it’s because they have too many long covid cases. It makes me kind of suspicious of the U.K. government. Are they really making new clinics, or just kicking ME people out of old ones and repurposing them? Hmm!