1. Patients launch a $1.27 million crowdfunding campaign for ME/CFS gut microbiome study.
    Check out the website, Facebook and Twitter. Join in donate and spread the word!
Embracing Change - ME and the International Classification of Diseases
The WHO ICD featured recently in an online article (since withdrawn), which heightened patient concern over what might happen when the current ICD-10 is finally revised. N.A.Wright provides a timely summary of this international classification system, considers some of the issues...
Discuss the article on the Forums.

Peter White/Barts - comments on draft NICE guidelines - insight into their views

Discussion in 'Action Alerts and Advocacy' started by Dolphin, Dec 15, 2009.

  1. Mithriel

    Mithriel Senior Member

    Messages:
    563
    Likes:
    36
    Scotland
    This might be what you want Mark. It has just been released.

    Mary Schwietzer was a university lecturer until she became ill and writes very incisive essays.

    She says what I believe so much better than I could.

    Mithriel
    Enid likes this.
  2. parvofighter

    parvofighter Senior Member

    Messages:
    436
    Likes:
    98
    Canada
    Playing NICE: circle time is over

    Thanks tomk, Mithriel, cjbrennan for your great posts. Allow me to expand on this NICE theme.:);):D

    In my view, discussion of CBT/GET as primary treatment for ME/CFS is as irrelevant to the XMRV finding - and to the scientific pursuit of an ME/CFS patient getting better - as one can get. And before anyone shoots me down for my transgression, I'm speaking not only as a decade-long, PCR/immunohistochemistry biopsy-confirmed case of persistent parvovirus B19 and ME/CFS, but also as a former medical professional with double degrees in Rehabilitation Medicine.

    Allow me to qualify this: CBT as a coping strategy, while the big boys (i.e. molecular biologists, retrovirologists, hematologists, oncologists, cardiologists, exercise physiologists, etc) do their work to treat this biological illness? Sure. GET as a pick-me-up after, say, all chance of exercise-induced cytokine storms and aberrant auto-immune response etc. has been eliminated with antiretrovirals, immunomodulators, and targeted antiviral therapy for opportunistic infections? Sure.

    Any physiotherapist/ occupational therapist/ physiatrist (and even psychiatrist - there are a few stellar ones researching ME/CFS) worth their salt would be jumping through hoops in enthusiasm, to learn more about post-exertional malaise and VO2Max abnormalities (eg. U of Pacific), mitochondrial dysfunction, opportunistic infections, RNase-L dysfunction, genetic signatures, etc. And of course XMRV. So indeed it's no surprise that Ivy League university Cornell has just joined the illustrious WPI team. Or that there's a veritable international race to replicate WPI's findings. Or that 75 of America's top virologists/retrovirologists dropped everything to meet at the Cleveland Clinic to fast-track XMRV research.

    Please heaven, give us a break with this unscientific CBT/GET-as-treatment-drivel. Rest assured, as a good rehab professional I've been there, desperately trying to toe the party line. Done that. Made me profoundly worse - not just once, but many times, because I was so sure that I could judiciously exercise my way out of this beast. And no, I'm not just a sample size of 1. If the CBT/GET lobby were to come down from its lofty perch and care to listen to ME/CFS patients with classic post-exertional malaise (particularly those with Canadian or Fukuda classified ME/CFS), the verdict is unanimous. Graded exercise - much less ANY exercise - can be and is poison, particularly to people with PEM and who can't do basic activities of daily living (ADL).

    Frankly, I'd be grateful if avid proponents of CBT/GET-as-treatment-for-ME/CFS could conduct this vapid marketing elsewhere, or on a dedicated marketing thread, where respondents want a monotonous, single-theme infomercial rooted in narcissism, rather than intelligent discourse on diverse matters that deeply affect our health. My observation is that the vast majority of people on this forum want to LEARN, and most importantly, want to GET BETTER!!! CBT/GET as a core strategy in our ME/CFS community's pursuit of health is illogical, unscientific, and downright bizarre.

