Review: 'Through the Shadowlands’ describes Julie Rehmeyer's ME/CFS Odyssey
I should note at the outset that this review is based on an audio version of the galleys and the epilogue from the finished work. Julie Rehmeyer sent me the final version as a PDF, but for some reason my text to voice software (Kurzweil) had issues with it. I understand that it is...
Discuss the article on the Forums.

David Bell Lyndonville News: XMRV Research Update

Discussion in 'XMRV Research and Replication Studies' started by Katrina, Aug 17, 2010.

  1. Katrina


    Central California Coast
    Click Link for Illustrations and further info
    return to Newsletters page

    XMRV Update

    There is so much to update, while at the same time almost nothing is happening on the outside. Except of course the CDC can't find XMRV in CFS, and it is directing the NIH XMRV conference in early September on how to find it. It seems that Dr. Harvey Alter can find it, but his paper was held after being accepted by the very prestigious journal PNAS. Very strange happenings, and I hope that someone is keeping a very accurate diary of all this.

    Of those persons who read this, most of you follow the news carefully, so I will not dwell on it too much. But it has been publicly announced that the NIH is funding an xmrv grant on the Lyndonville outbreak. So we will stay busy.

    In case you missed some of the news.lets see. New York Times article by David Tuller on July 14, 2010 quotes Hillary Johnson as saying, A cabal of top government administrators with a habit of heavy-handed, anti-science manipulation of peer-reviewed science ordered the delay of Dr. Harvey Alter's study. It is always exciting to see what is on Hillary Johnsons web site: Osler's Web.

    Look up Dr. Suzanne Vernon's comments about the CDC study at the CFIDS Association web site. She blasts the CDC study as being poor. She used to work for them.

    Having no inside information whatsoever about the CDC, here are my speculations. On the overly optimistic, (lets give them a break side) maybe the CDC did several studies. First was a simple PCR study just like the three other negative studies involving hundreds of tired people gained from a telephone interview or two, and no XMRV is to be found. Note: of the four published studies, none have tried to replicate Mikovits work. This is very important. It is now clear that if they do several thousand more PCR studies without trying to replicate the WPI work, they will not find it. Time to move on. Try replicating the WPI study and learn something.

    But maybe the CDC is also doing other studies, open minded as they are, and finding it all over the place. Finding it in some controls, the blood supply, and in lots of persons with CFS. Maybe they are stalling in order to gear up for a major assault on CFS and XMRV with clinical trials, serious research, and so on. Maybe just maybe.

    On the negative side, perhaps there is an organized effort to marginalize XMRV, even if it is the cause of CFS, because it may be expensive to treat. We know that this has been done before, with the excuse being "good science". Personally, I would insist on good science, but not political science. Lets find out what is there. If XMRV is marginalized, it will be no more visible to mainstream medical practitioners than the 2'-5' A synthetase, RNAse L, blood volume, isoprostanes, IVRT, natural killer cell data, immune upregulation, and the many other good science that has been done on CFS. It is all meaningless if the patients never get to see the benefit of this science.

    And perhaps most importantly, the Whittemore-Peterson Institute will open next week. For anyone who has been discouraged in the past about the lack of progress, this should be a shot in the arm.

    Research Group News

    I would like to thank the research group for its work and all of you for supporting the group financially. As I mentioned above, we have an NIH grant, and I am a consultant to this grant. As such, I will receive no funds from the NIH for this, and I am perfectly OK with that. All the preliminary data accrued came from your generosity. Your contributions, through Connecticut CFIDS Assn or otherwise, have paid for mailing of questionnaires, blood collection supplies, travel to conferences for myself, statistical help, and pizza for the meetings. So far I have not embezzled funds for a new kidney-bean swimming pool, and have no intentions to do that in the future. The expensive stuff, meaning the XMRV assays, have been paid for from other sources. So we here in Lyndonville are doing just fine. If there are a lot more conferences, that will be good, because it means that there is positive news to report. If that happens, we may need some support.

    Are there new studies in the works? At this point we are quite busy although nothing has shown to the outside world. We did get an NIH grant and that requires pilot data however. My hopes for the future would be to do a comprehensive pediatric study with many of the known researchers sending samples from children and adolescents as well as controls, and possibly a comprehensive neurologic study on the neurological symptoms present in persons positive for XMRV. These studies are way off in the future, and the NIH funding process, if it happens at all is very slow. These studies cannot be done by the research funds petty cash. They are major cash. So if anyone has $100,000 and wants to do one of these, let me know

    Diagnostic Criteria for XAND

    Assuming that research on XMRV really gets going, and it is found to be at the root of CFS in a majority of cases, listed below is my version of the Cadillac diagnostic work-up for CFS or rather, XAND, Xmrv Associated Neuro-immune Disease.

