• Welcome to Phoenix Rising!

    Created in 2008, Phoenix Rising is the largest and oldest forum dedicated to furthering the understanding of, and finding treatments for, complex chronic illnesses such as chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS), fibromyalgia, long COVID, postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS), mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS), and allied diseases.

    To become a member, simply click the Register button at the top right.

Bacterial overgrowth in stomach?

hixxy

Senior Member
Messages
1,229
Location
Australia
Hello,

I've been diagnosed as having H2S producing SIBO. Just wondering if it's possible for a person with extremely poor stomach acid production to have the SIBO spread into the stomach.

I would have thought there would be a delay between ingesting food and symptoms developing if you just have SIBO.

I feel horrendously sick within a minute or 2 of swallowing food. Increasing my betaine dose seems to make no difference at all. The only thing that helps a bit is cooking my food as a stew to the point where it's almost pre-digested.

Thanks,
Troy
 

Sushi

Moderation Resource Albuquerque
Messages
19,935
Location
Albuquerque
Hello,

I've been diagnosed as having H2S producing SIBO. Just wondering if it's possible for a person with extremely poor stomach acid production to have the SIBO spread into the stomach.
Thanks,
Troy

Hi Troy,

I'd guess yes. I also was producing H2S and had a huge overgrowth of prevotella. I also have low stomach acid. There are some other related threads. I posted this earlier today: http://forums.phoenixrising.me/show...thout-a-doctor&p=192663&viewfull=1#post192663

Best wishes,
Sushi
 

sleepy237

Senior Member
Messages
246
Location
Hell
Sushi if you have low stomach acid production can it also cause the same symptoms of GERD? I am curious as I have been on Lansoprazole for a few years now which would further reduce acid and my gut motitlity is very bad but as soon as i miss a ppi pill i have acid in my throat. Missed my gastric emptying study so trying to increase motility naturally if it is possible. Thanks. Best wishes ~Sleepy
 

redo

Senior Member
Messages
874
Hixxy, I am no expert on the subject, but it wouldn't surprise me. Perhaps not H2S producing bacteria, but overgrowth of other bacteria, which cause disease.
 

topaz

Senior Member
Messages
149
Hello,

I've been diagnosed as having H2S producing SIBO. Just wondering if it's possible for a person with extremely poor stomach acid production to have the SIBO spread into the stomach.

I would have thought there would be a delay between ingesting food and symptoms developing if you just have SIBO.

I feel horrendously sick within a minute or 2 of swallowing food. Increasing my betaine dose seems to make no difference at all. The only thing that helps a bit is cooking my food as a stew to the point where it's almost pre-digested.

Thanks,
Troy

I cant answer definitively but the SIBO is limited to the intestines. The symptom of feeling ill within a minute or two of swallowing food is a symptom of low stomach acid. the low stomach acid can be a cause of SIBO.

The HCL should help. What is your dose? I am no expert but have just posted a response on this and from what I know is that it is recommended to start slowly, no more than 500mg/day increasing to about 500mg/meal (up to 3000mg /day - Mark Hyman).

It also helps not to consume water with meals; limit snacks or no snacks between meals; chew food very well to assist digestion.

Unpasturised saurerkraut (1/4 to 1/2 cup per meal) is supposed to assist with both acidity and promotion of probiotics. Lemon juice in water is allegedly benefical too.

Unfortunately I cannot comment from experience and am just embarking on this journey.

Read this http://bb-cfs.blogspot.com/search/label/dysbiosis and this http://bb-cfs.blogspot.com/search/label/H2S

I'll follow with interest.
 

Sushi

Moderation Resource Albuquerque
Messages
19,935
Location
Albuquerque
Sushi if you have low stomach acid production can it also cause the same symptoms of GERD? I am curious as I have been on Lansoprazole for a few years now which would further reduce acid and my gut motitlity is very bad but as soon as i miss a ppi pill i have acid in my throat. Missed my gastric emptying study so trying to increase motility naturally if it is possible. Thanks. Best wishes ~Sleepy

Yes, low stomach acid can cause the same symptoms as GERD!

Vicious, isn't it?

