I disagree. Dr Shepherd also commented on MEA's Facebook page that pretty much anything gets through onto BMJ's RR pages and that they're not subject to the same level of editorial control as articles, but who is aware of that? I wasn't, until I read it just now, and I think it's a big mistake on the BMJ's part. They're a highly prestigious journal and they lend that prestige to anything they publish. I think they have to accept responsibility.