    1. History and Physical Examination

    As the basis for all good clinical medicine, the starting point is a good history and clinical exam. It is also the starting point for a constructive, provider-patient relationship. At some point effective treatments will be more widely known, but they cannot take place without a good relationship with your provider.

    2. Test for XMRV

    At this point in history we do not know the best and most accurate test for XMRV, and it has not been proven to my satisfaction that XMRV is the cause of CFS. However, it is my educated guess that XMRV can be found and that it will turn out to be the cause of this disease. The decision here is based upon how you will use the information, and the expense, as medical insurance will not pay for it.

    3. Blood levels of 3 enzyme system to neutralize ROS (reactive oxygen species)

    Superoxide dismutase (SOD) catalase (Cat) and the ratio of reduced to oxidized glutathione are three enzyme systems that are tasked to treat oxidative stress. If XMRV is the cause of CFS, FM and other related illnesses, it does so by creating massive oxidative stress by knocking out one or more of these enzymes. Their levels can be measured with a blood test in several laboratories. However, again, insurance will not pay for them and your provider may not have heard of them. While still not proven, it is my guess that levels of these enzymes will turn out to be an effective future marker to have if treatment should be attempted.

    4. Blood, urine levels of Isoprostanes

    Isoprostanes are a measure of oxidative stress and may be the link with the proven reduction of circulating blood volume.

    5. ATP production

    ATP production is the bottom line, and we need more studies like the Myhill, Booth, McLaren-Howard study which showed abnormalities in ATP production. Like the other suggestions above, a clinically practical test which will be covered by insurance is not available at the present time.

    6. Echocardiogram with cardiac output while standing and IVRT interrogation with oxygen

    While not published yet in the medical literature, Dr. Cheney's work here should be replicated. The echocardiogram is available, cheap and readily available.

    There are many other tests that can be used to prove the organic nature of CFS: 2'-5'A Synthetase, RNAse L, Natural Killer Cell analysis, cytokine profiles, anaerobic threshold exercise testing. The fact that persons are still told that there are no approved tests for CFS (see CDC website) is intolerable. Many people with severe CFS are deprived of disability because courts are following the suggestions of the CDC. Thus you become unable to "prove" that you are ill, even if you are bedridden.

    Responsible and Irresponsible Medicine

    The above suggestions as to criteria to diagnose XAND are easily dismissed as irresponsible, bad medicine. Modern medicine is based upon good, proven science - not speculation. Placebo therapies are no longer acceptable. And it is not acceptable to falsely raise people's hopes with bogus science. I agree with this 100%. But this process in CFS has gone off track.

    Science will be done only if it is adequately funded. A researcher has to feed his or her family. And the funding agencies generally will fund those studies that prove what they already believe. If you believe that CFS is not "real," you will not vote to fund a study that investigates a hypothesis regarding medical physiology in CFS. It would be a waste of money.

    Medical politics can and will marginalize and stigmatize certain areas in order to keep control of the process. Furthermore, while an open mind is the goal of a scientist, it is rare.

    We need to change the scientific process. We should not discipline providers who, in good faith, treat their patients differently than "mainstream" providers do. Patients are not stupid. We need to loosen our grip on those advances that fall outside of the convenient. The good studies on CFS need to be shared in medical education conferences. Now you only see conferences talking about diabetes and high blood pressure. And this is because the conferences are meant to be easy and are funded by drug companies.

    I once found that a medication I was using to treat CFS had a placebo effect. I found it by doing an inexpensive double blind trial. My patients did feel better but only because I was taking them seriously and trying to help. That is not false hope. After the study, I told them that the medication wasn't helping them. They managed to deal well with the news.

    But the process of proven-only treatments has gone overboard. There are some things that probably help. But we do not know because the process has discarded patients with CFS. It is too expensive, it is difficult to define, what subtypes do you want to study? And so on. No industry is going to fund a study on high dose vitamin B12, because that drug is generic and not patent protected.

    Attempting seriously to get to the bottom of CFS is not false hope. I challenge those who discriminate against and disrespect CFS to make accusations of irresponsible medicine.

    Question and Answer

    Question: Oh, and my vertigo story has taken an interesting turn. Last week I saw a new doctor who was filling in for my family physician. He suspected I have migraine-associated-vertigo and gave me a Maxalt in his office. Within twenty minutes my nausea was gone and most of my balance was restored. It felt like a miracle. He also gave me a referral to a neurologist to talk about preventative medications. I've been struggling with bouts of vertigo since 1995, so this is good news.