Sushi
 
Messages
52
so i guess the big question is how does one get rid of the bacteria in the gut? axb only or other natural supplements? like what? i tried GSE and gave me headaches, so i have been trying neem, for upper gut fermentation/bacteria and a strep and staph pellet homeopath and an herb, black radish and parsley, both by Hanna herb shoppe in boulder, co. you can goggle the site.

i know i have a lot of bacteria from mold and trying hard to rid myself of it

denise
 

topaz

Senior Member
Messages
149
so i guess the big question is how does one get rid of the bacteria in the gut? axb only or other natural supplements? like what? i tried GSE and gave me headaches, so i have been trying neem, for upper gut fermentation/bacteria and a strep and staph pellet homeopath and an herb, black radish and parsley, both by Hanna herb shoppe in boulder, co. you can goggle the site.

i know i have a lot of bacteria from mold and trying hard to rid myself of it

denise

It depends on how long and by what techniques a person has been trying to restore gut bacteria. My inclination would be to focus on restoring symbiosis. Our gut are supposed to have both good and bad bacteria. the quantity of bad bacteria are kept under control by the good bacteria...until something causes an imbalance (abx, yeast/candida, food allergy or otehr pathogen such as virus, bacteria, parasite). So if you are in the early stages of attacking the problem, I would focus on improving the colony of good bacteria (probiotics, kefir, homemade saurerkraut etc).

That is all 101. The best form of attack is to know what is the likely cause and a stool analysis can help here. If you have candida/yeast, then this needs to be addressed via diet and probiotics (in the generic sense, not just supplemental probiotics as the other forms such as kefir and saurerkraut can introduce other beneficial strains that may not be present in a probiotic).

The basis of fecal transplant success is the importation of healthy and beneficial good bacteria. This treatment has a good track record in treating c-diff which appears resilient to many conventional forms of treatment. This may be extreme, but the basis is the importation of good gut flora. This can be assisted via other means.

Depending on what may be the underlying cause, I would resist antibiotics (unless abx are the key treatment for the particular underlying cause ofcourse) as they are detrimental to the good gut flora, as are ant-inflamatories, diet (can cause candida/yeast) and antacids.

Unfortunately for most people, the cause is not just one factor but usually several (I have posted on this here recently) so it takes a while and a lot of patience to remedy.

Diet is key. Sugars are generally to be avoided to ensure the bad bacteria's food supply is cut off. If you can, avoid meat that is factory farmed (basically all of it unless the supply is organic, grassfed) as the animals are fed antibiotics as part of the routine course of raising them (a long story here of why but Ill save that for a rainy day and if there is any interest). It is antibiotics that are thought to be the (indirect) cause of the recent European e-coli outbreak. I was just reading this today http://medicalxpress.com/news/2011-07-small-amounts-antibiotics-big-problems.html

I have not been able to answer your question directly as I have no experience of mold bacteria but the key is to increase the symbiotic bacteria. I have heard that peppermint oil and garlic are often used as well but you would need to look into this further as I have no knowledge of this.

ps I did find this in a quick google search. The link came from a MS site where they believe MS may also be caused by dysbiosis. They had a link to mold bacteria treatments http://moldrecovery.blogspot.com/2010/01/treatment-options.html it is a starting point possibly and could require more digging from you.

Maybe start up a post with the key words "mold bacteria" to see if others can share their experience with you.
 

Enid

Senior Member
Messages
3,309
Location
UK
I don't know whether a recent experience of mine might aid Hixxy but certainly my bowel problems have improved (diahorrea, blackened feaces etc). Following some dental treatment (root extractions and infection suspected) I was put on high dose Amoxcillan for a week. Can't think this is pure coincidence but stools and urine have returned to the correct colour and odour free and solids too at last. Masses of probiotics taken after. I noticed a slight re-emergence of Herpes Simplex only but this has since disappeared too. Just a thought for you (I had previously tested high on KdeM's H2S measure). The whole action of the digestive tact (peristalsis) works too.
 

Dufresne

almost there...
Messages
1,039
Location
Laurentians, Quebec
I feel horrendously sick within a minute or 2 of swallowing food. Increasing my betaine dose seems to make no difference at all. The only thing that helps a bit is cooking my food as a stew to the point where it's almost pre-digested.

Thanks,
Troy

Hi Troy. This sounds similar to something I've experienced. In a nutshell I think the act of eating triggers or exacerbates an immune response and serious oxidative stress. I started a thread about it in which I reference three recovery stories that all involved a period of fasting and intravenous nutrition. I believe this approach could be a valuable tool in treating our disease.

http://forums.phoenixrising.me/showthread.php?8228-A-Role-for-TPN-in-CFS
 

hixxy

Senior Member
Messages
1,229
Location
Australia
I've thought about IV nutrition in aiding recovery from this illness in the past, but getting IV nutrition in Australia is near to impossible. How are you managing this problem at the moment? I know for a fact I had complete resolution of this problem 2 years ago on a triple abx therapy for blastocystis hominis. Thing is, the abx could have killed something other then blasto (SIBO?) as well. It relapsed viciously about 2 weeks later.

