MEAdvocacy.org Update and a Call for Continued Support
“I have tried raising money by asking for it, and by not asking for it. I always got more by asking for it.”
Discuss the article on the Forums.

The Wonders of Prebiotics

Discussion in 'The Gut: De Meirleir & Maes; H2S; Leaky Gut' started by Hip, Oct 6, 2010.

  1. xjhuez

    xjhuez Senior Member

    Messages:
    175
    Likes:
    42
    I can handle psyllium just fine, but supplemental inulin I'll never take again. It caused me terrible gas and then steatorhea. Not sure what this implies about my gut microflora.
     
  2. Christopher

    Christopher Senior Member

    Messages:
    499
    Likes:
    195
    Pennsylvania
    @Hip when you say you cut out sugars, did you mean most carbohydrates?
     
  3. JAM

    JAM Jill

    Messages:
    419
    Likes:
    453
    I have never taken prebiotics as supplements, but as foods. Pumpkin and summer squash are daily staples that helped my gut heal significantly. Still get occasional pain, but it is much less severe and the frequency and duration have decreased significantly. Pumpkin pie for breakfast will never get old! ;)
     
    Little Bluestem likes this.
  4. Hip

    Hip Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,779
    Likes:
    3,907
    No, I just cut out sugar as in sucrose, by switching to diet drinks, artificial sweeteners in tea or coffee, and avoiding sugary snacks.
     
  5. JAM

    JAM Jill

    Messages:
    419
    Likes:
    453
    There are so many health risks with artificial sweeteners. Why not just go to less refined natural sweeteners? My body accepts honey and dehydrated cane juice well.
     
    Sammy and end like this.
  6. Hip

    Hip Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,779
    Likes:
    3,907
    There's lots of conflicting research, but very little conclusive evidence of any risks.
     
  7. madietodd

    madietodd Senior Member

    Messages:
    2,540
    Likes:
    1,923
    East Coast, USA
    There are a lot of studies taking a new look at artificial sweeteners and insulin resistance. It's early days yet, but it's worth keeping any eye on the research. For example, this.
     
  8. Hip

    Hip Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,779
    Likes:
    3,907
    @madietodd

    That article said that sucralose's effect on insulin might even be beneficial. But they just don't know.

    Probably the safest artificial sweetener is stevia, but unfortunately it is also the most expensive.
     
  9. acer2000

    acer2000 Senior Member

    Messages:
    666
    Likes:
    449
    I think there is conflicting opinion about pre-biotics for people with GI upset issues because on one hand they help feed the benificial bacteria, but on the other hand many people with GI upset and "IBS" like symptoms have SIBO which by definition is overgrowth of bacteria in the small bowl. So there is some concern that adding pre-biotics (other than what is in the diet) could make it worse. I will admit though I'd like to see an actual study that shows this.
     
    Star-Anise likes this.
  10. JAM

    JAM Jill

    Messages:
    419
    Likes:
    453
    I have always had severe IBS pain and increasing pre-biotic foods really helped decrease the pain. That seemed to be typical according to the studies I read. If you find anything that contradicts that please let me know.
     
  11. Hip

    Hip Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,779
    Likes:
    3,907
    I guess you have a point there. Intestinal dysbiosis is where the harmful bacteria or fungi in the large intestine outgrow the beneficial bacteria; but SIBO is an overgrowth of any type of bacteria, good or bad, in the small intestine.

    So theoretically prebiotics, which is food for the good bacteria, could make SIBO worse. However, I found this study which found that augmenting antibiotic therapy for SIBO with either probiotics or prebiotics were both helpful.
     
    Star-Anise likes this.
  12. Star-Anise

    Star-Anise Senior Member

    Messages:
    205
    Likes:
    114
    Hi all!
    @Hip
    Thanks for the useful information.

    Working on suspected SIBO. Found some success with Garden of Life probiotic with Homeostatic Soil Organisms (HSOs). It was the best probiotic I had ever tried! As well have had great success with Unmodified potato starch, & have weaned myself off of all of the methylfolate I was on, & feeling far better.

    However, I still noticed bloating in small intestine area & difficulty if my diet wasn't perfect, so I decided to try Larch.

    After the first few doses - been trying 1/4 tsp one time per day, I noticed some general improvement in my upper gut, and mood improvement.

    However, after those first few days, I have become increasingly gassy with pain, about 4-5 hours after I take the larch, and so very, very bloated.
    I also have a headache & increased malaise.

    I'm wondering detox? Too much too fast? Any feedback re: people's experiences with larch?

    I also coincidentally ran out of probiotics around time I started larch. My plan is to resume asap. Get some more probiotics into me, and then while on the probiotics maybe try a smaller dose of larch.

    Is there any other prebiotic that I should be trying 1st though? I have tried psyllium & don't respond well. I get very gassy & increased malaise with bloating as well, with none of the positive effects.

