• Welcome to Phoenix Rising!

    Created in 2008, Phoenix Rising is the largest and oldest forum dedicated to furthering the understanding of, and finding treatments for, complex chronic illnesses such as chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS), fibromyalgia, long COVID, postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS), mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS), and allied diseases.

    To become a member, simply click the Register button at the top right.

Do we know who Jennifer Brea's doctor is?

Hajnalka

Senior Member
Messages
910
Location
Germany
Hi @cyclamen,
but did You try to tackle the POTS or the sleeping problem alone, by going to a new doctor, without telling him about the rest of your health baggage?
I agree that this might be the best option. Most people in German forums say that they try to never mention the diagnosis CFS (on the other hand, how will we manage to raise awareness with doctors this way). My problem is, that I'm not well enough to visit other doctors besides my GP. And I need to see my GP once a month to get a signature for my insurance that I'm still ill (really humiliating every time).
This visit to the GP is my only outing per month and I have to rest the remaining month to be able to do it again. The most absurd thing is that I'd need more doctors' letters and more diagnoses (like e.g. migraines that I'd fulfill easily) for medical retirement but I'm too sick to visit specialists. So I'm somehow not able to retire because I'm disabled because I'm too disabled to go to doctors. I managed to visit one cardiologist and he laughed about the idea that POTS exists and sent me home with the recommendation to exercise more. In addition to the physical effort to visit a doctor, it's the psychological effort too that is really draining. Always absolutely baffles me that PACE authors think we imagine the condition to get attention from doctors - doctors' visits are among the worst parts of this.
I know I have push more and try more doctors and fight for myself but I really don't have the physical strength at the moment and no one who supports this effort. Angry that I wasn't diagnosed earlier, used to have an amazing private insurance (not anymore) and lived in big cities and would have been still healthy enough to visit specialists and try treatments. By the time I was diagnosed 14 years later I was already mostly homebound.

In Germany at the moment I would avoid a diagnosis of CFS from a regular doc at almost all costs.
I have a diagnosis from the Charite. Need to use it (via my GP) for sickness benefits and medical retirement. The only other option would be to use my prior misdiagnosis of depression - that would actually make it much easier with insurance and medical retirement. But it would also prevent any treatment and I'm generally just not willing to put up with that diagnosis anymore, had to live for years with it. In addition, there was an official statement from the German government "No, CFS isn't a problem Germany, just a handful of people retired with this diagnosis", so I want to show up in official statistics to show our numbers. And lastly, if there will be ever any treatment like ritux or cyclo in the future, I want my diagnosis officially registered to be able to get it. :)

The only exemption might be, being a constant(!) patient at the Charité, not depending on other GPs.
That would be absolutely wonderful and I even lived in Berlin at the time I was diagnosed at the Charite. I wasn't prepared at all when I had my appointment and was a little late. Afterwards I read that other people travel there from everywhere in Germany and even neighbor countries and prepare this visit for a year. :rolleyes: I actually believed this was just the first visit of many and it was in my city, so nothing special. When the doctor asked if I have a question, my only question was (somehow sad and funny at the same time in hindsight to be so naiv): "Yes, when will my treatment start and how often will I have to come here?" :rofl: I then was informed to my surprise that I wouldn't be allowed to come back ever. They don't treat CFS patients at the Charite.
I'm not sure about the exceptions, I think from German forums, very, very few people are allowed to come back (about once a year or so) who have severe unusual immunodeficiencies that are interesting for the Charite. And the people who are recruited for small trials (I think 10 people for the current plasmapheresis one), but they only chose people with interesting autoantibodies. So for the majority it's one visit in the Charite, one blood draw and a diagnosis in a letter 4 months later. I had doctors laugh at this letter and no one took the time to read it (several pages), so while I'm extremely grateful for the diagnosis and wouldn't know what to do without it, it's still not widely accepted (e.g. my medical insurance rejected to pay sickness benefits on the basis of the diagnosis from the Charite at first).

