He would seem to be an immunologist.
Agreed and it's a little hypocritical to accuse the review of cherry picking when we're cherry picking what we see as the interesting findings ourselves.
In my mind, the issue with cherry-picking is when you choose to publish based on certain data while well aware you are ignoring studies that directly relate to your topic of choice. I think there is an inherent understanding that your data would be weakened by what you have chosen not to address.
-J