    Any suggestions would be welcoming. I'm trying to avoid spending ++$$ and more pain/discomfort by trial/error, but maybe this is also just part of the process too....

    All the very best to everyone,

    S
     
  13. JAM

    JAM Jill

    Messages:
    419
    Likes:
    453
    I don't do well on any of the prebiotics taken alone, only the whole foods. So eat a lot of pumpkin and other squashes. Any vegetables high in soluble fiber are good. I also took GasX when I started upping the soluble fiber in my diet. It takes a while for the bugs to stabilize, and GasX made the transition much easier.
     
    Star-Anise and Little Bluestem like this.
  14. optimist

    optimist Senior Member

    Messages:
    342
    Likes:
    259
    Norway
    Thanks for the informative post @Hip! Have you guys heard of/tried Molkosan? I have tested it for about a week now, 2x15ml together with 16 billion/8 strain probiotics a day. It has definitely not made me worse, but I am starting to wonder if I see a little positive effect. It would be nice to try introducing some of the prebiotics you are suggesting here on top of my current protocol.

    I've seen at one of our local super markeds that there's a bag with the name "Husk" on it. Do you know if there are other foods than the one you mention here called husk? Anyways, I will have a closer look at it if there's mentioned something about Ispaghula/psyllium on it when I am there.
     
  15. optimist

    optimist Senior Member

    Messages:
    342
    Likes:
    259
    Norway
    I know I can be a bit slow minded, so this could be worth keeping in mind when taking husk:
     
  16. end

    end *****

    Messages:
    263
    Likes:
    151

    As Dr Natasha Campbell-McBride has stated in her book many times is that prebiotics feed both the good and the bad bacteria in the GUT, so depending on exactly what your colonised with when supplementing prebiotics will determine your results.

    Negative effects would probably indicate a high pathogenic load.

    The GAPS nutritional protocol selectively feeds the good and eliminates the bad.

    It is a harsh diet though, and many sledge it as a result.
     
  17. Hip

    Hip Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,779
    Likes:
    3,907
    As mentioned earlier in this thread, prebiotics are by their definition, a food source that is far more assimilable by the beneficial bacteria in the gut, than by the pathogenic bacteria.

    More specifically, the actual 1995 defintion of "prebiotic" is:
    Source: Dietary modulation of the human colonic microbiota: introducing the concept of prebiotics.

    See also: Prebiotics: The Concept Revisited.

    So if something feeds the bad bacteria in the gut and thereby undermines heath, it is not a prebiotic, by the definition of the term "prebiotic".
     
  18. end

    end *****

    Messages:
    263
    Likes:
    151
    @Hip

    I understand the various definition's of "prebiotics"

    *What I am outlining is that the GAPS nutritional protocol by Dr Natasha Campbell-McBride PROHIBITS them ie inulin - I recall specifically.

    I guess one persons definition, does not always reflect another's.

    Hip, like the L-Glutamine thread outlined - a specific compound is not always universally beneficial to all who take it. The trick is, understanding exactly why it is that way in your case.

    I miss Rich Van K as he always tried to identify the reasons as to, why.
     
    Last edited: Dec 25, 2014
  19. Hip

    Hip Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,779
    Likes:
    3,907
    @end
    As far as I can work out, it was that above-citied 1995 paper by Gibson and Roberfroid which first defined and introduced the concept of prebiotics, so the notion of a "prebiotic" appears to be their invention.

    Though I can imagine it is possible that some people may get ill effects from taking the prebiotics that are generally beneficial for the most of the population.

    Does Campbell-McBride explain why she prohibits prebiotics?
     
  20. end

    end *****

    Messages:
    263
    Likes:
    151
    http://gapsaustralia.com.au/bio-kult/

    "[A: There seems to be a trend engaging the market for prebiotics or probiotics with prebiotics contained within them. In light of this, Dr Natasha advises that prebiotics generally feed pathogens as well as beneficial microbes and that is why they are on the avoid list and for this reason she does not recommend using them at the beginning of the programme. Patients who start prebiotics too soon will have symptoms associated with flatulence and bloating."
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    @Hip
    I imagine like I stated above. Probably because of a high "pathogenic load" in your GUT which results in negative effects.

    Fairly simple, if PREbiotics give you flatulence and bloating like Dr Natasha Campbell-McBride has stated, you probably have a high pathogenic load and should avoid taking them initialy.
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    UOTE="Hip, post: 538820, member: 249"]@end
    As far as I can work out, it was that above-citied 1995 paper by Gibson and Roberfroid which first defined and introduced the concept of prebiotics, so the notion of a "prebiotic" appears to be their invention.

    Though I can imagine it is possible that some people may get ill effects from taking the prebiotics that are generally beneficial for the most of the population.

    Does Campbell-McBride explain why she prohibits prebiotics?[/QUOTE]
     
    Last edited: Dec 25, 2014

See more popular forum discussions.

Share This Page