1. Patients launch $1.27 million crowdfunding campaign for ME/CFS gut microbiome study.
    Check out the website, Facebook and Twitter. Join in donate and spread the word!
The Pathway to Prevention (P2P) for ME/CFS: A Dangerous Process
Gabby Klein gives an overview of the P2P process, shedding light on the pitfalls with advice as to what we can do in protest ...
Discuss the article on the Forums.

*2 new* letters, Myra McClue, Annette Whittemore

Discussion in 'XMRV Research and Replication Studies' started by VillageLife, May 5, 2010.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Cookie Monster

    Cookie Monster

    Messages:
    76
    Likes:
    0
    Very good points indeed - although it is insufficient for us to let it lie now - i think many of us were holding back in the hope that some co-operation may have been prevailing in the background, however we now have clear proof that isnt going to happen.

    How can one person and a weasal take it upon themselves to act on behalf of the regulatory authorites in this country and even then produce such an unprofessional and rushed piece of work? That isnt ethical practice and surely those initial decisions are way outside of her and the Weasal's durisdiction anyway. They arent tasked with monitoring how doctors are prescribing treatments - that is under the remit of the GMC.

    I wonder if there is a regulatory type body that McClure practices under...if someone were considering lodging an official complaint against her? *whistles*
     
  2. fred

    fred The game is afoot

    Messages:
    400
    Likes:
    1
    And what a fine job they make of this remit.
     
  3. Angela Kennedy

    Angela Kennedy *****

    Messages:
    1,026
    Likes:
    154
    Essex, UK
    LOL. Cookie Monster's put it more elegantly here than I ever could!
     
  4. Gerwyn

    Gerwyn Guest

    with that letter her scientific credibility has gone.Retrovirologists all over the world know exactly what her letter means. Correct protocol would be to validate her assay they all know that.But as she says she just runs a lab.perhaps they will take pity on her!
     
  5. gu3vara

    gu3vara Senior Member

    Messages:
    337
    Likes:
    44
    Nobel prize for McClure :p
     
  6. jimbob

    jimbob ME/CFS84-XMRV+

    Messages:
    321
    Likes:
    9
    myrtle beach, s.c.
    McClure McClueless!
     
  7. Forbin

    Forbin Forbin

    Messages:
    271
    Likes:
    299
    I always suspected that Mrs. Whittemores initial letter was a sort of olive branch in the sense of before confirmatory studies destroy your career, here is an opportunity to save face by accepting our offer to help you.

    When someone is arrogant enough to ignore your advice that they stop backing up toward the edge of a cliff, at some point all you can do is wish them a pleasant trip.

    Bon Voyage, Dr. McClure.
     
  8. Ecoclimber

    Ecoclimber Senior Member

    Messages:
    646
    Likes:
    1,122
    Mercer Island Wa
    I don't think it helps our cause if we start making degrogatory comments about other researchers. She may have been set up or used unknowningly by the politics of the situation. We don't know but it sounds like she is pissed off as being the point person on this when maybe other nameless culpits were behind the scenes setting her up. Because of this, she doesn't want to be associated anymore with this research especially if later research nullifies her results....perfectly understandable.
     
  9. fingers

    fingers Senior Member

    Messages:
    210
    Likes:
    7
    SW Endland
    Movin' on

    I think the doc's post sums it up, and Forbin's signature seems apt here:
    "In questions of science,
    the authority of a thousand
    is not worth the humble reasoning
    of a single individual."​

    Galileo Galilei 1564-1642​


    Time to ignore the noise and move on I think. Humble reasoning shall prevail.
     
  10. shrewsbury

    shrewsbury member

    Messages:
    1,540
    Likes:
    55
    Just a reminder that Dr. McClure, along with Dr Mikovits, is on the scientific committee for the 1st International XMRV Workshop this coming September. It seems that she is not planning on going away soon.

    Scientific Committee:
    The members of the Scientific Committee (SC) assist the OC by providing them with suggestions for speakers and topics. In addition, members of the SC actively participate in the reviewing process of the submitted abstracts.

    Norbert Bannert, Koch Institute, Germany
    Bill Dahut, National Cancer Institute, USA
    Rika Furuta, Japanese Red Cross Osaka Blood Center, Japan
    Stephen Goff, Columbia University, USA
    Walid Heneine, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, USA
    Jerry Holmberg, US Dept HHS, Advisory Committee on Blood Safety, USA
    Myra McClure, Imperial College London, UK
    Judy Mikovits, Whittemore Peterson Institute, USA
    Ila Singh, University of Utah, USA
    Suzanne Vernon, CFIDS Association of America, USA
     
  11. shrewsbury

    shrewsbury member

    Messages:
    1,540
    Likes:
    55
    Please tell me that my following thought carries no weight and that I shouldn't be worried.