During that period of remission, it was the best I'd felt in years, almost complete recovery. Since then I've gone on to develop MCS and EMF sensitivity and a lot of other neurological problems. Sigh.
 

hixxy

Senior Member
Messages
1,229
Location
Australia
I'm starting to believe there is some sort of stomach pathogen (protozoa?) not showing up on testing as I no longer show up positive for blastocystis hominis, only "parasite present, taxonomy unknown" with metametrix.
 

Gavman

Senior Member
Messages
316
Location
Sydney
that sucks that more stuff came back, hixxy. Were you taking anything for leaky gut at all?
 

Sushi

Moderation Resource Albuquerque
Messages
19,935
Location
Albuquerque
I'm starting to believe there is some sort of stomach pathogen (protozoa?) not showing up on testing as I no longer show up positive for blastocystis hominis, only "parasite present, taxonomy unknown" with metametrix.

Hi Hixxy,

Metametrix does an aerobic test, I believe. It is likely to miss anaerobic infections. I had a huge anaerobic infection. I think the the only lab that does an anaerobic test is Redlabs in Belgium--which makes it difficult internationally.

Best wishes,
Sushi
 

Dufresne

almost there...
Messages
1,039
Location
Laurentians, Quebec
I've thought about IV nutrition in aiding recovery from this illness in the past, but getting IV nutrition in Australia is near to impossible. How are you managing this problem at the moment? I know for a fact I had complete resolution of this problem 2 years ago on a triple abx therapy for blastocystis hominis. Thing is, the abx could have killed something other then blasto (SIBO?) as well. It relapsed viciously about 2 weeks later.

During that period of remission, it was the best I'd felt in years, almost complete recovery. Since then I've gone on to develop MCS and EMF sensitivity and a lot of other neurological problems. Sigh.

This feature is no longer as pronounced as it once was for me. There's only a slight worsening in symptoms now following a meal. My immune system seems to be doing its nastiness, regardless of eating, all on its own. But for the record the only relief I ever had from this was with wormwood which seems to alter things in a favourable way. However, this approach would only work if accompanied by a sugar/carb free diet, perhaps suggesting a sugar-fed pathogen to be involved. This would be compatible with the bacteria (or other gremlin) you were nailing with antibiotics. The fact that your troubles returned suggests a resilient bacterial-like infection. I recently tested positive for Lyme and coinfections, which fits this bill. Hopefully food for thought.
 

hixxy

Senior Member
Messages
1,229
Location
Australia
Sushi, I've had the same test done here in Australia. That test was actually developed by Dr Henry Butt in Australia at Bioscreen. I've just had this test repeated and my H2S producing bacteria levels are down, I've now got a clostridium overgrowth :(
 

hixxy

Senior Member
Messages
1,229
Location
Australia
Dufresne, unfortunately for me, a completely carb free diet for me results in rapid weight loss. I'm unable to absorb fats efficiently due to lack of bile flow (ox bile only works a little for this) so can't load up on fats. Doesn't matter how many digestive/pancreatic enzymes and betaine hcl I take, I still don't seem absorb protein efficiently. So my only hope is to kill whatever it is!!

Lyme testing is very expensive isn't it? Where are you located? I don't think Lyme is very common in Australia.
 
Messages
88
Location
NJ
Hi Hixxy,

Metametrix does an aerobic test, I believe. It is likely to miss anaerobic infections. I had a huge anaerobic infection. I think the the only lab that does an anaerobic test is Redlabs in Belgium--which makes it difficult internationally.

Best wishes,
Sushi

Sushi,

The Metametrix test claims to identify anaerobes by useing DNA testing. Redlabs claims to use 16s PCR amplifcation followed by high throughput screening. I'm not sure what the difference is if any. I'd like to know as I wondered if the Metametrix test was just as good because it's certainly easier to get done. I'm wary of all these labs because for the longest time they only did aerobic tests which are not worth much, they seem to frequently default to the "taxonomy unknown" identification a lot and they charge a lot for the tests. Any insight appreciated.

http://www.redlabs.be/red-labs/our-tests/intestinal-dysfunction-assays.php
http://www.metametrix.com/test-menu/profiles/gastrointestinal-function/dna-stool-analysis-gi-effects
 

Dufresne

almost there...
Messages
1,039
Location
Laurentians, Quebec
Dufresne, unfortunately for me, a completely carb free diet for me results in rapid weight loss. I'm unable to absorb fats efficiently due to lack of bile flow (ox bile only works a little for this) so can't load up on fats. Doesn't matter how many digestive/pancreatic enzymes and betaine hcl I take, I still don't seem absorb protein efficiently. So my only hope is to kill whatever it is!!