    It does raise the issue of moral hazard however, and the MBA in me gets it that a veritable multi-million $/ CBT/GET industry built on the lives of patients suffering from a retrovirus and known opportunistic persistent viral infections is understandably loath to relinquish its cash cow.

    Additionally, I am reminded of the research finding a disproportionately high rate of Narcissistic Personality Disorder in the medical profession. Self-selection in action. Think: someone who despite the facts continues to propagate his/her skewed view of reality. Someone who will stop at nothing to get his/her way. Someone who is clinically incapable of empathy. To my fellow ME/CFS patients. Look up Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) I know you guys are beautifully internet literate, and thank heavens for the power this gives us. I will eat my Canadian Winter Olympics hat if key personalities in the CBT/GET saga dont have NPD. But then again, NPDers are clinically devoid of insight they will never get the grievous damage they have foisted on this patient group. And they won't stop unless we stop them. Thankfully WPI is doing just that.

    Those of us who are fighting to get our lives back from this devastating illness and the chorus is resounding on this forum are not deaf or blind to the CBT/GET lobbys thinly-veiled malice, and concerted effort to show us - and the world - the error of our misguided ways. To the CBT/GET lobby, please do not mistake our silent observing of your obfuscations for meek agreement with your flat-earth exhortations.

    Weve got science on our side. Which, not coincidentally, underscores that the symptoms we've been describing to our docs for the past several decades are quite simply the unvarnished TRUTH. As for the inevitably crumbling CBT/GET lobby?

    Its a tale told by an idiot.
    Full of sound and fury.
    Signifying nothing.
  3. Dolphin

    Dolphin Senior Member

    Messages:
    6,309
    Likes:
    4,084
    Haven't watched it in a while but perhaps the Sleepydust video might be of some value?

    Sleepydust - About M.E. / Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0w9-eQ_fKQ

    This video has a procession of photos of people with severe/very severe M.E. - in effect, it is like lots of people saying it destroyed their life:
    Raising awareness of severe M.E.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0w9-eQ_fKQ

    You could start a thread in this forum with heading: "looking for internet material to direct family and friends to" and then post what you are looking for and see what comes forward. This particular thread is quite a special interest thread so probably won't get as many responses as you could by posting it here.
  4. Dolphin

    Dolphin Senior Member

    Messages:
    6,309
    Likes:
    4,084
    Glad we have you on our side, parvofighter.
    Fingers crossed that it is crumbling. For the 15 years I've been diagnosed and severely affected, they have been hampering progress into the illness and spreading misinformation as you alude to. And in some countries in particular (e.g. the UK, the Netherlands, Belgium), they have pretty much taken over.

    By the way, what is that quote from? It sounds familiar. Is it by one of the World War One poets (wild guess)?
  5. Dolphin

    Dolphin Senior Member

    Messages:
    6,309
    Likes:
    4,084
    There might also be books that might suit.
  6. Mithriel

    Mithriel Senior Member

    Messages:
    563
    Likes:
    36
    Scotland
    Parvofighter, your post says it all so well.

    I became ill in 1968 and was finally diagnosed with ME in 1984. My OH is a microbiologist who read Eleanor Bell's wonderful paper which showed that ME existed as sporadic cases as well as epidemics and that cases were there if anyone looked for them. I am trying to find a copy of it as no one mentions it any more.

    She finished by saying that she feared hospital waiting rooms were full of very sick undiagnosed patients who were being treated with disdain by doctors who were failing them. Almost thirty years later the situation is worse than ever.

    For a few brief years ME was taken seriously and we had hope, then came the CDC and Wessely with their CFS .....

    I hope this is a new dawn.

    Mithriel
  7. Quilp

    Quilp Senior Member

    Messages:
    174
    Likes:
    128
    Thanks tomk

    You have put a great deal of work into this thread and gone a long way to highlighting the carp we have to go through here in the UK.
    Further to your excellent points I would like it known that the other chief architect pertaining to the NICE guidelines is Simon Wessely.

