But this news article alone deserves it's own thread I think. As I have stated in the other thread, this kind of news is potentially very damaging to our cause. With the caveat I still believe in XMRV and contamination is not an issue. If contamination is an issue, then it's all over.
Like you, I want the truth, even if it means that XMRV is just a contaminant (as then a treatment would offer no hope anyway).
BBC adds "... say researchers". I think that's important. This is the opinion of one team of researchers. Fine. Let's hear what the others say...
I feel if they say XMRV is not an infectious human virus at all this might even challenge Silverman, De Risi and Klein, who discovered XMRV. So some more capable people that will be forced to fight on our side.
Whenever there is a positive biomedical research finding in ME/CFS, ie the recent ME Research UK viral findings, the British press seek 'balance' and ask psychiatrists for a (negative) comment. Even Dr Shepherd at the ME Association doesn't seem to think this is unreasonable.
Yet somehow, now we have some 'contamination' papers, there is apparently no need for 'balance' - in fact we have I think 4-5 contamination studies published in a row - just in time for Xmas. Where is a comment from Harvey Alter for eg. - just for 'balance' of course?
No problem. Coffin has always been a bit paranoid about contamination, so this is not a new move for him. Also it's good that there are people worried about this, I don't want them silenced or anything. I want the truth.
I am becoming quite worried though that some of these scientists are not in it to help us or find the truth (not talking about Coffin here). It's more like they are trying to find their own truth, or at least that's the vibe I am getting.
I don't like the way they cover this neither. But Lo et al. got some 300+ articles that reported about it and could be found via Google within 1 or 2 days. I don't think this will get to 100. Not saying i know what to make of it, though. I hope for reactions from the "positive camp" without having to wait for too long.