Discussion in 'Other Health News and Research' started by clive powney, Jul 17, 2012.
I think they are confusing general fatigue with CFS
Interesting, but I would like to know how shilajit works long term. Things that stimulate the HPA axis have a habit of only working for a short period of time, before the HPAA adapts.
Yes, it looks like the rats just have general fatigue. They are physically stressed. Physically exhausted at worst.
And I don't really see how it's possible diagnose a rat with CFS anyway, because you can't ask them about muscle and joint pain, headaches, unrefreshing sleep or sore throats etc.
I've never heard 'shilajit' before, so I looked it up on wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shilajit
It seems like a bizarre substance... It's a naturally occuring mineral substance that "seeps from cracks in mountains"!
It looks like there have been quite a number of research papers on it.
Chronic exercise is a fairly common "trigger" in CFS animal studies. At best it mimics overtraining syndrome which may have vague similarities, but I wouldn't put much stock in such studies for CFS. Other methods I've read about include introducing a pathogen or toxin. ScienceDaily.com recently posted an article about a new development in understanding the biology of depression, which also discusses the inadequacies of behavioural measurements in lab animals (http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/07/120711134714.htm).
Yes overtraining syndrome would be a much better description. Whatever those rats had it wasn't chronic, they would have recovered by resting regardless of treatment.
Still at least no weasels were involved
it would be against the law to give rats CBT. They are rats and they deserve respect. ;-)
shilajit IIRC can be a source of lithium
That's not CFS nor is it ME that's CF via Over-training. The people who keep doing these garbage studies are either biased, ignorant and need a Super Giant Billboard Spelling out exactly what CFS is and isn't or both.
You can also try a Google Site Search
Separate names with a comma.