Again: Sorry this got so long! :rolleyes: And I guess you know most of this anyway, but maybe the situation in other countries is also interesting for others here.

And sorry @ivorin, for getting slightly off topic. Back on your topic, Jen said in the new science friday podcast, that she tried 200 treatments (my guess is that she included the different supplements in this number too because they talked about them) and explained the difficult treatment situation - and that we need more science to match treatments to the (subgroups of) people who can be helped by them.
 

ivorin

Senior Member
Messages
152
Hi @cyclamen,
I agree that this might be the best option. Most people in German forums say that they try to never mention the diagnosis CFS (on the other hand, how will we manage to raise awareness with doctors this way). My problem is, that I'm not well enough to visit other doctors besides my GP. And I need to see my GP once a month to get a signature for my insurance that I'm still ill (really humiliating every time).
This visit to the GP is my only outing per month and I have to rest the remaining month to be able to do it again. The most absurd thing is that I'd need more doctors' letters and more diagnoses (like e.g. migraines that I'd fulfill easily) for medical retirement but I'm too sick to visit specialists. So I'm somehow not able to retire because I'm disabled because I'm too disabled to go to doctors. I managed to visit one cardiologist and he laughed about the idea that POTS exists and sent me home with the recommendation to exercise more. In addition to the physical effort to visit a doctor, it's the psychological effort too that is really draining. Always absolutely baffles me that PACE authors think we imagine the condition to get attention from doctors - doctors' visits are among the worst parts of this.
I know I have push more and try more doctors and fight for myself but I really don't have the physical strength at the moment and no one who supports this effort. Angry that I wasn't diagnosed earlier, used to have an amazing private insurance (not anymore) and lived in big cities and would have been still healthy enough to visit specialists and try treatments. By the time I was diagnosed 14 years later I was already mostly homebound.

I have a diagnosis from the Charite. Need to use it (via my GP) for sickness benefits and medical retirement. The only other option would be to use my prior misdiagnosis of depression - that would actually make it much easier with insurance and medical retirement. But it would also prevent any treatment and I'm generally just not willing to put up with that diagnosis anymore, had to live for years with it. In addition, there was an official statement from the German government "No, CFS isn't a problem Germany, just a handful of people retired with this diagnosis", so I want to show up in official statistics to show our numbers. And lastly, if there will be ever any treatment like ritux or cyclo in the future, I want my diagnosis officially registered to be able to get it. :)

That would be absolutely wonderful and I even lived in Berlin at the time I was diagnosed at the Charite. I wasn't prepared at all when I had my appointment and was a little late. Afterwards I read that other people travel there from everywhere in Germany and even neighbor countries and prepare this visit for a year. :rolleyes: I actually believed this was just the first visit of many and it was in my city, so nothing special. When the doctor asked if I have a question, my only question was (somehow sad and funny at the same time in hindsight to be so naiv): "Yes, when will my treatment start and how often will I have to come here?" :rofl: I then was informed to my surprise that I wouldn't be allowed to come back ever. They don't treat CFS patients at the Charite.
I'm not sure about the exceptions, I think from German forums, very, very few people are allowed to come back (about once a year or so) who have severe unusual immunodeficiencies that are interesting for the Charite. And the people who are recruited for small trials (I think 10 people for the current plasmapheresis one), but they only chose people with interesting autoantibodies. So for the majority it's one visit in the Charite, one blood draw and a diagnosis in a letter 4 months later. I had doctors laugh at this letter and no one took the time to read it (several pages), so while I'm extremely grateful for the diagnosis and wouldn't know what to do without it, it's still not widely accepted (e.g. my medical insurance rejected to pay sickness benefits on the basis of the diagnosis from the Charite at first).

Again: Sorry this got so long! :rolleyes: And I guess you know most of this anyway, but maybe the situation in other countries is also interesting for others here.