    I get concerned a bit that the WPI is posting what seems to be private correspondence (with a few missing as one astute reader inferred) on their website. I'm not sure that this will win friends and influence people within the scientific community. Other researchers, funders etc that we really want involved, might want to stay away because of this.
     
  12. fingers

    fingers Senior Member

    Messages:
    210
    Likes:
    7
    SW Endland
    Hi Shrewsbury, I've been away a while but you don't half look like someone I know :D

    McClure just planning on going away from CFS, but not XMRV, you mean?

    F
     
  13. Dr. Yes

    Dr. Yes Shame on You

    Messages:
    867
    Likes:
    22
    Maybe not.. but never underestimate the lure of a free trip and one more thing to put on your CV! :D
     
  14. Gerwyn

    Gerwyn Guest

    she used the wrong technique and she knows it.If a student was told in a viva that there were four known ways to find a virus and asked which one would be best to use.IF he/she said that he /she would use one of their own they would get an F grade and rightly so
     
  15. Gerwyn

    Gerwyn Guest

    McClur,sbreach of scientific protocol will not go unnoticed
     
  16. VillageLife

    VillageLife Senior Member

    Messages:
    674
    Likes:
    36
    United Kingdom
    I think everyone is a little worried but they are doing it because we have / are treated so badly by the world. They feel someone has to stick there neck out and fight for us. We are all really un well people and WPI cannot just sit and watch us suffer, now they know the truth about XMRV. It's like if people with cancer were not believed and made to have psychiatric therapy and the scientists wouldn't retest there blood again to see if they have cancer. I'm suprised wpi are so calm, giving what they know and how things are for us. I'm suprised they are so diplomatic.

    You only get one life, one chance and I'm proud there fighting for us.
     
  17. Rivotril

    Rivotril Senior Member

    Messages:
    154
    Likes:
    0
    McClure agrees to cooperate with WPI -> WPI shares her techniques with McClure ->UK samples turn out to be positive in McClure's Lab -> end of scientific reputation of McClure

    it's just as simple as that. And McClure already knows by now that WPI did find XMRV in the Dutch samples with their more sophisticated techniques

    conclusion: she can win nothing with cooperation, and just lose a lot of things
    For her the best escape out of all of this is let another lab solve this..
    in the worst case for her, this other lab finds XMRV in UK samples, but this is not so bad news as headlines in the papers as "McClure didn't find anything with her own method and now finds XMRV in her own lab, helped by WPI"

    Science is cooperation, sharing results, and helping each other to ultimately find the truth, for the benefit and health of people who are ill
    This is more or less the opposite of everything that integer science stands for...
     
  18. usedtobeperkytina

    usedtobeperkytina Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,384
    Likes:
    186
    Clay, Alabama
    My immediate thought was that the Whittemore letter seems to refer to a conversation or comments from McClure that is not in the first letter.

    It is nice, after Whittemore's bold first letter, to see McClure taking a friendly, personal tone.

    So, McClure wants to obviously stay in XMRV but get out of the CFS part. LOL Honey, I don't blame you. Too complicated. You only put your toe in and ended up in the center of international and vicious debate. It sounds like it is too complicated. We'll leave that ground breaking (and possible Nobel Prize) to those with courage.

    I don't know about posting these follow up letters, but I have no problem with the first letter where Whittemore corrected other information in the public. In fact, she should have done it sooner. Incorrect public statements about scientific research must be corrected swiftly and publicly.

    Tina
     
  19. jspotila

    jspotila Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,074
    Likes:
    606
    McClure's email read very informally to me, and I really hope WPI had her permission to publish it. The CFS community is best served by lots of rigorous research, and the accompanying rigorous discussion/debate among researchers. I don't have any idea whether WPI had McClure's permission, but IF they didn't and they published a direct personal email communication without her permission, I share shrewsbury's concern about a chilling effect on the dialogue. I want everyone to be talking to each other, sharing results and information. We do not want any researcher to think "I'm not going to email WPI (or any other entity) because it might end up on their website." Members of this forum and others have rightly sought permission before publishing personal communications, and when it became apparent permission was not given, forum members have deleted the posts involved. But if WPI had McClure's permission then that makes all the difference. Like I said, I don't know the facts of whether permission was given, so this is all speculation.
     
  20. Adam

    Adam *****

    Messages:
    495
    Likes:
    1
    Sheffield UK
    Known in UK as a Beano, Junket or Jolly.

    Who knows, maybe they can straighten things out over a beer or ten and a best of three arm wrestle?

    One can but hope.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

See more popular forum discussions.

Share This Page