The information comes from Dr Carmen Scheibenbogen in Berlin. It has nothing to do with the Beiger interview although it may have been mentioned there. I am fairly sure there is no publication but the information has been shared with the research community. I agree that we do not know much about inclusion criteria but I doubt these are a major issue. Some cases were very unwell even if not strictly in the severe category (which did not give good responses in Norway).
Although I very much hope the phase III rituximab study is positive I think we should still be cautious.
I don't hope that many people find you pessimistic now professor Edwards -

. In science it is not uncommon not publicate negative findings but i don't have to tell you that. In that cohort there was a man who ended up in a wheelchair after rituximab and didn't recover anymore. The positive thing about the findings of Fluge and Mella is that i believe in serendipity maybe rituximab will lead to a better understanding of this disease. They dig deep in their research that is positive but nothing have been found yet.
Also with the mitochondria's nothing wrong. I know of an unpublished study in which muscle biopsies were taken, there was nothing found. The low metabolic state is totally different in what i know from ATP production problems, so i think Naviaux findings will end up to be due to something else, it is not the key either. Sorry if i am to pessimistic again people
My favorite is VanElzakker, the parasympathetic nervoussystem is broken.