    I want to make this very clear; Simon Wessely has stated ( this is on public record ) that using these guidelines 'one third of M.E patients went on to make a full recovery, two thirds make a significant recovery and the rest we can't do anything for'.
    Underpinning this diaspora, this 'corollary' of propagandist egregiousness is the fact that Peter White has said that we are 'the least deserving sick in society', that we suffer from 'abnormal illness beliefs' in that we are responsible for pertuating symptoms hitherto of our own making.
    There are no words to describe these crimes.

    Kind regards, Mark
  8. Quilp

    Quilp Senior Member

    Messages:
    174
    Likes:
    128
    25 years of hurt

    We have become part of a lost generation. I pray that we will all find our way back one day.

    Kind regards, Mark
  9. CJB

    CJB Senior Member

    Messages:
    743
    Likes:
    387
    Oregon
    The quote is from Shakespeare -- Macbeth, I think.

    ETA I think the Phoenix Rising site that Cort has put together is a very good place to direct friends and family who want to dig down into the facts and it's getting more comprehensive all of the time.
  10. Dolphin

    Dolphin Senior Member

    Messages:
    6,309
    Likes:
    4,084
    Thanks - makes sense as that is one of the Shakespeare plays we studied in school (along with Henry IV part 1).
  11. Dolphin

    Dolphin Senior Member

    Messages:
    6,309
    Likes:
    4,084
    Thanks for that, Mark.

    BTW, KCL where Simon Wessely/Trudie Chalder have been based also sent in some critical comments of the draft NICE guidelines along similar lines to Peter White/Barts but they didn't send in as much. But they've written more than their fair share of this sort of stuff over the years.
  12. parvofighter

    parvofighter Senior Member

    Messages:
    436
    Likes:
    98
    Canada
    One-stop-shopping for ME info; Media ideas

    @tomk & mithriel, I do indeed believe that we are witnessing the very beginning of the crumbling of the CBT/GET lobby. This barbaric approach to a biological disease that ruins lives MUST be shouted from the rooftops. Not just because we are fellow sufferers with ME/CFS. But because we are citizens of this world. I thought I had it bad, fighting here in Canada for diagnosis and treatment for 11 years. Losing my health. My sense of character. My ability to be a deeply involved parent & spouse. My life-long friends. My company. My career. My exuberant sports hobbies (skiing, windsurfing, backpacking, rollerblading, canoe portaging...). Then I read about the CBT/GET lobby. I read about Bell's "Munchausen-by-proxy" ME/CFS children, ripped from their families. About UK/EU patients categorically denied biologically-based medical care, committed to psychiatric institutions for "faulty illness beliefs". This MUST be stopped.

    @Quilip, we ARE a lost generation - and so are our kids. The ripple effects of the disdain and criminal neglect ME/CFS patients have endured from the medical profession - much less from the CBT/GET psych lobby - are the stuff of blockbuster movies. Tom Hanks (Philadelphia Story), Michael Moore(his documentaries), Stephen Spielberg (Schindler's List). We NEED some big Hollywood/Cannes names to see this story for what it is: a riveting, nauseating, head-shaking expos of how terrifyingly barbaric humans can be to each other; and how capricious medical care can be. This is a perfect example of the banality of evil, and it is extraordinarily telegenic. And the clincher: this could happen to anyone! We just need to catch the eye of the media/book/film world - and quickly - before more ME/CFS'ers lose their lives. FYI Anyone can submit a story idea to: Michael Moore @ http://www.michaelmoore.com/submit Not sure about Spielberg and Hanks

    @cjbrennan. You're right.:D The quote is from Shakespeare's Macbeth, Act 5, Scene 5::). It's Macbeth's Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow soliloquy. Geez, that guy could write. Too bad he isn't around to provide his profound commentary now. But then again, he still is, in the genius of his writing. Shakespeare so GOT the blackest depths of human nature.

    Tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow,
    Creeps in this petty pace from day to day
    To the last syllable of recorded time,
    And all our yesterdays have lighted fools
    The way to dusty death. Out, out, brief candle!
    Life's but a walking shadow, a poor player
    That struts and frets his hour upon the stage
    And then is heard no more: it is a tale
    Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury,
    Signifying nothing.


    @cjbrennan - Good idea. I also agree that the Phoenix Rising site is a great one-stop shop to direct friends & family to.
    I wonder if Cort might do a "ME/CFS for dummies" summary that has all the research meat in it & the debunking of the "ME/CFS is imaginary" myth, in one concise article, hotlinked to the details in his site? I also love how this diagram summarizes the Canadian/Fukuda/ criteria vs CBT/GET lobby's self-serving, empire-building "criteria":

    [​IMG]
  13. Mithriel

    Mithriel Senior Member

    Messages:
    563
    Likes:
    36
    Scotland
  14. Dolphin

    Dolphin Senior Member

    Messages:
    6,309
    Likes:
    4,084
    Yes, it is depressing.

    One slightly positive thing was that I remember Dr. Chia saying he found the work of UK researchers on the area (of Coxsackie viruses in the illness) useful when he was learning about the area - if there wasn't that research in the UK in the 80s and 90s, he might have given up and possibly never done the work he has.
  15. fresh_eyes

    fresh_eyes happy to be here

    Messages:
    900
    Likes:
    4
    mountains of north carolina
    @ parvo, I'm totally with you. I continue to be just absolutely...horrified, appalled, etc. etc. - with what is happening in the UK. It seems to me to go beyond medical malpractice and into a human rights abuse. The banality of evil is exactly right, everybody "just doing their jobs".

    I've wondered, looking at Levi's "Unexplained Illnesses" Joint Resolution thread, if all this might be something to bring up with the United Nations or some human rights org (Amnesty International?). It does seem like a human rights violation to presume insanity in the case of unexplained illness. Doesn't it??
  16. parvofighter

    parvofighter Senior Member

    Messages:
    436
    Likes:
    98
    Canada
    A new Human Rights Advocacy string?

    @fresh eyes - brilliant idea re: human rights issue. UN. Amnesty International. World Health Organization. Medcins sans Frontiers/Doctors without Borders. What do you think of starting up a new string on this?

    I"m going to be out of commission for a couple of days, but will check back.
  17. Countrygirl

    Countrygirl Senior Member

    Messages:
    726
    Likes:
    320
    UK
    Human Rights



    Just a thought .......could the European Bill of Human Rights help us? I took a copy of it along to an appeal tribunal, placed it conspicuously on the table in front of the panel of folk who were to decide my fate . and I won! Dunno where my copy is now....:mad:
  18. xanadu

    xanadu

    Messages:
    63
    Likes:
    1
    Human rights?

    They will say it's neurosis, not insanity. And doctors make that diagnosis all the time...

    xan
  19. Orla

    Orla Senior Member

    Messages:
    445
    Likes:
    36
    I thought people might be interested in this piece by Peter White (and a colleague, Anthony Clare - who is dead now) in a medical text book that is very widely used in the UK, and has been translated into other languages.

    The index entry for ME directs the reader to the entry for CFS. There is a very small entry in the infectious diseases seciton under the heading Postviral/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, which states "Studies have suggested that two-thirds of patients with a symptom duration of more than 6 months have an underlying psychiatric disorder".

    As CFS wouid normally not be diagnosed within this timeframe, that means basically most of us have a psychiatric reason for our symptoms (according to them).


    This section (and the index entry on CFS) then directs then reader to the CFS piece in Section 22 (Psychological Medicine), where CFS/ME is listed nder "Functional or Psychsomatic Disorders: Medically Unexplained Symptoms".

    Anyway this is the text below and the details of the book.

