Yeah I know I read her blog. Science also carried a story entitled 'False Positive'. Don't know who got the idea first really. Did you see/read Jamie's comment on Racaniello's site by any chance? I don't think she was very happy - but I felt the 'burning cross' was over the top. Still Racaniello pulled the T-Shirt image didn't he? After receiving a more reasonable request. Anyway, what did you think of the above? Racaniello said something about another paper coming out in a few weeks - wonder what that is all about?