    Comment: There is an old paper establishing the link between vertigo, CFS, and migraine (Ash-Bernal R, Wall C, Komaroff A, Bell D, Oas J, Payman R, et al. Vestibular function tests anomalies in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome. Acta Otolaryngol. 1995;115:9-17.) It is quite reasonable to try migraine meds in this situation.

    Question: I have had several episodes of shingles but my doctor will not test them, but suggests the vaccine.

    Comment: I feel that repeated episodes of shingles do occur in CFS and may be related to reduced number or function of natural killer cells. I do not know how CFS patients respond to the vaccine for shingles. But here is what I would do.
    a) ask for a referral to an infectious disease specialist
    b) without being arrogant, ask during the visit if he or she would be willing to follow you if XMRV turns out to be the cause of CFS. If the specialist says no, then you have not lost anything. If the specialist says yes, then you wait. But wait respectfully and patiently.
    c) See the specialist regularly so he or she can get to know you. Maybe when the time is right a treatment will be offered. If XMRV turns out to be the cause of CFS, the infectious disease specialists will embrace it and lead in the treatment efforts.

    It is a great pleasure for me to encourage everyone to buy and read this book. While it seems trite to say, this book really is a triumph of the human spirit. If you thought you understood something about ME/CFS, read this and it is possible you will realize that you understood very little. I learned huge amounts and want to give a copy of it to the family of every patient I have ever had. The writing is magnificent.

    And also, congratulations to D. Lark.

    Sculpture "Free" by D. Lark <>


    To Subscribe: If you wish to either subscribe or unsubscribe to the Lyndonville News, go to and enter your information. The e-mail subscription is free.

    Disclaimer Any medical advice that is presented in the Lyndonville News is generic and for general informational purposes only. ME/CFS/FM is an extremely complex illness and specific advice may not be appropriate for an individual with this illness. Therefore, should you be interested or wish to pursue any of the ideas presented here, please discuss them with your personal physician.


    2010 David S. Bell
  2. Otis

    Otis Señor Mumbler


    WOW. Thanks for posting this. I just love Dr. Bell. He's swinging for the fences. Just a few gems.

    I know it's been his nature to be the easy-going country Dr., but he's decided to take a stand and is speaking his mind.

    Love it.
  3. markmc20001

    markmc20001 Guest

    "No industry is going to fund a study on high dose vitamin B12, because that drug is generic and not patent protected."

    "These studies are way off in the future, and the NIH funding process, if it happens at all is very slow. These studies cannot be done by the research fund’s petty cash. They are major cash. So if anyone has $100,000 and wants to do one of these, let me know……"

    Sure highlights the need for the WPI and other funding( outside of government)
  4. JT1024

    JT1024 Senior Member

    I've posted this newsletter either here or on other sites...... no brain to remember where but Dr. Bell is great!

    In the last two days, I've seen two heavyweights in the ME/CFS world ( Dr. Bell & Annette Whittemore) bring up the failure of the CDC in public forums. It's about time.

    Can't wait for more information to be published to finally dispel the myths surrounding ME/CFS and other neuro-immune disorders. Time to kick butt and ask questions of those who obstructed the truth.

    It's also time to move on with REAL science. Enough of the political agendas of self preservation.
  5. Sasha

    Sasha Fine, thank you

    The book in question is The Sound of a Wild Snail Eating, which is published next week. It looks like the sort of thing that would make me want to punch someone but that if I were a better person with a more advanced sensibility, I would enjoy! I may need a personality transplant (which perhaps is the point of the book!). The fact that Dr Bell is recommending it is the view that you should take seriously, not mine!:D

    ETA: Just read the first few pages on the Amazon preview thingy and couldn't stop reading! I take it all back! I thought it was going to be a very different kind of book, based on the blurb. I think I'm going to have to order it from the library now! (Oh, so fickle).
  6. Andrew

    Andrew Senior Member

    Los Angeles, USA
    I think they CDC made their position clear when they claimed that neurological symptoms are exclusionary for CFS/ME. Looking at the cohort for which CFS was named, this is clearly not true ( There are some key people at the CDC who are not above telling lies to save face, even if it means destroying our heath by discouraging doctors from giving appropriate tests. I'd tell you what I think should be done to these people, but doing so would be inconsistent with my normal style of posting.

See more popular forum discussions.

Share This Page