I wish I had seen your post. If I understand correctly what your post contained, it seems like a double standard that it was deleted. Unfortunately, it's difficult to discern this since the original post no longer exists. However, since Gerwyn/V99/Tingle insist that they are knowledgeable enough about science to make scientific pronouncements and want to be taken seriously, then we should be able to voice the same type of criticisms and analysis that other scientiest are subject to on this and other forums and not have these type of comments considered "personal". Extraordinary claims not only require extraordinary evidence but also extraordinary scrutinizing. If someone analysis, ERV, Racinello, Lipkin's previous research etc. and it's not considered personal then why not the same standard for Gerwyn, et. al.? Unless people are saying not to criticize him because he doesn't have scientific credibility? IMHO Barb C. :>) Changed a word.