And sorry @ivorin, for getting slightly off topic. Back on your topic, Jen said in the new science friday podcast, that she tried 200 treatments (my guess is that she included the different supplements in this number too because they talked about them) and explained the difficult treatment situation - and that we need more science to match treatments to the (subgroups of) people who can be helped by them.
No matter, it seems we're all doing the same in the end, just jumping through a hundred things till we find stuff that helps at least a bit. Not much more you can do.
 

Mij

Senior Member
Messages
2,353
Got a little long, sorry. I guess I've just very much resentment bottled up about feeling excluded from the medical system. I regularly cry when I'm driven home from doctors' visits because I'm made to feel like I don't deserve any treatment (not even for sleep, pain, POTS) and that no doctor seems to care if I have to retire and spend life in bed with thirtysomething. That's why I'm grateful to Jen that she speaks openly about this topic.

I'm sorry to read this. Your doctor should be treating you for sleep and pain, this is basic care outside of M.E.
 

Hajnalka

Senior Member
Messages
910
Location
Germany
'm sorry to read this. Your doctor should be treating you for sleep and pain, this is basic care outside of M.E.
Thanks @Mij! Yep, but I guess false illness beliefs shouldn't be treated. And our guidelines are very clear that "chronic tiredness syndrome" is not a disease but "a self fulfilling prophecy" and "a rare result of a consultation" and "a diagnostic artifact" and the CCC are called "bodily injury" (because exclusion test are required and tests enforce false illness beliefs). :rolleyes:
 

frederic83

Senior Member
Messages
296
Location
France
That would be absolutely wonderful and I even lived in Berlin at the time I was diagnosed at the Charite. I wasn't prepared at all when I had my appointment and was a little late. Afterwards I read that other people travel there from everywhere in Germany and even neighbor countries and prepare this visit for a year. :rolleyes: I actually believed this was just the first visit of many and it was in my city, so nothing special. When the doctor asked if I have a question, my only question was (somehow sad and funny at the same time in hindsight to be so naiv): "Yes, when will my treatment start and how often will I have to come here?" :rofl: I then was informed to my surprise that I wouldn't be allowed to come back ever. They don't treat CFS patients at the Charite.
I'm not sure about the exceptions, I think from German forums, very, very few people are allowed to come back (about once a year or so) who have severe unusual immunodeficiencies that are interesting for the Charite. And the people who are recruited for small trials (I think 10 people for the current plasmapheresis one), but they only chose people with interesting autoantibodies. So for the majority it's one visit in the Charite, one blood draw and a diagnosis in a letter 4 months later. I had doctors laugh at this letter and no one took the time to read it (several pages), so while I'm extremely grateful for the diagnosis and wouldn't know what to do without it, it's still not widely accepted (e.g. my medical insurance rejected to pay sickness benefits on the basis of the diagnosis from the Charite at first).

I'm french and I saw a TV report with Dr Harald Pruss treating a patient with autoimmune encephalitis. I contacted him and ask if he had something for CFS. He told me to contact Carmen Scheibenbogen. I did and she told me their treatment is symptomatic and sent me an article (similar to what they are doing at Berlin) on good practices regarding CFS. Good information but nothing new for me. I ask her if she knew a CFS doctor in Europe that treats CFS, I already know de Meirleir. She told me to check the ME Network EUROMENE.
Well, that the snake that bites its own tail with this disease.
 

Hajnalka

Senior Member
Messages
910
Location
Germany
I'm french and I saw a TV report with Dr Harald Pruss treating a patient with autoimmune encephalitis. I contacted him and ask if he had something for CFS. He told me to contact Carmen Scheibenbogen. I did and she told me their treatment is symptomatic and sent me an article (similar to what they are doing at Berlin) on good practices regarding CFS. Good information but nothing new for me. I ask her if she knew a CFS doctor in Europe that treats CFS, I already know de Meirleir. She told me to check the ME Network EUROMENE.
Well, that the snake that bites its own tail with this disease.
Hi @frederic83, I agree!