    Kumar and Clark - Clinical Medicine

    By Parveen Kumar, CBE, BSc, MD, FRCP, FRCP (Edin), Professor of
    Clinical Medical Education, Barts and The London, Queen Mary's School
    of Medicine and Dentistry, University of London, and Honorary
    Consultant Physician and Gastroenterologist, Barts and The London NHS
    Trust, London, UK; and Michael Clark, MD, FRCP, Honorary Senior
    Lecturer, Barts and The London, Queen Mary's School of Medicine and
    Denistry, University of London, UK

    ISBN 0702027634 Paperback 1528 Pages 1283 Illustrations
    Saunders Published August 2005


    ----------------

    Contributors include:

    ----------------

    Anthony W Clare MD FRCPI FRCP FRCPsych MPhil
    Professor of Clinical Psychiatry
    Trinity College, Dublin;
    Medical Director
    St Patrick's Hospital, Dublin, Ireland

    ---------------------------------

    Peter D White MD FRCP FRCPsych
    Senior Lecturer in Psychological Medicine, Honorary Consultant in
    Liaison Psychiatry
    Barts and The London, Queen Mary's School of Medicine and Dentistry,
    University of London, UK

    -----------------------------------

    <>

    We all have illness behaviour when we choose what to do about a
    symptom. Going to see a doctor is generally more likely with more
    severe and more numerous symptoms and greater distress. It is also
    more likely in introspective individuals who focus on their health.

    Abnormal illness behaviour occurs when there is a discrepancy between
    the objective somatic pathology present and the patient's response to
    it, in spite of adequate medical investigation arid explanation.

    FUNCTIONAL OR PSYCHOSOMATIC DISORDERS: MEDICALLY UNEXPLAINED SYMPTOMS

    `Functional' disorders are illnesses in which there is no obvious
    pathology or anatomical change in an organ (thus in contrast
    to `organic and there is a presumed dysfunction in an organ or
    system. The word psycho-somatic has had several meanings, including
    psychogenic, `all in the mind'; imaginary and malingering. The modern
    meaning is that psychosomatic disorders are syndromes of unknown
    aetiology in which both physical and psychological factors are likely
    to be causative, The psychiatric classification of these disorders
    would be somatoform disorders, but they do not fit easily within
    either medical or psychiatric classification systems, since they
    occupy the hinterland between them. Medically unexplained symptoms
    and syndromes are very common in both primary care and the general
    hospital (over half the outpatients in gastroenterology and neurology
    clinics have these syndromes). Because orthodox medicine has not been
    particularly effective in treating or understanding these disorders,
    many patients perceive their doctors as unsympathetic and seek out
    complementary treatments of uncertain efficacy. Examples of
    functional disorders are shown in Table 22.4.

    Because epidemiological studies suggest that having one of these
    syndromes significantly increases the risk of having another, some
    doctors believe that these syndromes represent different
    manifestations in time of `one functional syndrome', which is
    indicative of a somatization process. Functional disorders also have
    a significant association with psychiatric disorders, especially
    depressive and panic disorders as well as phobias. Against this view
    is the evidence that the majority of primary care patients with most
    of these disorders do not have either a psychiatric disorder or other
    functional disorders.

    Table 224

    Functional or psychosomatic syndromes (medically unexplained symptoms)

    `Tension' headaches
    Atypical facial pain
    Atypical chest pain
    Fibromyalgia (chronic
    widespread pain)
    Other chronic pain syndromes
    Chronic or post-viral fatigue syndrome
    Multiple chemical sensitMty
    Premenstrual syndrome
    Irritable or functional bowel syndrome
    Irritable bladder syndrome

    It also seems that it requires a major stress or a psychiatric
    disorder in order for such sufferers to attend their doctor for help,
    which might explain why doctors are so impressed with the
    associations with stress and psychiatric disorders. Doctors have
    historically tended to diagnose `stress' or `psychosomatic disorders'
    in patients with symptoms that they cannot explain. History is full
    of such disorders being reclassified as research clarifies the
    pathology. A recent example is writer's cramp (p. 1233) which most
    neurologists now agree is a dystonia rather than a neurosis.

    Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS)

    There has probably been more controversy over the existence and
    aetiology of CFS than any other functional syndrome in recent years.
    This is reflected in its uncertain classification as neurasthenia in
    the psychiatric classification and myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME)
    under neurological disorders. There is good evidence for this
    syndrome, although the diagnosis is made clinically and by exclusion
    of other fatiguing disorders. Its prevalence is 0.5% in the UK,
    although abnormal fatigue as a symptom occurs in 10-20%. It occurs
    most commonly in women between the ages of 20 and 50 years old, The
    cardinal symptom is chronic fatigue made worse by minimal exertion.
    The fatigue is usually both physical and mental, with associated poor
    concentration, impaired registration of memory, irritability,
    alteration in sleep pattern (either insomnia or hypersomnia), and
    muscular pain. The name myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME) is
    decreasingly used within medicine because it implies a pathology for
    which there is no evidence.

    Aetiology


    Functional disorders often have aetiological factors in common with
    each other (see Table 22.5), as well as more specific aetiologies.
    For instance, CFS can be triggered by certain infections, such as
    infectious mononucleosis and viral hepatitis. About 10% of patients
    with infectious mononucleosis have CFS 6 months after the infectious
    onset, yet there is no evidence of persistent infection in these
    patients. Those fatigue states which clearly do follow on a viral
    infection can be classified as post-viral fatigue syndromes. Other
    aetiological factors include physical inactivity arid sleep
    difficulties. immune and endocrine abnormalities noted in CFS may be
    secondary to the inactivity or sleep disturbance commonly seen in
    patients. Mood disorders are present in a large minority of patients,
    and can cause problems in diagnosis because of the large overlap in
    symptoms. These mood disorders may be secondary, independent (co-
    morbid), or primary with a misdiagnosis of CFS. The role of stress is
    uncertain, with some indication that the influence of stress is
    mediated through consequent psychiatric disorders exacerbating
    fatigue, rather than any direct effect.

    Management

    The general principles of the management of functional disorders are
    given in Box 22.7. Specific management of CFS should include a
    mutually agreed and supervised programme of gradual increasing
    activity However, few patients regard themselves as cured after
    treatment. It is sometimes difficult to persuade a patient to accept
    what are inappropriately perceived as psychological therapies' for
    such a physically manifested condition. Antidepressants do not work
    in the absence of a mood disorder or insomnia.

    Prognosis

    This is poor without treatment, with less than 10% ot hospital
    attenders recovered after 1 year Outcome is worse with increasing
    age. co-morbid mood disorder, and the conviction that the illness is
    entirely physical.

    Table 22.5 Aetiological factors commonly seen in functional disorders

    Predisposing

    Perfectionist obsessional and introspective personality
    Childhood traumas (physical and sexual abuse)
    Similar illnesses in first-degree relatives

    Precipitating (triggering)

    Infections
    Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS)
    irritable bowel syndrome (IBS)
    Psychologically traumatic events (especially accidents)
    Physical Injuries ('fibromyalgia and other chronic pain syndromes)
    Life events that precipitate changed behaviours (e.g. going off sick)
    Incidents where the patient believes others are responsible

    Perpetuating ( maintaining)


    Inactivity with consequent physiological adaptation (CFS
    and 'fibromyalgia').
    Avoidant behaviours multiple chemical sensitivities (MCS) CFS
    Maladaptive illness beliefs (that maintain maladaptive behaviours)
    (CFS)
    Excessive dietary restrictions (`food allergies')
    Stimulant drugs
    Sleep disturbance
    Mood disorders.
    Somatization disorder
    Unresolved anger or guilt
    Unresolved compensation

    Box 22.7 Management of functional disorders

    The first principles is the identification and treatment of
    maintaining factors (e.g. dysfunctional beliefs and behaviours mood
    and sleep disorders)

    Communication

    Explanation of ill-health, including diagnosis and causes
    Education about management (including self-help leaflets) .
    Stopping drugs (e. g. caffeine causing insomnia, analgesics causing
    dependence)