Lyme testing is very expensive isn't it? Where are you located? I don't think Lyme is very common in Australia.

I had a similar problem with rapid weight loss, though mine seems to have been due to low stomach acid (of course hypochloridia leads to SIBO too). I originally solved this by taking 1 oz of vinegar with meals (I can't take betaine HCI). Unfortunately I sensitized to vinegar shortly afterwards and had to stop. However, serendipitously I stumbled upon a rather counter-intuitive solution when I started on the pleomorphism diet. Counter-intuitive because the primary purpose of the diet is to alkalize. It improved my digestion in a matter of days and I started putting on the pounds. Even better though, I felt more clearheaded and lighthearted than with just about anything else. It was as if my system was throwing up a guard against the onslaught of mammalian meats I was giving it and decreasing gastric juices. The difference is profound and has to be integral to my recovery process. You'll see, though, it's rather restrictive when you combine it with the sugar/carb free diet, but if it works, you gotta stay with it. All this as I digest filet mignon - but nobody's perfect, eh?

Werthmann Hypoallergetic-
renic-restoration Diet

Avoid!
Mammalian meats (beef, pork,
lamb, etc.)
Cow's milk and all dairy
products: yogurt, cottage cheese,
ice cream, chocolate, cheese and
cheese dishes
Nuts and nut dishes
Chicken egg white, egg dishes,
cakes, etc.
Pork, Nam and 5ausages
Citrus Fruit (except lemon and
lime)
All Histamine rich meats: Rabbit,
Venison, Anchovies, sardines
No Canned foods or Foods
containing preservatives
No refined sugars or products
containing them - carbonated
soft drinks
Yeast and yeast containing foods

Permitted:
All vegetables, potatoes,
etc.(Salads
Chestnutso Rice (brown)
Beans (Mung, adzuki etc.-soak 6
hrs., cook in fresh water)
Soy dishes (seaweed: powdered
kelp, kombu, dulse, nori)
Egg yolk
Grain dishes - preferably
unrefined and low gluten (millet,
qulnOa, buckwheat)
Fruit (except citrus and melons) -
should be eaten before 12 pm-
noon.
Pineapple is permitted all day.
Chicken (white meat) and Fish
(only __ times per week)


As for Lyme down there, you'll find groups if you google it. I came across the following:

Myths surrounding Lyme Disease in Australia

(there is also a downloadable version of this list here)

- There is no Lyme Disease in Australia this is FALSE. The misconception that Lyme Disease does not exist in Australia is based on a study in 1994 by Russell and Doggett. There were numerous problems with this study and its methodology, which are the focus of an upcoming article in the Medical Journal of Australia. By contrast Willis was able to identify the bacteria that causes Lyme Disease in Australian ticks in 1995. In addition to this Carly and Pope found an Australian strain of Borrelia, Borrelia Queenslandica in 1962. A 1959 study by Mackerras isolated Borrelia on Australian fauna kangaroos, wallabies and bandicoots, this was also omitted. Adding to this is the fact that a large number of diagnosed Lyme Disease patients in Australia have never travelled out of Australia. More study desperately needs to be done on Lyme Disease in Australia.
 

redo

Senior Member
Messages
874
I'm starting to believe there is some sort of stomach pathogen (protozoa?) not showing up on testing as I no longer show up positive for blastocystis hominis, only "parasite present, taxonomy unknown" with metametrix.

I am actually beginning to think more and more in the direction that a stomach pathogen is at the core of this disease. Rather than having it's main reservoir in the intestines, I'd say it might be the stomach.

Many patients I have been in contact with improve with treatments somewhat similar to the Helicobacter pylori treatments (combination of antibiotics). H. pylori is thought to thrive more when the person is stressed. Perhaps a pathogen of the stomach could be trail. Would make sense with regards to how many get worse from certain foods, and how many who have used antibiotics relapse quickly when off (that's how other stomach pathogens have behaved).