The team at the Charite that diagnosed me is Prof. Scheibenbogen's team, sorry, I didn't make that clear. After the appointment you get a letter with your diagnosis and recommendations for a few supplements.
Since January 2017 sadly only people from Berlin and the surrounding area can be diagnosed in the Charite. I read in German forums that people even try to get fake Berlin addresses because they are desperate. But at the Charite, it's a tiny team of three people with zero government funding for CFS and several other diseases they have to diagnose and study at the same time. When I was there last year, they had one day a week to diagnose CFS patients.

At least Dr. Pruss knew that Prof. Scheibenbogen exists... I guess we can't take anything for granted...:rolleyes: I was at the Charite one year before my CFS-diagnosis with all the classical textbook symptoms ("Since this infection 14 years ago, I feel like I've run a marathon every day and like having a flu, I can't work and can't manage everyday life anymore"...) and they said they had no idea and sent me home - instead of telling me to make an appointment with Prof. Scheibenbogen's team next door. So even in the Charite CFS doesn't seem to be widely known. :aghhh: Did you manage to find a doctor?
 

ivorin

Senior Member
Messages
152
Yes they are.
I developed actual hate for doctors and paychiatrists after having been treated like third grade sh*** and/or being completely ignored for 6.5 years which ended up creating depression and anxiety symptoms which weren't even related to my symptoms but to the appointments. They do bad things to people's minds and blame them. It's a sad thing really.
 

Hajnalka

Senior Member
Messages
910
Location
Germany
paychiatrists
Freudian slip? :rofl:
That's simply perfect! :love: I even paid for one paychiatrist privat at one point, because of insurance problems and because I was desperate to get better - 100 Euro a week over months. I want my money back!

Joh, my ❤️ goes out to You, I`m sorry You are not well enough to do some doctor hopping for some symptoms. And of course I understand Your reasons and it is a shame that You have to pay this hefty price.
Thank you so much @cyclamen! In addition my parents are in their late 70ies, so they can't drive me longer distances. I know its a long shot, but in case you know a doctor in NRW, I'd be happy about a recommendation. :)
 

frederic83

Senior Member
Messages
296
Location
France
The team at the Charite that diagnosed me is Prof. Scheibenbogen's team, sorry, I didn't make that clear. After the appointment you get a letter with your diagnosis and recommendations for a few supplements.
Since January 2017 sadly only people from Berlin and the surrounding area can be diagnosed in the Charite. I read in German forums that people even try to get fake Berlin addresses because they are desperate. But at the Charite, it's a tiny team of three people with zero government funding for CFS and several other diseases they have to diagnose and study at the same time. When I was there last year, they had one day a week to diagnose CFS patients.

At least Dr. Pruss knew that Prof. Scheibenbogen exists... I guess we can't take anything for granted...:rolleyes: I was at the Charite one year before my CFS-diagnosis with all the classical textbook symptoms ("Since this infection 14 years ago, I feel like I've run a marathon every day and like having a flu, I can't work and can't manage everyday life anymore"...) and they said they had no idea and sent me home - instead of telling me to make an appointment with Prof. Scheibenbogen's team next door. So even in the Charite CFS doesn't seem to be widely known. :aghhh: Did you manage to find a doctor?

An idea crossed my mind: to pretend being a migrant and going to Berlin :)

I first self-diagnosed because my results were normal, then I sent tests myself and went to KDM to get deeper tests. In France, they barely recognized CFS, most doctors don't know it and once the classic tests come back negative, they just don't know. You can have antidepressants or antibiotics but nothing else.
Now, I'm looking for treatments mostly, trying various antivirals. I have EBV and think it is the problem for me.
I'm interested in Erkisen's theory.
 

ivorin

Senior Member
Messages
152
An idea crossed my mind: to pretend being a migrant and going to Berlin :)

I first self-diagnosed because my results were normal, then I sent tests myself and went to KDM to get deeper tests. In France, they barely recognized CFS, most doctors don't know it and once the classic tests come back negative, they just don't know. You can have antidepressants or antibiotics but nothing else.
Now, I'm looking for treatments mostly, trying various antivirals. I have EBV and think it is the problem for me.
I'm interested in Erkisen's theory.
Good luck Frederic! You to Joh :)
 
Messages
33

Ambrosia_angel

Senior Member
Messages
544
Location
England
Hi @Ambrosia_angel, JB is very open about her treatment and talks about it on TV, radio and print interviews, in Unrest and has also posted test results (on FB). She said she talks about it for advocacy purposes. The following is not directed at you personally, just my general thoughts on the matter. Sorry this got so long!