    Rehabilitative therapies

    Cognitive behaviour therapy (to challenge unhelpful beliefs and
    change coping strategies)
    Supervised and graded exercise therapy for approximately 3 months (to
    reduce inactivity and improve fitness)

    Pharmacotherapies

    Specific antidepressants for mood disorders,analgesia and sleep
    disturbance .
    Symptomatic medicines (e.g. appropriate analgesia, taken only when
    necessary)

    -------------------------------------------------
  20. parvofighter

    parvofighter Senior Member

    Messages:
    436
    Likes:
    98
    Canada
    Grounds for legal/human rights action

    @Orla, thanks for posting this. One would think it was written in the Middle Ages, rather than in 2007.:eek: I would LOVE to hear what some medico-legal minds think about this:D. Reading through it, I just kept thinking: medical malpractice; incompetence; wilful ignoring of viral etiology; class action lawsuits. And a patient population swimming not only against incompetent medical practice, but also against institutionally entrenched financial interests in CBT/GET. Anyone have contacts in the medical malpractice/human rights field? Let's get this party started...

    Here are some take-aways on the inherent contradictions in this document:
    1)Lack of evidence of "adequate medical investigation and explanation", particularly related to post-viral symptoms.
    The diagnosis of abnormal illness behavior, somatization, hypochondria etc. depends on the flawed assumption that adequate medical investigation has been performed. Where is the discussion for example that ME/CFS viruses such as parvovirus B19 and Human Herpes-6 are sometimes absent on PCR in blood, but found in tissue? Where is the guidance on how to ensure that "adequate medical investigation" has indeed been done? This treatise on Medically Unexplained Symptoms devotes all its energy to so-called abnormal illness behavior, and completely glosses over "adequate medical investigation and explanation", which I believe is our medicolegal wild card, the Achilles Heel of the CBT/GET lobby. I am reminded of an immunologist who refused to conduct parvovirus B19 tests on me - and refused to see me - as soon as he heard that I had ME/CFS symptoms. Yup, got it in writing.

    2) Patient reports of continuing pathology - despite subjective medical claims that they have been appropriately treated.
    3) Evidence of incompetence: inaccurate/misleading assertions of absence of objective physical signs of pathology, particularly related to viral etiology.
    On the contrary, competent physicians know how/where to look for evidence of viral reactivation & persistent viral infection. A great summary of this is the letter to the CFSAC by Dr Ablashi, Scientific Director of the HHV-6 Foundation@ http://www.hhs.gov/advcomcfs/meetings/presentations/ablashi_1009.pdf

    "It is imperative that the CDC study biopsy samples from the gut, and brain as well as heart tissues,
    and that they look at spinal fluid. Most of the studies done by the CDC have been on serum.
    However, many pathogens cannot be found in the serum because they
    do not circulate in the peripheral blood after the initial infection
    ."​

    4) Evidence that these physicians/psychiatrists are abundantly aware of the viral connection with ME/CFS. Given this knowledge, so nicely profiled here, the adequacy of their medical investigation can be raked over the coals.
    Infections are #1 on their list of precipitating factors. It is no great mystery - even to the CBT/GET lobby - that ME/CFS is connected with viruses. The perps knowingly disregarded the viral etiology.

    5) Documentation that patients get worse, particularly when we keep insisting that the biological causes of ME/CFS are not being addressed.


    In summary
    ME/CFS, is the GET/CBT lobby's poster-child for Medically Unexplained Symptoms:
    Now the ME/CFS community is the poster child for how patients with Medically Unexplained Symptoms are abused by a negligent and capricious medical system. I found myself reminded of WB Yeats' poem, "The Second Coming":

    Turning and turning in the widening gyre
    The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
    Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
    Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
    The blood-dimmed tide (XMRV) is loosed, and everywhere
    The ceremony of innocence (CBT/GET) is drowned​

    WB Yeats​
    Can't help thinking this is how the CBT/GET lobby sees recent XMRV events. Ceremony of innocence, indeed.

See more popular forum discussions.

Share This Page