• Welcome to Phoenix Rising!

    Created in 2008, Phoenix Rising is the largest and oldest forum dedicated to furthering the understanding of, and finding treatments for, complex chronic illnesses such as chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS), fibromyalgia, long COVID, postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS), mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS), and allied diseases.

    To become a member, simply click the Register button at the top right.

What type of doctor has helped you the most? (MD, neuro, IM, FM, chiro, naturopath etc)

dangermouse

Senior Member
Messages
430
I had a really good GP but she had to leave her job to look after her mother. I've not had good experiences with Rheumatologists, more so the dismissive attitude and stubbornness to acknowledge ME separately from Fibromyalgia. My Cardiologist seems knowledgeable about ME and knew not to prescribe certain medications and how sensitive ME patients can be to drugs.
 

JamBob

Senior Member
Messages
191
I once had an amazing GP who worked in partnership with patients and was willing to try different stuff.

Doctors with a generalist training (like GPs or internists) work better for me than superspecialists as I have a lot of diseases and need someone who can think in the round and handle complexity rather than someone with super specialised knowledge who narrowly focuses on one organ. Obviously for surgery you might want a super specialist but for chronic disease I need a different kind of whole systems approach.
 

David Jackson

Senior Member
Messages
195
For me, it hasn't been any kind of doctor at all; rather it has been the completely alternative type of health practitioners, most especially those that work with the body's subtle energies, like chakras, auras, Qi, prana, etc. My herbalist, also has helped me out a great deal.

Of course, I will still go to see a doctor and get medical tests done, so I don't advocate completely giving up on the medical establishment. However, I do think that chronically sick people in general can neglect to look in this very alternative direction, which, in my humble opinion, may be able to help them out, sometimes considerably.
 

Sushi

Moderation Resource Albuquerque
Messages
19,935
Location
Albuquerque
I haven't found that you can say anything about a particular specialty--it is more about the individual doctor and what they know about ME/CFS. There are ME/CFS specialists who come from a wide variety of specialties--including someone like Dr. David Bell who I think is a GP or specialized in family practice (that is from memory, don't take it as fact).
 

Hugo

Senior Member
Messages
230
A good Infectious Disease Specialist would be nice, I meet one once and she was very strange. She was terrible in attitude but for some reason gave me prescriptions for a lot of stuff, that was beyond strange because she told me that I wasnt sick and in the same sentence she gave me antiviral and a prescriptions for stereoids.

Like having Trump for a doctor. She contradict herself in nearly every sentence.
 

Hugo

Senior Member
Messages
230
I haven't find that you can say anything about a particular specialty--it is more about the individual doctor and what they know about ME/CFS. There are ME/CFS specialists who come from a wide variety of specialties--including someone like Dr. David Bell who I think is a GP or specialized in family practice (that is from memory, don't take it as fact).

True but in my experience its mostly GP, but on the other hand its the most common specialists and they also meet the same patients several times.
 

Mij

Senior Member
Messages
2,353
@Dechi the M.E specialist who diagnosed me (partner of Dr.Hyde) told me "there is no treatment or breakthroughs and to condition my life around it".
 

Dechi

Senior Member
Messages
1,454
@Dechi the M.E specialist who diagnosed me (partner of Dr.Hyde) told me "there is no treatment or breakthroughs and to condition my life around it".

Dr Hyde says there are some drugs on trial right now who might work. He also told me moderately affected people like me usually don't recover. But I won't stop fighting ! :)
 

Mary

Moderator Resource
Messages
17,376
Location
Southern California
Thanks for all your replies! I think I was hoping for a magic bullet of sorts (which I know doesn't exist :oops:)

I tend to agree that it's the individual doctor who is open-minded and willing to be educated, etc. who is the most effective, rather than any specialist. My original doctor who helped me get disability for ME/CFS (he died last year unfortunately) did not know much about ME/CFS (though who does?!), but he was extremely knowledgeable about nutrition and was also very open-minded and willing to help me try new things that I would bring to his attention. I haven't found anyone to replace him yet.

I did see Dr. Kaufman at OMI and he was not able to help me, though he was a nice man. Most of the help I have gotten has been either through my own research and self-experimentation or from muscle testing done by a competent practitioner.

I am going to see a naturopath/chiropractor/doctor of Oriental medicine on Thursday to see if he can help with sleep issues - it's a crap shoot, either he will or won't - wish me luck!
 

Dechi

Senior Member
Messages
1,454
@Mary Good luck with your appointment ! I've really thought about going to see a traditionnal chinese doctor and it's still something I'd like to do. Please tell us about it !