I totally agree with @TiredSam, that she's still severely ill and that looks and showing up and pushing through while feeling awful are deceiving. She recently rated herself a 4 out of 10. I think the important point is the progress. She has talked about it in several interviews and you can see in Unrest how she goes from bedridden to walking within days with the right medication. And she ties her improvement to the medication because she collapses if she forgets to take it. So the medication seems to ensure at least a basic level of functioning.

I get that it's strange to talk about another person's treatment. My interest in this is the advocacy angel. I'm not interested to try the stuff she's trying, because we're all so different. JB makes it clear in her interviews that when she talks about her medication, it's not so that people go and try it, but as advocacy. She emphasizes in most interviews that there are probably already existing medications sitting on shelfs that could help (not cure) at least some of us. But we don't know because it has been decades without real clinical trials and most doctors are not interested to try any medication with their ME patients. Also I guess (just my speculation) that she talks about antivirals and other medication in interviews to show that this is an organic disease and we need the appropriate treatment and not CBT/GET. These are all my words, of cause she says everything better and in better English. :)

If I remember correctly in Unrest the ME specialist is the first doctor to find the active infections. Tests and medication could have saved her from 2 years in bed. It just shows what happens if we're not taken seriously. I have to retire in my 30ies and have not been offered any treatment to try in 15 years (apart from CBT and sport). Apparently it's ok if someone is home- and bedbound in her 30ies and that is still not considered bad enough to at least treat symptoms or write a referral or write a prescription for the stuff the Charite recommended in my diagnosis letter. My sister who is a doctor only shrugs me off with "Well nothing can be done for ME". So this is less about JB for me, but an advocacy matter that we're not treated, are not allowed to try any medicine (after all this would enforce false illness beliefs), that there are no big clinical trials (exception Norway) and we still have not one approved drug for 17 million people worldwide after the WHO recognized ME in 1969. And an example of a public figure like JB who is successfully being treated for her symptoms (not cured) shows what a difference it could make if doctors listened and tried to help.

Got a little long, sorry. I guess I've just very much resentment bottled up about feeling excluded from the medical system. I regularly cry when I'm driven home from doctors' visits because I'm made to feel like I don't deserve any treatment (not even for sleep, pain, POTS) and that no doctor seems to care if I have to retire and spend life in bed with thirtysomething. That's why I'm grateful to Jen that she speaks openly about this topic.
I know and I 100% agree with everything you've said. My only worry was that because Jennifer Brea isn't active on here, these sorts of threads will lead to speculation.
I wouldn't have said anything if she was active and involved in the conversation too.
 

priya

permanently dislabeled
Messages
28
hi all,

not able to be on forums much. wanted to chime in that Jen was using Valcyte. she may have changed it to another anti-viral more recently. this is the one she was taking when she started walking more in her house, I'm 99% sure.
 

Hajnalka

Senior Member
Messages
910
Location
Germany
I know and I 100% agree with everything you've said. My only worry was that because Jennifer Brea isn't active on here, these sorts of threads will lead to speculation.
I wouldn't have said anything if she was active and involved in the conversation too.

I get what you mean. Just wanted to ensure you that what has been said here is not speculation but repetitions of what Jen talked about herself in interviews and what people can see on iTunes and in cinemas. She e.g. tweeted about her Coxsackie virus a few days ago (and several times before). Watched an Q and A yesterday where she and Omar talked about the costs for her drugs and about prescriptions and insurance, so they are very open and use the information for advocacy. She's also a member on PR.