• Welcome to Phoenix Rising!

    Created in 2008, Phoenix Rising is the largest and oldest forum dedicated to furthering the understanding of, and finding treatments for, complex chronic illnesses such as chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS), fibromyalgia, long COVID, postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS), mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS), and allied diseases.

    To become a member, simply click the Register button at the top right.

A Song for ME: Blowin' in the Wind

Messages
60
Some of you may remember me asking for volunteers to sing in the chorus of a protest song about ME a while back.

Here is the finished result, performed by 18 ME patients and carers from 7 different countries:


I am hoping that people may play and/or sing the song at the #MillionsMissing protests on 12 May. For those who would like to, I have produced a printable lyrics sheet and a printable chords sheet.

To request a free MP3 file of the song to play at a protest, please email asongforMEcfs@gmail.com


YouTube description:

Originally written and recorded by Bob Dylan for his breakthrough 1963 Freewheelin’ album, I started working on my alternative lyrics for Blowin’ in the Wind in 2016. It wasn’t until the end of last year that I stumbled upon the idea of recording it with other people with ME from around the world.

Having posted messages on forums and social media, I was encouraged by the number of replies I received from people who were interested to take part. Sadly, several volunteers had to drop out because they were not well enough to record themselves singing. However, the final recording includes the voices of 18 people from 7 different countries – most of whom have never met or communicated with each other.

Originally, I was only going to use the extra voices for the choruses, but Kaeley’s harmony was so beautiful that I couldn’t not use it throughout the song. I had no experience of doing anything like this before. I have never sung in a choir or been well enough to play my guitar in public, and I’d never tried mixing more than one person’s voice, so I had no idea if it would work or not. But I am very pleased with the final result.

It’s been a privilege and a pleasure to work with so many talented and motivated people from the international ME community. As well as all the singers, I am indebted to Anna and Jonas for providing me with the images for the video from their ME Perspective website, and for their help and enthusiasm throughout the project. I very much hope that our combined efforts will help to raise awareness of our struggle, the ignorance and injustices we face, and the desperate need for a huge increase in investment in biomedical ME research.

The song is dedicated to Anne Örtegren. I never knew Anne, or had any contact with her, but I had just read her beautifully written and deeply moving Farewell Letter when I recorded the song, and she has been very much in my mind throughout the process of production.

NB: It has been suggested that it might have been better to use gender-neutral lyrics rather than referring to a man. This is a valid point, not least because ME affects at least three times as many women as men. However, when I tried using gender-neutral alternatives I didn’t feel they worked so well lyrically. I also wanted to echo Dylan’s original lyrics (“How many roads must a man walk down”) and decided that the masculine form was acceptable as I was writing about my own situation.

Credits:

Guitar and vocals: Robert Saunders (aka Robert McMullen; West Sussex, UK)
Harmony: Kaeley Pruit-Hamm (Seattle, WA, USA)
Chorus: Christina Kalinen (London, UK); Nikki Franklin (West Sussex, UK); Leela (USA); Maya Leutwiler (Zürich, Switzerland); Darla Nagel (Flushing, Michigan, USA); Lorna Robinson (West Sussex, UK); Olivia Rowe (North Cornwall, UK); Noa Henrietta Ruscheweyh-Sternberg (Hamburg, Germany); Barbara Saunders (West Sussex, UK); Emma Shorter (Edinburgh, Scotland, UK); Richard Shorter (Edinburgh, Scotland, UK); Simas (Lithuania); Becky Taurog (St Paul, MN, USA); Jen “Gemma” Taylor (Hagerstown, Maryland, USA); James Wallace (Hokkaido, Japan); Zoë Williams (Oxfordshire, UK)
Video images: Anna and Jonas, ME Perspective (Switzerland)
Arrangement, production and alternative lyrics: Robert Saunders
Original music & lyrics: Bob Dylan

[ETA: For those of you on Twitter, I am @RobertHMcMullen]
 

Misfit Toy

Senior Member
Messages
4,178
Location
USA
Originally, I was only going to use the extra voices for the choruses, but Kaeley’s harmony was so beautiful that I couldn’t not use it throughout the song. I had no experience of doing anything like this before. I have never sung in a choir or been well enough to play my guitar in public, and I’d never tried mixing more than one person’s voice, so I had no idea if it would work or not. But I am very pleased with the final result.

Her voice is angelic. I love this. It's absolutely beautiful. You did a much better job than Dylan. I am a big Dylan fan. This is beautiful and brings about such emotion. What an amazing feat to get so many people together for this. From all different countries.

I know this may sound trite, but I am so proud of you for all of us. Thank you so much.
 

hangininthere

Senior Member
Messages
101
Location
USA
Oh wow!!! Excellent!!!

Love the photos depicting the view from our sickbed that we see years on end. So realistic. Wow. Just wow.

Absolutely beautiful guitar work and lyrics and singing by all.

"...how many voices must scream from the dark..."

Patti
 
Last edited:

Sundancer

Senior Member
Messages
569
Location
Holland
@Robert 1973
beautiful, heartbreaking, made me cry and feel surrounded by other patients, not alone anymore.

My son asked me last week what music I would want at my funeral ( i'm not about to die yet, but we think it prudent to make clear arrangements beforehand)
well, this is it, could I have a MP3 version for that use?
 

Countrygirl

Senior Member
Messages
5,473
Location
UK
@Robert 1973 This is amazingly good. Congratulations! I have been replaying it all day. I have also been sending it to others, including a US TV producer whom I am advising on the making of a certain aspect of a film at the moment. I heard from his PA who thought it was very moving. So good!
 
Last edited:

Gingergrrl

Senior Member
Messages
16,171
@Diwi9 The second song (vocals and musics) was beautiful but I was confused if it was referring to the #MeToo movement b/c it seemed to keep referring to a man and saying that even though he was from a good family, to get away from him. It referred to (I assume the same man) scratching her on shoulder and then something "Red Rover" (I don't know what this means) but I assume re: some kind of abuse? Was this song about abuse? The lyrics didn't seem to match with a physical illness like the first song but maybe I am just missing it and need to listen again!